Wednesday

16th Jun 2021

Analysis

Commission bets on states to make farm policy 'green'

  • 'The commission's plans offer almost no protection for health, the environment and climate,' said NGO Greenpeace in response (Photo: Stijn te Strake)

The European Commission is leaving it up to member states to propose how much greenhouse gas reductions the EU's agricultural sector should achieve during the next EU budget period (2021-2027).

It is giving national governments the freedom to come up with their own 'strategic plans' in which they explain how they will achieve the overarching European goals of the common agriculture policy (CAP).

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Become an expert on Europe

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

However, the common climate goals are worded so broadly that there is no assurance that the EU will indeed end up with climate action that is in line with the 2015 global 'Paris agreement' on climate.

The 'EU specific objective' on climate that the commission laid down in the annex to a legislative proposal, presented on Friday (1 June), said: "Contribute to climate change mitigation and adaptation, as well as sustainable energy".

The 'impact indicators' through which that objective should be achieved, said that greenhouse gas emissions from agriculture should be reduced, but not by how much.

That means that the actual efforts the 27 EU member states will not be known until they have submitted their national plans for the first year of the new CAP regime, 2021.

A commission source who briefed journalists about the proposal - on condition of anonymity - said on Friday that member states had an overall commitment to reduce greenhouse gases.

That will be taken into account when the commission assesses the strategic plans, the source said, noting that the commission will have to approve the plans.

"Clearly member states have to demonstrate their higher level of ambition. So when they submit their strategic plans, their level of ambition has to be higher than what they are today," said the commission official.

But again, that does not guarantee that the aggregate of member state plans will contain enough ambition to help the EU reduce emissions in line with 'Paris'.

The goal of the Paris agreement is to limit global warming, which is already at 1.1C above the pre-industrial average, to 1.5C if possible, but definitely below 2C.

There are 2030 reduction targets for each EU member state for ammonia emissions, which are almost exclusively produced by the agriculture sector.

Ammonia, however, has mostly negative consequences on the environment, like decreased biodiversity and acid deposition.

More important in the context of climate change is methane, a powerful greenhouse gas.

Over half of all methane emissions in the EU come from agriculture. However the EU has no specific reduction targets for methane.

The commission said on Friday that 40 percent of the CAP's €365bn budget was "expected to contribute to climate action".

However, the commission source briefing journalists conceded that this was only an estimate, and that it would depend on the measures which member states were expected to propose in their national plans.

One novelty from the CAP will be that member states will be required to offer voluntary "eco-schemes" that benefit the environment and climate.

"The whole idea and the logic of the eco-schemes, which are flexible, is to allow people to make the transition from a more conventional type of agriculture to the one that moves into more environmental practices," said the commission source.

Here again, the commission will leave it to member states to define what constitutes as "agricultural practices beneficial for the climate and the environment".

Heavy criticism from NGOs

Environmental groups are very sceptical.

Greenpeace released a statement saying the new CAP proposal "could spell disaster for [the] environment".

"The new CAP proposal gives national governments the responsibility to define national agriculture plans, but does not set the safeguards necessary to ensure that these plans protect public health, the environment and the climate," the environmental lobby group said.

"The commission's plans offer almost no protection for health, the environment and climate," it added.

Another group, Birdlife, also criticised the lack of guarantees.

"The reform pins all its hopes to achieve EU objectives on wishful thinking, assuming that member states will pursue public over vested interests," it said.

"Nature cannot survive another decade of intensive agriculture, so MEPs and agriculture ministers need to wake up and make the CAP another reason for citizens to believe in the EU project," it added.

MEPs and agriculture ministers will need to agree with the proposal before it can become law.

Opinion

The risks behind the 'green bond' boom

The EU should not overuse the financial system in order to achieve environmental goals, or it risks the emergence of a green bond bubble which would be detrimental to the financial sector and hinder the achievement of climate targets.

Opinion

Nordic and Baltic farmers urgently need EU support

Drought is causing severe problems for farmers in the Nordic region and the Baltic countries. This is the third year in a row that the region has experienced extreme weather conditions, pushing farmers' financial situation to a breaking point.

News in Brief

  1. China calls Nato statement 'slander'
  2. Israel bombs Gaza after Hamas responds to far-right march
  3. Kosovo and Serbia resume EU-brokered talks
  4. IKEA fined €1m for spying on French employees
  5. Markets snap up €20bn of new EU recovery bonds
  6. German court to test European Defence Fund legality
  7. Climate crisis may hit Europe's coffee and chocolate imports
  8. EU top court affirms national data watchdogs' power

EU faces long wait for full vaccine supplies

The EU is still several months away from having enough vaccines to inoculate its 450 million people, with Pfizer and BioNTech, its principle suppliers, aiming for September for delivery targets.

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Nordic Council of MinistersNineteen demands by Nordic young people to save biodiversity
  2. Nordic Council of MinistersSustainable public procurement is an effective way to achieve global goals
  3. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic Council enters into formal relations with European Parliament
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersWomen more active in violent extremist circles than first assumed
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersDigitalisation can help us pick up the green pace
  6. Nordic Council of MinistersCOVID19 is a wake-up call in the fight against antibiotic resistance

Latest News

  1. EU and US make peace on trade before Russia summit
  2. Hungary passes anti-LGBTIQ bill ahead of 2022 election
  3. Prisoners, homeless, migrants, 'overlooked' in EU vaccine race
  4. EU must treat homeless as rights-holders, not criminals
  5. China officially joins Russia as a danger to Nato
  6. German Greens face reality check amid CDU gains
  7. EU Parliament wants Europe to take lead on sea-rescues
  8. MEPs urged to end gas-funding, fix cross-border projects rules

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us