Thursday

3rd Dec 2020

Opinion

EU charting the wrong course in migration policy

  • The EU is said to measure the success of its efforts with the reducing number of people crossing the Mediterranean. (Photo: Alessandro Rota/Oxfam)

It is the International Day of Peace on Thursday (21 September) and this year, the theme of the global initiative is 'respect, safety and dignity for all'.

These principles should be the cornerstone of the EU's approach to migration and displacement.

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Become an expert on Europe

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

However, a review of EU interventions along the Central Mediterranean route highlights that this is far from being the case.

European officials have faced strong criticism for prioritising security interests over the rights of vulnerable people, in their efforts to stem migration flows.

In particular, many perceive the EU, which measures the success of its efforts in the reduced number of people crossing the Mediterranean, to be guilty of hypocrisy as it claims that its efforts are informed by "strong policies to protect human rights and ensure dignified living conditions for migrants in countries of transit".

But the reality is that migrants are trapped in appalling conditions.

Border control

The EU and its member states have been impelled to work with problematic partner governments in order to 'do something' about migration. Particularly, the main approach has been to reinforce the capacity of priority countries - like Libya, Niger and Chad - to control their borders and, as such, control Europe's.

Nevertheless, this kind of support not only overlooks the role that these regimes play in pushing people out in the first place, but also the manner in which they deal with migrants and refugees on their territory.

Notably, the EU is supporting the UN-backed Government of National Accord (GNA) in Libya to enhance its control over the country's northern and southern borders.

However, the horrendous way in which migrants, refugees and asylum-seekers - and those seeking to help them - are being treated has led many to condemn the EU for outsourcing its 'dirty work' to Libyan authorities.

In this context, the EU must think strategically about how it provides security support to governments.

While there is a real need to improve security provision in these countries, the focus should be on security sector reform to ensure that security services are responsive to people's needs and are held to account when abuses are committed.

By contrast, the reliance on 'train and equip' programmes risks further militarising contexts that are characterised by weak and abusive governance.

In Niger, for instance, national authorities have increased controls on migrant flows under EU pressure.

It has since been reported that smugglers have driven up their fees in response to rising operating prices, which include 'lavish' bribes paid to security forces. This has caused anger among local communities, whose livelihoods depend so much on border crossing that it risks causing tensions with the security sector.

And it could be complicated further, as the different security forces operating in the region are also competing over migratory proceeds, in part to complement their low incomes.

Empowering militias

The risk of militarisation is also being reinforced by the empowerment of militias as proxy border guards.

At the apparent prospect of financial support from European countries, cross-border Saharan tribes have agreed to form a border force to stop migrants from reaching Europe. But there is a clear risk of unaccountable and unsupervised actors committing abuses against people on the move.

Moreover, in some cases, these tribes run the very smuggling networks that the EU is trying to stop, and thus the defence they provide against illicit migration may amount to little more than a protection racket.

This illustrates the need for the EU to root its engagement in a sound understanding of the contexts it is operating in. And this is particularly important, as migration is perceived very differently in third countries compared to how it is at EU level.

In the Sahel for instance, migration is very much part of life in the African region, and freedom of movement is guaranteed across the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS).

As such, many individuals who depend on the industry surrounding migratory flows view the introduction of anti-smuggling regulations as designed to destroy their livelihoods.

Enhanced controls could therefore have a negative impact on what has traditionally been perceived as a stabilising factor in the region, where marginalised youth have notably been vulnerable to recruitment into violent groups.

And while the EU and others are also supporting livelihood and resilience programmes, this will not be sufficient to counteract the other factors driving instability and migration, and may even contribute to enhancing the means of those set on reaching Europe.

In view of such concerns, it is important that the EU acts on some of the criticisms levelled at its migration policy.

Not everything the EU is doing is off the mark, but interventions meant to produce 'quick wins' on the security front, even if allegedly designed "in full respect of [EU] humanitarian and human rights obligations" often prove counter-productive - robbing refugees, asylum-seekers and migrants of the respect, safety and dignity to which they, as human beings, have a right.

Instead, the EU needs coherent, long-term strategies that support peace, justice, inclusion and prosperity for all.

Kloe Tricot O'Farrell is EU policy and advocacy coordinator for Saferworld, an international NGO working to prevent conflict and build safer lives.

Disclaimer

The views expressed in this opinion piece are the author's, not those of EUobserver.

EU to step up migrant returns

After Juncker's state of the union speech, the EU Commission is set to propose many new measures on migration before the end of the year, with an emphasis on returns, legal routes, and "solidarity" with African states.

Smugglers test migrant Black Sea route to Romania

Several hundred migrants and asylum seekers have arrived from Turkey to Romania in the past few weeks. Frontex, the EU's border agency, says the spike does not mean the route is reopening.

EU accused of complicity in Libya migrant abuse

Medecins Sans Frontieres International says European governments are contributing to "the manufacturing of suffering at an industrial level" in Libyan detention centres.

News in Brief

  1. Valéry Giscard d'Estaing dies from Covid-19 complications
  2. Belgium expelled 15,000 EU nationals in recent years
  3. Centre-right EU lawmakers want to kick out Fidesz MEP
  4. Slovak journalist's killer gets longer sentence
  5. Egyptian leader embarks on 'execution spree'
  6. Covid-19: UK first to approve Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine
  7. Car kills five people in German town's pedestrian zone
  8. UK warns no-deal Brexit still possible

The human cost of whistleblowing

The fate of Jonathan Taylor, a British whistleblower stuck in legal limbo in Croatia, is a test of European laws designed to protect those who put themselves at risk for the common good.

EU vs US tech agenda under Biden

What will the new Joe Biden administration bring to the realm of digital policy, and how will it affect the relationship with the EU?

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Nordic Council of MinistersJoin the Nordic climate debate on 17 November!
  2. UNESDAMaking healthier diets the easy choice
  3. Nordic Council of MinistersUN Secretary General to meet with Nordic Council on COVID-19
  4. UNESDAWell-designed Deposit Return Schemes can help reach Single-Use Plastics Directive targets
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic Council meets Belarusian opposition leader Svetlana Tichanovskaja
  6. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic Region to invest DKK 250 million in green digitalised business sector

Latest News

  1. EU keen to repair damage of Trump years
  2. Szájer 'sex party' coverage shows Orbán's media control
  3. EU commission mulls ways round Hungary-Poland block
  4. Revealed: Hit to EU mental health services during Covid-19
  5. MEPs seek parliament inquiry into Frontex
  6. Erdoğan to face human rights scrutiny next week, EU says
  7. 2020 Prague European Summit: 'Real solutions, acting together'
  8. Nationwide protests reveal awakening of Poland's youth

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us