Monday

15th Aug 2022

Opinion

Covid-19 - why didn't Europe's tracing apps work?

  • The German corona tracing app. Only 21 percent of potential users have downloaded it (Photo: Matthew Tempest)

Covid-19 vaccination has started - yet lifting restrictive measures will take time.

Monitoring of local outbreaks and contact tracing remain essential to avoid future lockdowns and permit larger gatherings. Regrettably, contact tracing apps were not successful in Europe.

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Become an expert on Europe

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

Automated contact tracing should still play an important role in reopening society, however using different technology and a different approach.

Earlier in 2020, we supported European efforts to better track Covid-19 contagion with the help of smartphone apps, but cautioned the technology's complexity and worried about Europe's country-by-country approach.

Now, we can ascertain that despite occasional progress the struggle continues.

Deployment and adoption of tracing apps remained below expectations, and high infection rates across Europe hindered large-scale contact tracing. Moreover, accelerating vaccination shifted focus from technical solutions for contact tracing.

It is important, however, that the high hopes in vaccination do not lead decision-makers to concentrate again on a single solution. It will take time to reach a critical mass of vaccinated citizens and the vaccines have yet to prove to what extent they protect us from infection and from being infectious.

A fast and safe recovery of our societies and economies necessitates a combination of restrictive measures, vaccination, testing and tracing; the latter requiring automated support.

EU attempts failed

Several European countries launched contact tracing apps already in early 2020, yet in a scattered approach to a problem that respects no national borders.

Two consortia of researchers, dominated by European players, worked on centralised and decentralised protocols to run tracing apps.

Unfortunately, EU countries could not agree on a single path, which turned out to hinder interoperability.

At the same time, in an unprecedented collaboration, US tech giants Apple and Google released in May 2020 a joint framework and protocol specification for contact tracing (GAEN).

Given the global dominance of their mobile phone operating systems, it was inevitable that most contact tracing apps would eventually build on GAEN from the outset or were reconfigured to be compatible.

To overcome fragmentation, the European Commission launched in September an interoperability gateway service, linking national apps across the EU.

Unfortunately, as of today, only 11 of 27 member states have registered with the service.

Contrary to early predictions that up to 85 percent of potential users would download contact-tracing apps, worldwide download rates have so far been much lower.

In Germany around 21 percent, in Italy 14 percent, in France the latest version TousAntiCovid is at 15 percent.

With about 40 percent, Iceland and early mover Singapore have the highest rates to date.

And downloading the app is not the same as using it or responding to warnings.

Root causes

So why have contact tracing apps not delivered what was expected of them?

Despite claims that users' privacy would be guaranteed, and even in cases where corona apps were rubber stamped as privacy protecting, concerns prevailed and uptake was dissatisfying.

Secondly, the idea of contact tracing focussed almost exclusively on fast deployment via smart phones.

Everyone has a smart phone – smart phones have Bluetooth – so let's go for apps, using Bluetooth technology. Essential aspects of privacy and ease-of-use were downplayed.

Finally, tracing apps were not well embedded in existing ecosystems to fight the pandemic. It is, for example, not helpful to have an app, if not enough testing facilities are in place, or if they are not easily accessible.

Automated contact tracing: lost cause?

To reopen public life, we need to combine the gradual release of restrictive measures like social distancing, remote working, or lockdowns with vaccination, intense testing, and fast contact tracing.

Automated contact tracing has particular relevance for larger gatherings like concerts or sports events. These will only be feasible if we closely monitor possible outbreaks and react fast to prevent substantial restrictions.

Unfortunately, contact tracing apps did not deliver.

The lessons learnt from their failure should be:

1. Privacy first, second and third

2. Simplicity, simplicity, simplicity.

3. Reliability.

4. Take an approach that works with limited but focussed use.

We therefore stressed the importance to consider alternative technologies, like physical tokens.

Tokens are a proven technology in logistics and have been deployed in Singapore to trace Covid-19 infections.

They only require minimal functionality for contact tracing, are small, robust, cheap, and consume little energy.

And their simplicity, single application, and the fact that they are not 'always on' allow for high levels of security and privacy protection. Tokens even work small scale if deployed to limited groups of people.

No download or installation are needed, no connection to personal data possible.

EIT Digital partners created ventures to test Covid-19 tracing tokens in real-life settings and to commercialise and deploy their products.

The tokens are built in Europe, operate on European software, and work independent of non-European (mobile) platforms. A tangible contribution to a more sovereign digital Europe.

We invite governments, businesses, sports and cultural sectors to apply tracing tokens for targeted use in schools, at workplaces, or for events. At this point, we must put all options on the table that could benefit a faster and safer return to a thriving economy and an open society.

Author bio

Willem Jonker is CEO of EIT Digital. an independent organisation supported by the European Institute of Innovation and Technology.

Disclaimer

The views expressed in this opinion piece are the author's, not those of EUobserver.

Vestager pushes tracing apps as key for summer holidays

The commissioner for the digital portfolio, Margrethe Vestager, warned that "without the technology, it will be very difficult to open [society] to the degree that we all want" - since new outbreaks might surge back until there is a vaccine.

EU must beware Beijing's new charm offensive

The EU needs to be clear eyed about China's new diplomatic charm offensive, as it's more likely driven by short-term necessity than any fundamental policy re-assessment.

Only Western unity can stop Iran hostage-diplomacy

The Belgian parliament's recent decision to ratify its prisoner-exchange treaty with Iran is a grave mistake, and one which exemplifies the many downfalls of dealing with Iran's human-rights abuses on a case-by-case basis.

Column

Global hunger crisis requires more than just the Odessa deal

International donors are playing hide and seek. Instead of stepping up their assistance programmes, richer nations are cutting overseas aid, or reallocating funds from other parts of the world towards the Ukraine crisis.

Exploiting the Ukraine crisis for Big Business

From food policy to climate change, corporate lobbyists are exploiting the Ukraine crisis to try to slash legislation that gets in the way of profit. But this is only making things worse.

News in Brief

  1. Germany to help nationals cope with energy price spike
  2. Germany wants pipeline from Portugal
  3. Ukraine urges US to sanction all Russian banks
  4. Spain evacuates 294 Afghans
  5. EU sanctions have 'limited' effect of Russian oil production
  6. Donors pledge €1.5bn to Ukraine's war effort
  7. Sweden overtakes France as EU's top power exporter
  8. Italy's far-right star in European charm offensive

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. EFBWW – EFBH – FETBBConstruction workers can check wages and working conditions in 36 countries
  2. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic and Canadian ministers join forces to combat harmful content online
  3. European Centre for Press and Media FreedomEuropean Anti-SLAPP Conference 2022
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic ministers write to EU about new food labelling
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersEmerging journalists from the Nordics and Canada report the facts of the climate crisis
  6. Council of the EUEU: new rules on corporate sustainability reporting

Latest News

  1. Defying Russian bombs, Ukraine football starts 2022 season
  2. Sweden to extradite man wanted by Turkey
  3. EU must beware Beijing's new charm offensive
  4. Forest fire near Bordeaux forces over 10,000 to flee
  5. Estonia and Latvia sever China club ties
  6. Russian coal embargo kicks in, as EU energy bills surge
  7. Only Western unity can stop Iran hostage-diplomacy
  8. Kosovo PM warns of renewed conflict with Serbia

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us