Saturday

17th Apr 2021

Economic control hangs in the balance

The European Court of Justice in Luxembourg will on Tuesday (13 July) hand down what may be the most significant ruling in its 46 year history.

The case may not sound like much (Judgement C-27/04 Commission v Council), but at stake is who is in control of the EU economy - Brussels or member states.

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Become an expert on Europe

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

The European Commission took the Council of member states to court over its decision in November to suspend disciplinary procedures against France and Germany for repeatedly breaking EU economic rules.

Brussels had recommended that France and Germany take measures to bring their budget deficits below the maximum EU permitted level of three percent of gross domestic product (GDP).

But Paris and Berlin persuaded enough of their colleagues to vote down these recommendations and place the procedure "in abeyance", effectively killing off the rules that underpin the euro.

The Commission argues that the Council had no right to suspend the procedure it recommended - a disciplinary procedure that could result in fines of billions of euro.

But the Council maintains that the final decision rests with member states.

What happens if...

Whichever side wins, there are serious consequences for decision-making in the EU economic sphere.

If the Commission wins and the Court decides that the member states had no right to suspend the disciplinary procedure, then it could annul the member states' declaration and the member states would have to go back to the Commission's recommendations to France and Germany that they suspended in the first place.

"We would be back to where we started", says Guillaume Durand, an expert on economic governance at the European Policy Centre in Brussels.

"But as the same people would be around the table, it is hard to see why there would be a difference".

If the procedure were to be re-started and carried through to its conclusion, Germany and France - who this year will have exceeded the limit for three consecutive years - could in theory next year face fines of up to 0.5 percent of their GDP.

If these fines were indeed dished out, Germany would face a sanction of just under 10 billion euro and France could expect a fine of just over seven billion.

In practice, though, few analysts believe the fines would ever actually be levied.

Death to the pact

However, France and Germany are not the only member states currently in breach of the rules. The Netherlands, Greece and Italy all have deficits over three percent of GDP and could face similar punishment.

If the Court decides that the member states acted within their legal rights to suspend the procedure, it effectively buries all claims from the Commission to be the supervisor of EU economic policy.

And with another huge row brewing between member states and the Commission over the EU budget for 2007-2013, it would give EU capitals the upper hand in an ongoing power struggle.

Power struggle

Some analysts believe that winning this power battle is more important than the actual implications of the result. Mr Durand says that the case is "a largely symbolic issue" and that the row is really about control.

"It's more for the Commission to show the Council that they can not just do what they want", he says.

And Jorgen Mortensen, an expert at the Centre for European Studies argues in a recent paper that the crisis over the economic rules, "brought into the open a conflict that had been brewing ever since the creation of the EEC in 1958: the sharing of competences for macroeconomic policy-making between the national governments and the EU institutions".

Neither side involved in the case was prepared to speculate on what implications the result might have.

A spokesman for the EU Presidency said, "we will have a reaction tomorrow" and a Commission spokesman said that he would not like to comment on "hypothetical questions".

Institutions grapple for EU economic control

Legal teams from the European Commission and the Council of Member States battled head-to-head at the European Court in Luxembourg today (28 April) in a bid to retain supremacy over EU economic policy.

Date set for crucial euro pact ruling

The European Court of Justice on Monday announced that it would reveal on 13 July its judgement regarding the row between the Commission and member states over the rules that underpin the euro.

Brussels wins crucial court case over euro rules

France and Germany are again facing the prospect of record fines after the European Court of Justice today overturned a decision suspending infringement procedures against them.

News in Brief

  1. EU postpones decision on labelling gas 'sustainable'
  2. MEPs call for mass surveillance ban in EU public spaces
  3. Greek and Turkish ministers trade jibes in Ankara
  4. Biden repeats opposition to Russia-Germany pipeline
  5. Navalny in danger, letter warns EU foreign ministers
  6. Lithuania keen to use Denmark's AstraZeneca vaccines
  7. Gas plants largest source of power-sector emissions
  8. Study: Higher risk of blood clots from Covid than vaccines

Vietnam jails journalist critical of EU trade deal

A journalist who had demanded the EU postpone its trade deal with Vietnam until human rights improved has been sentenced to 15 years in jail. The EU Commission says it first needs to conduct a detailed analysis before responding.

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Nordic Council of MinistersDigitalisation can help us pick up the green pace
  2. Nordic Council of MinistersCOVID19 is a wake-up call in the fight against antibiotic resistance
  3. Nordic Council of MinistersThe Nordic Region can and should play a leading role in Europe’s digital development
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic Council to host EU webinars on energy, digitalisation and antibiotic resistance
  5. UNESDAEU Code of Conduct can showcase PPPs delivering healthier more sustainable society
  6. Nordic Council of MinistersWomen benefit in the digitalised labour market

Latest News

  1. US rejects Slovenia-linked plan to break up Bosnia
  2. Ukraine urges Borrell to visit Russia front line
  3. Could US sanctions hit Russia vaccine sales to EU?
  4. Polish court pushes out critical ombudsman
  5. Political crises in Romania and Bulgaria amid third wave
  6. Von der Leyen's summer plans undisclosed, after Ukraine snub
  7. Over a million EU citizens back farm-animal cage ban
  8. Three options for West on Putin's Ukraine build-up

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us