Thursday

27th Jan 2022

ECJ told to dismiss Poland and Hungary rule-of-law challenge

  • Poland's prime minister Mateusz Morawiecki (l) and Hungarian prime minister Viktor Orbán at a previous EU summit (Photo: Council of the European Union)
Listen to article

The EU's highest court should dismiss a challenge by Poland and Hungary against a new tool aimed at suspending funds for member state governments that break the bloc's rule-of-law principles, an advisor to the court said on Thursday (2 December).

Advocate general Manuel Campos Sanchez-Bordona said in his opinion that the "court should dismiss the actions for annulment brought by Hungary and by Poland".

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Become an expert on Europe

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

While this opinion is non-binding, the Luxembourg-based European Court of Justice (ECJ) usually follows the advice in its final ruling. The ruling in this case is expected in early 2022.

Hungary and Poland have argued that the new and highly-fought over mechanism that links EU funds to the rule of law is too vague, and goes beyond what the EU treaties allow for the bloc.

The advocate general said, however, that the conditionality mechanism does not indent to replicate the Article 7 sanctions procedure based on the EU treaty, but "rather to establish a financial conditionality instrument to safeguard that value" of the EU.

The governments in Warsaw and Budapest both immediately criticised the advocate general's opinion.

"It was a naivety to trust EU institutions would be capable of self-restraint," Poland's deputy justice minister, Sebastian Kaleta said.

Hungary's justice minister Judit Varga argued in a Facebook post that the opinion "ignores" that the conditionality regulation has several "obvious legal errors", which would already justify its annulment.

"Its legal basis is incorrect, it bypasses the treaties, and violates the rule-of-law requirements, especially the principles of legal certainty and clarity," Varga wrote, calling for scrapping the new tool.

"We say no to blackmail the rule of law!", she wrote.

Clearing the way

A ruling, in line with the opinion, would clear the way for the EU Commission to launch the mechanism against Poland and Hungary. It has been reluctant to trigger the new tool before a court ruling.

The EU executive have sent letters last month to the two countries asking questions on specific rule-of-law concerns.

Liberal Dutch MEP Sophie in't Veld said that the claims of Hungarian prime minister Viktor Orbán and Polish prime minister Mateusz Morawiecki against such conditionality are "bogus".

"[EU Commission president Ursula] von der Leyen has run out of excuses for not applying it. Except for a lack of political courage, of course," she tweeted.

The European Parliament has taken steps to sue the commission for failing to act on the regulation which was adopted by legislators a year ago and came into force in January 2021.

Slovak liberal MEP Michal Simecka said Orbán and Morawiecki "play for time. "The EU Commission should finally put an end to the delay and 'ostrich' politics," he tweeted.

The conditionality mechanism was last year hailed as a long-awaited effective tool for the EU Commission to clamp down on governments that repeatedly breach EU rules and values.

The EU executive has struggled for years to discipline the two countries. The Article 7 probe is already under way against both Poland and Hungary, but failed to produce tangible results.

In the meantime, the commission has also withheld the approval of the two countries' national Covid-19 economic recovery plans, blocking payments from the EU's €800bn recovery fund.

Polish rule-of-law debate boils over to EU summit

The summit discussion comes after the EU Commission president Ursula von der Leyen said this week the bloc's executive will take action against Warsaw, for challenging the supremacy of EU law.

EU orders Poland to pay €70m in fines

The case is one of many disputes between the EU and Poland's ruling Law and Justice (PiS) party, which have started to cost money for Warsaw.

€70m deadline dawns on fines in Polish rule-of-law row

Poland is facing a deadline on Tuesday to spell out to the EU Commission how it wants to bring its domestic judicial reforms into line with the order from the European Court of Justice on how Warsaw disciplines judges.

Feature

15 years on: How are Bulgaria and Romania doing in the EU?

The latest European Commission health report puts the pair of south-eastern EU accession states last in terms of the overall lifespan of their citizens. Romanians and Bulgarian now die even younger than before.

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us