Tuesday

22nd Aug 2017

Investigation

Part VI: A circumstantial EU hanging

  • Kessler stands by the Olaf report (Photo: ec.europa.eu)

When Olaf chief Giovanni Kessler stood in front of the Brussels press corps on 17 October 2012 - the day after John Dalli lost his job - his message was not an easy one to sell.

He first said there is "no conclusive evidence of the direct participation of the commissioner,” in the attempt to solicit a bribe.

Thank you for reading EUobserver!

Subscribe now and get 40% off for an annual subscription. Sale ends soon.

  1. €90 per year. Use discount code EUOBS40%
  2. or €15 per month
  3. Cancel anytime

EUobserver is an independent, not-for-profit news organization that publishes daily news reports, analysis, and investigations from Brussels and the EU member states. We are an indispensable news source for anyone who wants to know what is going on in the EU.

We are mainly funded by advertising and subscription revenues. As advertising revenues are falling fast, we depend on subscription revenues to support our journalism.

For group, corporate or student subscriptions, please contact us. See also our full Terms of Use.

If you already have an account click here to login.

He then added, gripping the edge of the podium with his left hand as he read his statement, that there is “unambiguous and converging circumstantial evidence” that Dalli was aware of the attempted bribe.

Journalists, in a prior press briefing with EU commission spokesperson Pia Ahrenkilde Hansen, had already started giving the EU side a hard time.

"If someone makes an indecent proposal to you, as Swedish Match described it, is that really your fault unless you indicate that you are inclined to be indecent?" one reporter asked.

"What is the fault? Is it that he [Dalli] didn't actually denounce the attempt to the commission, to Barroso?" another one asked.

Hansen stonewalled.

She said only that the Olaf report had been handed over to Maltese authorities and that Dalli had resigned, leaving the journalists frustrated.

The media’s curiosity was piqued still further when Dalli, in a video-taped interview with New Europe later the same morning, refuted all the claims, noting that he had not even been allowed to see the Olaf report.

What more do you want?

At first glance, Olaf’s leaked report on the five-month investigation appears convincing.

It contains a heap of “circumstantial evidence”: witness statements; records of phone calls; the verbatim transcript of one wire-tapped conversation; corresponding emails and SMS-es; records of related meetings; and notes on the intertwined histories of the main protagonists.

It says Dalli first met tobacco lobbyists - BAT and Estoc’s Tomas Hammargren - in the swimming trunks encounter at the Kempinski in Malta on 20 August 2010.

It says he met lobbyists a second time - Gayle Kimberley and Silvio Zammit, who were now working for Swedish Match - at his own office in St Julians, Malta on 6 January 2012.

It says he was likely in contact with them a third time - via Zammit - at his private residence in Malta on 10 February 2012.

It also notes that there were numerous phone contacts between Dalli and the lobbyists before and after the 6 January and 10 February meetings.

Dalli and Zammit contacted each other 23 times between 5 January and 17 July 2012. When busy, Dalli would respond after a few seconds, multiplying the number of individual calls.

“They [the call logs] attest the frequency of the conversations of these two persons and also the fact they communicated at key stages of the illicit negotiation carried out by Mr Zammit,” the Olaf press office told this website.

Olaf says the logs, obtained by Maltese authorities, shows that at one point Zammit interrupted a call to a tobacco lobbyist, Inge Delfosse, called Dalli, then called Delfosse back.

In a transcript of the latter Delfosse call, Zammit asked her for a bribe.

“The logs also show that after being interviewed by Olaf, Mr Zammit called Mr Dalli”, the Olaf press office added.

Kimberley and Zammit themselves exchanged 20 phone calls and sent each other dozens of text messages between 13 February and 5 July 2012.

Meanwhile, Kimberley’s written report to Swedish Match on the 6 January meeting sounds damning.

“You will be glad to hear he [Dalli] has an open mind and is in no way pre-conditioned [against snus]”, she said.

“I think if any commissioner has what it takes to lift the ban it’s this one … I have direct access to the commissioner to send any emails or information we want passed to him.”

Her oral report to Swedish Match on the 10 February meeting sounds even more damning.

