Sunday

1st Oct 2023

Air data ruling could affect data retention law dispute

  • The data retention law would mean internet and telephone data would be stored for between six and 24 months (Photo: EUobserver)

The legal verdict against Brussels' competencies on the transfer of passenger data to the US is likely to boost opponents of another contentious issue – the bloc's disputed data retention issue.

The European Court of Justice (ECJ) on Tuesday (30 May) announced that an EU-US agreement from 2004 regulating the handover of air passenger data to US security authorities lacked an "appropriate legal basis."

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Become an expert on Europe

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

The top court ruled that the handing over such information falls under member states' criminal law legislation, and not under EU scope.

The verdict comes only a week after Dublin announced that Ireland had started a legal challenge to test the judicial bearing of the recent EU data retention directive, which also concerns the processing of possibly sensitive personal data.

An EU official in Brussels told the EUobserver that although Dublin had not publicly made a link between the two EU data deals, a lot of people believe there is a strong thread linking them.

"It would be hard to deny that there is connection between the two," the official said.

The data retention directive aims at harmonising law in all 25 EU member states to help police keep tabs on criminals and terrorists via phone and internet records, obliging member states to store internet and telephone data for six to 24 months.

The directive was opposed by Ireland and Slovakia when it was adopted by member states in February, with Dublin contesting the law on legal grounds similar to Tuesday's ruling - that national security is a matter for member states and not the EU.

Both laws were passed by a procedure whereby member states acted on a proposal by the European Commission under the so-called "first pillar" of EU decision making - a practice rejected by the court on air passengers.

First pillar decisions are made by majority voting between member state governments, with a necessary consent by a majority of the European Parliament, but security-related justice decisions are usually made under the so-called third pillar, where unanimous consent by member states is necessary and parliament can only issue an opinion.

Civil rights activists bide their time

Tuesday's air data transfer verdict may also serve claims that the data processing practice is violating EU basic privacy rights.

Liberal MEP and member of the parliament's civil liberties committee Alexander Alvaro told EUobserver that although the cases were "similar but not identical", it would most probably be used to set a precedent on future court decisions where the judicial bearing is unclear.

"We are now waiting for the member states implementation of the (data) directive, meaning national courts may also challenge the legislation, with the German high court likely to question very strongly if this is in line with its constitution," the German MEP said.

The European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS), which earlier supported civil rights advocates within the parliament, said Tuesday's judgment was important as it addresses the scope of the data protection directive, notably when it comes to interaction with law enforcement.

The EDPS said, however, that the civil rights aspect of the agreement should have been dealt with by the court, not only on whose table the law should lie.

"The judgment seems to have created a loophole in the protection of European citizens whereby their data are used for law enforcement purposes," Peter Hustinx of the EDPS said.

A commission spokesperson said that the air data ruling had moved the matter from a first pillar decision back to the third pillar- where member states have a veto.

"This ruling may confirm the commission's intention to apply the "passerelle" (footbridge to transfer powers from member states to Brussels) and shift policies in the area of police and criminal justice cooperation," the spokesperson said.

EU and US struggle to avoid air travel chaos

The European Union and the United States are still negotiating a deal on air passenger data transfers in an attempt to avoid a "legal chaos" despite a "temporary break down" on Saturday night, EU officials said.

Column

Will Poles vote for the end of democracy?

International media must make clear that these are not fair, democratic elections. The flawed race should be the story at least as much as the race itself.

Opinion

Orbán's 'revenge law' is an Orwellian crackdown on education

On Tuesday, the Hungarian parliament passed a troubling piece of legislation known by its critics as the 'revenge law', which aims to punish and intimidate teachers who dare to defy Viktor Orbán's regime. This law is a brutally oppressive tool.

Latest News

  1. EU women promised new dawn under anti-violence pact
  2. Three steps EU can take to halt Azerbaijan's mafia-style bullying
  3. Punish Belarus too for aiding Putin's Ukraine war
  4. Added-value for Russia diamond ban, as G7 and EU prepare sanctions
  5. EU states to agree on asylum crisis bill, say EU officials
  6. Poland's culture of fear after three years of abortion 'ban'
  7. Time for a reset: EU regional funding needs overhauling
  8. Germany tightens police checks on Czech and Polish border

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Nordic Council of MinistersThe Nordic Region is stepping up its efforts to reduce food waste
  2. International Medical Devices Regulators Forum (IMDRF)Join regulators, industry & healthcare experts at the 24th IMDRF session, September 25-26, Berlin. Register by 20 Sept to join in person or online.
  3. UNOPSUNOPS begins works under EU-funded project to repair schools in Ukraine
  4. Georgia Ministry of Foreign AffairsGeorgia effectively prevents sanctions evasion against Russia – confirm EU, UK, USA
  5. International Medical Devices Regulators Forum (IMDRF)Join regulators & industry experts at the 24th IMDRF session- Berlin September 25-26. Register early for discounted hotel rates
  6. Nordic Council of MinistersGlobal interest in the new Nordic Nutrition Recommendations – here are the speakers for the launch

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Nordic Council of Ministers20 June: Launch of the new Nordic Nutrition Recommendations
  2. International Sustainable Finance CentreJoin CEE Sustainable Finance Summit, 15 – 19 May 2023, high-level event for finance & business
  3. ICLEISeven actionable measures to make food procurement in Europe more sustainable
  4. World BankWorld Bank Report Highlights Role of Human Development for a Successful Green Transition in Europe
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic summit to step up the fight against food loss and waste
  6. Nordic Council of MinistersThink-tank: Strengthen co-operation around tech giants’ influence in the Nordics

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us