Monday

21st Aug 2017

Italy referendum could have surprising consequences

  • Renzi is well-capable of U-turns (Photo: governo.it)

As Italy enters the final week of campaigning for its 4 December constitutional referendum, all bets are off on the outcome, but beware of easy assumptions.

A defeat for prime minister Matteo Renzi will not necessarily pave the way for the anti-establishment, anti-euro Five Star Movement (M5S) to take power, and a victory might be a short-lived success for the centre-left leader.

Thank you for reading EUobserver!

Subscribe now and get 40% off for an annual subscription. Sale ends soon.

  1. €90 per year. Use discount code EUOBS40%
  2. or €15 per month
  3. Cancel anytime

EUobserver is an independent, not-for-profit news organization that publishes daily news reports, analysis, and investigations from Brussels and the EU member states. We are an indispensable news source for anyone who wants to know what is going on in the EU.

We are mainly funded by advertising and subscription revenues. As advertising revenues are falling fast, we depend on subscription revenues to support our journalism.

For group, corporate or student subscriptions, please contact us. See also our full Terms of Use.

If you already have an account click here to login.

  • Grillo called on voters to give Renzi a "slap" (Photo: kbytesys)

The referendum hinges on reforms that clip the powers of the upper chamber of parliament and of regional administrations to the benefit of the national government. The aim is to give steadier governance to Italy, a country that has had 63 executives and 27 prime ministers since it emerged from fascist rule and became a republic in 1946.

Renzi is the chief sponsor of the changes and has tied his political future to them.

Having promised to resign in case of a referendum defeat, he has galvanised his critics into turning up at the polls to cast No votes, transforming the campaign into a love-him-or-hate-him plebiscite on his nearly three years in government.

"We have to slap him in the face," M5S leader Beppe Grillo, a former comedian, said at a rally in Rome on Saturday (26 November). "Trust your gut and not your brain … look at [Renzi and his allies] in the face and then vote," he said.

The M5S and other No campaigners are battling against the proposed reforms also on the grounds that they undermine checks and balances, especially when considered alongside a new election law that guarantees safe majorities in the lower chamber of parliament.

Paradoxically, it is precisely such a set up that could most easily produce a Grillo victory in a general election.

The so-called Italicum election law allocates 55 percent of parliamentary seats to any party that secures at least 40 percent of the vote, or comes out top in a second round ballot. According to pollsters, Renzi’s Democratic Party (PD) and the M5S would be most likely to square off in a second round if an election was held today and M5S would be favourites to win.

A Yes outcome would be a short-term triumph for Renzi, who is almost alone against a No campaign that features not just all the opposition parties, but also some PD dissidents.

“This outcome may … allow the Five Star Movement to grab more power in any future election,” Daniele Antonucci, an analyst at the Morgan Stanley investment bank, said in a paper on 14 November.

Erik F. Nielsen, chief economist of Italy’s UniCredit bank, said on 20 November that a No vote would be “a setback for Renzi, but it’ll have nothing in common with the Brexit or Trump stories. Indeed, it’ll put additional space between reality and the Five Star Movement - and that’s good for Italy”.

Troubling prospect

The prospect of M5S winning power in Italy, the eurozone’s third-largest economy and the eighth-biggest in the world, is troubling for financial markets and mainstream policymakers.

The party’s agenda includes a referendum on Italy’s eurozone membership, a renegotiation of Italy’s gargantuan public debt, an end to sanctions against Russia, and a rejection of free trade deals with the US and Canada.

Risk indicators on Italian government bonds have already surged to a five-month high and the central bank said on 18 November it expected “a big increase in volatility” on financial markets as the referendum date nears.

Meanwhile, recapitalisation plans for two major banks - Monte dei Paschi di Siena (MPS) and UniCredit - are on hold as potential foreign investors want to see the referendum outcome before committing their money.

"I don't know if it will be useful to Renzi if I say that I hope for a Yes win. I will only say that I hope that the ‘No' will not win," European Commission president Jean-Claude Juncker told Sunday’s La Stampa newspaper, echoing endorsements made by outgoing US president Barack Obama and by business leaders, such as Fiat-Chrysler boss Sergio Marchionne.

Polls are banned in the final two weeks of campaigning, but before the curfew was enforced, all surveys predicted a defeat for Renzi, with the important qualifier that a high number of undecided voters could swing the result.

In any case, poll-based forecasts were proven resoundingly wrong in previous Italian votes.

Speaking at a campaign event in Turin on Sunday, Renzi said that he would be “doomed” if only PD voters followed his advice.

“We would [lose by] 35 to 65 percent,” he said. “It’s a difficult game of course, but many people outside of the PD long for a simpler, more stable country,” he added, aiming to pick up support across party lines.

