27th Nov 2021

EU advisors question ethics of cloned food

The European Commission's advisory group charged with consideration of ethics in science and technology has concluded that at present the production of cloned food cannot be justified.

The European Group on Ethics in Science and New Technology (EGE) said Thursday (17 January) that due to the level of suffering of the mothers into which a cloned embryo is placed and the health problems of the animal clones themselves, the group "has doubts as to whether cloning animals for food supply is ethically justified."

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Become an expert on Europe

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

  • The commission's scientific ethics advisory group is concerned about the welfare of cloned animals (Photo: Wikipedia)

Cloned animals are faced with a wide range of health problems, with a high death rate and a high incidence of disease.

Clones commonly suffer from premature ageing; enlarged tongues; squashed faces; intestinal blockages; immune deficiencies; diabetes; heart, lung and liver damage; kidney failure; and brain abnormalities.

Surrogate mothers are also burdened with significant suffering and a high death rate, in particular as a result of 'large-offspring syndrome'.

The EGE made the comments in a published opinion on the ethical aspects of animal cloning for food supply. The opinion is in stark contrast to the views of the European Food and Safety Agency (EFSA), which two days ago declared cloned food to be safe to eat or drink its own report on the subject.

The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) issued its own opinion on cloned food on Wednesday (16 January), also declaring cloned food safe for consumption.

Both the EFSA and EGE opinions had been requested by the commission months ago in response to announcements that the US FDA was to consider the issue of cloned food, said commission spokesperson Nina Papadoulaki.

"There's no conspiracy. It's just an odd coincidence," she added, referring to the close timing of the US and EU opinions.

When asked about the disagreement between the two groups, Ms Papadoulaki, said that there was no problem – the commission would go away and consider the two opinions.

"It's a sort of mathematics: EFSA plus EGE equals risk assessment; the commission equals risk management."

Biodiversity concerns

In a nuanced consideration of the controversial issue, the ethics group said that while "at present, the EGE does not see convincing arguments to justify the production of food from clones and their offspring," if in the future cloned animals were to be introduced to the European market, a series of stringent demands would first have to be met.

The cloning of animals would have to accord with norms of animal welfare, and the animals would have to meet current EU traceability legislation requirements.

The EGE further recommended that the commission take proper measures to preserve farm animal biodiversity, a key concern regarding cloning.

According to Eurogroup for Animals, a federation of European animal welfare advocates, cloning would greatly reduce genetic diversity within livestock populations, increasing the chances of whole herds being wiped out by disease.

Additionally, in the event that cloned food is allowed into Europe, the EGE calls for a system of labelling.

The ethics group said that although compliance with World Trade Organisations provisions may complicate decisions on cloned food, the commission must ensure consumer rights.

The EGE is an independent body composed of fifteen experts appointed by the commission for their ethical expertise. Members represent a broad range of disciplines such as biology and genetics, medicine, pharmacology, agricultural sciences, ICTs, law, ethics, philosophy, and theology.

The task of the group is to examine ethical questions arising from science and new technologies and then issue opinions to the commission.

MEPs call for workers to have 'right to disconnect'

MEPs called for a new law guaranteeing workers can 'disconnect' outside work hours, without repercussion. But they also passed a last-minute amendment, calling on the commission to delay any legislation for three years.

EU rolls out vaccine, as UK-variant spreads

Most EU member states began rolling out the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine against Covid-19 on Sunday, as a more contagious variant from the UK begins to spread on the continent.

News in Brief

  1. Covid variant: EU to block travel from southern Africa
  2. France and UK seek EU help on Channel migrants
  3. New Swedish PM who resigned after 7 hours gets second chance
  4. Belgium to decide on Friday on Covid measures
  5. UK rings alarm on new Covid strain in South Africa
  6. Turkish police use tear gas at women's rights march
  7. Poland calls for more Nato troops
  8. Ex-Navalny aide leaves Russia


Sweden's non-lockdown didn't work - why not?

The Swedish king would have been better advised to use his annual Christmas interview to call for unity of purpose and shed light on the political roots of the country's response.


BioNTech: Stop talking about their 'migration background'

I understand that the German-Turkish community - often subjected to condescension in Germany - celebrated the story. Uğur Şahin and Özlem Türecki represent scientific excellence and business success at the highest level.

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Nordic Council of MinistersNew report reveals bad environmental habits
  2. Nordic Council of MinistersImproving the integration of young refugees
  3. Nordic Council of MinistersNATO Secretary General guest at the Session of the Nordic Council
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersCan you love whoever you want in care homes?
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersNineteen demands by Nordic young people to save biodiversity
  6. Nordic Council of MinistersSustainable public procurement is an effective way to achieve global goals

Latest News

  1. Belgium goes into three-week 'lockdown light'
  2. MEPs list crimes of 'Kremlin proxy' mercenaries
  3. EU to open up 'black box' of political ads
  4. Can the ECB solve climate change and inflation on its own?
  5. EU set to limit vaccine certificate to nine months
  6. Surprise coalition in Romania without former Renew's Ciolos
  7. This 'Black Friday' is a turning point in corporate accountability
  8. West struggling to show strength on Ukraine

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us