She says that she, Dalli, and Zammit on 10 February hatched the whole plan which led Zammit to later ask Swedish Match for the €60 million bribe.

She notes they talked about who to nominate in Dalli’s cabinet in order for the snus plan to go well, who Dalli’s “friends” are in the commission, Swedish Match’s annual profit, and how Dalli intends to proceed with the “snus ban and what does he need?”.

The Kimberley bombshell

But the Olaf report also records a huge discrepancy on the 10 February meeting at Dalli’s house.

Kimberley originally told Swedish Match she went to Dalli’s residence with Zammit.

But when questioned by Kessler at a meeting in Troia, Portugal, she told him she had lied to the Swedish firm, possibly in order to help secure her €5,000 consultancy fee.

She also told Kessler that her role was limited to helping Zammit prepare for the 10 February encounter with Dalli.

She said she gave the Peppi’s owner a paper entitled “Meeting with Commissioner” on the strategic plan of attack, which he returned to her later on 10 February, purportedly with his handwritten notes in the margins.

Olaf says the handwritten notes are proof that Zammit and Dalli did discuss snus on 10 February.

It noted that telephone calls were made on the same day between Zammit, Kimberley, and Swedish Match executive John Gabrielsson.

But Zammit’s responses to the questions in Kimberley’s paper make little sense.

Zammit, for instance, writes “France” next to the question: “Who are the friends of Dalli in the commission and what countries does he have a good relations with?”.

For Dalli to say France is an ally for lifting the snus ban is unlikely.

French diplomats and Dalli had in fact fallen out when Dalli approved the cultivation of genetically-modified potatoes in Europe by German chemical giant BASF.

The most likely pro-snus member states would be Sweden - whose ministers have long pushed for the sale ban to be lifted - and the UK, through its affiliations with British American Tobacco.

Olaf investigators also swept the marked up paper for Dalli’s fingerprints and found nothing.

So what really happened on 10 February?

Zammit and Dalli admit that they met, but they say they didn't discuss snus and talked instead about local politics.

Their version has some plausibility: Zammit was at the time running for local city council. He had in the past worked as a canvasser for Dalli and had been chosen by the Nationalist Party to stand for office in the town of Sliema.

Elections were less than a month away, in a campaign which saw Zammit grab the seat as deputy mayor on 11 March. Another 50 or so votes and he would have been mayor.

Grist to Dalli’s mill

Kimberley’s Olaf testimony also undermines the importance of the phone contacts.

She told Kessler that her phone calls and texts with Zammit had nothing to do with snus.

“Whenever I had a conversation with Silvio Zammit it was either non-snus related or about my introduction to BAT,” she said.

Her Olaf statements are grist to Dalli’s mill.

He claims he did not report the Hammargren meeting or the 6 January meeting at St Julians because he thought they were insignificant.

He notes that the Hammargren encounter looked like a coincidence and that Zammit, on 6 January, never told him that Kimberley was already working for Swedish Match.

Zammit defenders say if Kimberley was prepared to lie to Swedish Match about the 10 February meeting, then might she not have embellished her report on the 6 January encounter in order to impress the Swedish firm?

Dalli also told EUobserver that after 6 January “Silvio [Zammit] never came back to me with anything on this issue [snus]”.

Meanwhile, EUobserver has seen new evidence which suggests Kimberley was more deeply involved in the attempted bribe than she led the Olaf investigators to believe.

In this series of eight articles, EUobserver reporter Nikolaj Nielsen takes a closer look at events which, in the words of one MEP, will haunt Brussels for the next 10 years to come.

Introduction - EU smoke & mirrors

Part I - From Peppi's to Barroso's

Part II - Malta's 'Mr Teflon'

Part III - Actors assemble for EU melodrama

Part IV - EU judges, Maltese mysteries, and Christians in the Caribbean

Part V - Dalli’s big tobacco theory

Part VI - A circumstantial EU hanging

Part VII - €60mn Valentine's Day gift - will be published on Tuesday 11 November

Part V: Dalli’s big tobacco theory

John Dalli claims that his tough stand against tobacco as EU health commissioner led the industry to pull levers inside the European Commission to get him ousted from office.