Promises, promises

If defeated, Renzi is expected to make good on the promise to step down. President Sergio Mattarella would have the task of cobbling together a new government, whose priority would be changing election rules once again, because under a No win scenario Italy would be left with conflicting voting procedures for the upper and lower chambers of parliament.

Renzi would be down, but not necessarily out.

If he were to lose by a respectable margin - say by 45-55 or 47-53 percent - he could still claim to represent almost half of the country and could capitalise on that result to consolidate his grip on the PD and prepare for the next general elections, due by 2018 at the latest.

“In other words, after Renzi, there could be yet more Renzi,” says David Allegranti, a journalist and biographer of the former Florence mayor.

Such a scenario would require Renzi to forfeit his original pledge, made 11 months ago, not only to leave the prime ministerial post, but also to quit politics altogether.

He is well capable of U-turns, however.

Renzi is the man who said in January 2014 that he had no intention of becoming prime minister, just weeks before taking over the top job from party colleague Enrico Letta, in a deft palace coup.

EU 'finance ministry' pardons Italy and Spain

Italy, Portugal, and Spain are unlikely to face sanctions for breaking EU budget rules, the European Commission has said, in what it described as a “political” decision by a kind of “common finance ministry”.

Analysis

Renzi's EU attacks are survival strategy

Faced with a difficult referendum campaign, the Italian prime minister is playing the antiestablishment card, including verbal attacks on the EU and Germany.

Countdown to Italy's future

The long-running campaign for Sunday's referendum has wrapped up, but market jitters and the rise of euroscepticism risks Italy's shaky post-recession growth.

Italy referendum spooks eurozone

Prime minister Matteo Renzi's resignation, followed by a crushing rejection of his reforms, has sent the euro plunging against the dollar and put the country's fragile banking system at risk.

Spain prepares to stop Catalan vote

Spanish prime minister Mariano Rajoy has said he is ready call an extraordinary cabinet meeting if Catalonia's authorities table a bill to organise the vote on 1 October.

News in Brief

  1. Austria has begun checks at Italian border
  2. Slovenian PM: Brexit talks will take longer than expected
  3. Merkel backs diesel while report warns of economic harm
  4. UK to publish new Brexit papers this week
  5. Macedonia sacks top prosecutor over wiretap scandal
  6. ECB concerned stronger euro could derail economic recovery
  7. Mixed Irish reactions to post-Brexit border proposal
  8. European Union returns to 2 percent growth

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. European Jewish CongressEuropean Governments Must Take Stronger Action Against Terrorism
  2. European Healthy Lifestyle AllianceDoes Genetics Explain Why So Few of Us Have an Ideal Cardiovascular Health?
  3. EU2017EEFuture-Themed Digital Painting Competition Welcomes Artists - Deadline 31 Aug
  4. ACCABusinesses Must Grip Ethics and Trust in the Digital Age
  5. European Jewish CongressEJC Welcomes European Court of Justice's Decision to Keep Hamas on Terror List
  6. UNICEFReport: Children on the Move From Africa Do Not First Aim to Go to Europe
  7. Centre Maurits CoppietersWe Need Democratic and Transparent Free Trade Agreements Says MEP Jordi Solé
  8. Counter BalanceOut for Summer, Ep. 2: EIB Promoting Development in Egypt - At What Cost?
  9. EU2017EELocal Leaders Push for Local and Regional Targets to Address Climate Change
  10. European Healthy Lifestyle AllianceMore Women Than Men Have Died From Heart Disease in Past 30 Years
  11. European Jewish CongressJean-Marie Le Pen Faces Trial for Oven Comments About Jewish Singer
  12. ACCAAnnounces Belt & Road Research at Shanghai Conference

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. ECPAFood Waste in the Field Can Double Without Crop Protection. #WithOrWithout #Pesticides
  2. EU2017EEEstonia Allocates €1 Million to Alleviate Migratory Pressure From Libya in Italy
  3. Dialogue PlatformFethullah Gulen's Message on the Anniversary of the Coup Attempt in Turkey
  4. Martens CentreWeeding Out Fake News: An Approach to Social Media Regulation
  5. European Jewish CongressEJC Concerned by Normalisation of Antisemitic Tropes in Hungary
  6. Counter BalanceOut for Summer Ep. 1: How the EIB Sweeps a Development Fiasco Under the Rug
  7. CESICESI to Participate in Sectoral Social Dialogue Committee on Postal Services
  8. ILGA-EuropeMalta Keeps on Rocking: Marriage Equality on Its Way
  9. European Friends of ArmeniaEuFoA Director and MEPs Comment on the Recent Conflict Escalation in Nagorno-Karabakh
  10. EU2017EEEstonian Presidency Kicks off Youth Programme With Coding Summer School
  11. EPSUEP Support for Corporate Tax Transparency Principle Unlikely to Pass Reality Check
  12. Counter BalanceEuropean Parliament Improves the External Investment Plan but Significant Challenges Ahead