Part III: Actors assemble for EU melodrama

The new EU health commissioner’s first known contact with a tobacco lobbyist was on 20 August 2010 at the five-star Kempinski Hotel on the Maltese island of Gozo.

Part II: Malta's 'Mr Teflon'

Part II of VIII: Prince William peers out of a black stretched luxury car as the vehicle turns down a street in Malta’s capital city, Valletta.

Part VII: €60mn Valentine's Day gift

While Silvio Zammit risks jail time and former EU health commission John Dalli is still under investigation, the witness to the prosecution, Gayle Kimberley, has largely escaped scrutiny.

Part VIII: A scandal 'for the next 10 years'

In her office on the 15th floor in the Altiero Spinelli wing of the European Parliament, German centre-right MEP Ingeborg Graessle shuffles some papers on a table and then pours two glasses of water.

EU smoke & mirrors

EUobserver reporter Nikolaj Nielsen sheds new light on the Dalli lobbying scandal, which, by Barroso's own admission, threatened to bring down the EU executive, but which is not over yet.

News in Brief

  1. Austria has begun checks at Italian border
  2. Slovenian PM: Brexit talks will take longer than expected
  3. Merkel backs diesel while report warns of economic harm
  4. UK to publish new Brexit papers this week
  5. Macedonia sacks top prosecutor over wiretap scandal
  6. ECB concerned stronger euro could derail economic recovery
  7. Mixed Irish reactions to post-Brexit border proposal
  8. European Union returns to 2 percent growth

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. European Jewish CongressEuropean Governments Must Take Stronger Action Against Terrorism
  2. European Healthy Lifestyle AllianceDoes Genetics Explain Why So Few of Us Have an Ideal Cardiovascular Health?
  3. EU2017EEFuture-Themed Digital Painting Competition Welcomes Artists - Deadline 31 Aug
  4. ACCABusinesses Must Grip Ethics and Trust in the Digital Age
  5. European Jewish CongressEJC Welcomes European Court of Justice's Decision to Keep Hamas on Terror List
  6. UNICEFReport: Children on the Move From Africa Do Not First Aim to Go to Europe
  7. Centre Maurits CoppietersWe Need Democratic and Transparent Free Trade Agreements Says MEP Jordi Solé
  8. Counter BalanceOut for Summer, Ep. 2: EIB Promoting Development in Egypt - At What Cost?
  9. EU2017EELocal Leaders Push for Local and Regional Targets to Address Climate Change
  10. European Healthy Lifestyle AllianceMore Women Than Men Have Died From Heart Disease in Past 30 Years
  11. European Jewish CongressJean-Marie Le Pen Faces Trial for Oven Comments About Jewish Singer
  12. ACCAAnnounces Belt & Road Research at Shanghai Conference

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. ECPAFood Waste in the Field Can Double Without Crop Protection. #WithOrWithout #Pesticides
  2. EU2017EEEstonia Allocates €1 Million to Alleviate Migratory Pressure From Libya in Italy
  3. Dialogue PlatformFethullah Gulen's Message on the Anniversary of the Coup Attempt in Turkey
  4. Martens CentreWeeding Out Fake News: An Approach to Social Media Regulation
  5. European Jewish CongressEJC Concerned by Normalisation of Antisemitic Tropes in Hungary
  6. Counter BalanceOut for Summer Ep. 1: How the EIB Sweeps a Development Fiasco Under the Rug
  7. CESICESI to Participate in Sectoral Social Dialogue Committee on Postal Services
  8. ILGA-EuropeMalta Keeps on Rocking: Marriage Equality on Its Way
  9. European Friends of ArmeniaEuFoA Director and MEPs Comment on the Recent Conflict Escalation in Nagorno-Karabakh
  10. EU2017EEEstonian Presidency Kicks off Youth Programme With Coding Summer School
  11. EPSUEP Support for Corporate Tax Transparency Principle Unlikely to Pass Reality Check
  12. Counter BalanceEuropean Parliament Improves the External Investment Plan but Significant Challenges Ahead