25th Oct 2021

Labelling gas as 'green' clashes with EU law, NGO says

  • The taxonomy was designed to address so-called greenwashing in financial markets, but experts now fear that it might end up becoming a greenwashing tool itself (Photo: European Parliament)
Listen to article

Environmental lawyers from NGO ClientEarth have warned the European Commission that labelling some types of natural gas facilities as "green" investments in its upcoming sustainable finance rules would clash with EU laws and international commitments.

The EU unveiled, last April, its so-called Taxonomy Regulation - a classification system of economic activities considered as an "environmentally sustainable investment," which aims to push private capital into transition projects.

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Become an expert on Europe

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

But it postponed a separate decision on whether to classify gas and nuclear as a green investment, now expected this autumn.

As the date draws nearer, ClientEarth's lawyers urged the EU executive to exclude all types of gas industries from the regulation, pointing out the risk of creating incentives for additional gas-fired power generation in times of severe climate change.

Labelling some types of natural gas facilities as "green" would be "in total contradiction with the commitments undertaken by the European Commission both at international and EU level," they said in a letter sent to EU climate commissioner Frans Timmermans last Thursday (7 October).

Such a decision would be at odds with the EU's obligations under the 2015 Paris Agreement and the commitments under the EU climate law, they said, as well as the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, which requires the EU to "pursue a high degree of environmental protection and international cooperation to combat climate change".

Natural gas also failed to fulfil the requirements of the EU 'taxonomy' itself, ClientEarth added, because the regulation explicitly says green activities must "contribute substantially to the stabilisation of greenhouse gas emissions at a level that prevents dangerous climate change" and have no low-carbon alternative.

This classification system was designed to address greenwashing in financial markets, but experts now fear that it might end up becoming a greenwashing tool itself.

"Labelling gas as sustainable is misleading and only encourages further greenwashing by industry players. Doing so will only pave the way for yet another era of fossil fuels, as opposed to clean and efficient energy," said Marta Toporek, a lawyer at ClientEarth.

"Gas is a fossil fuel - classifying it as environmentally sustainable is not only absurd, it's also unlawful. The European Union cannot keep its climate promises and give gas a free pass at the same time," she added.

Earlier this year, a leak of the EU Commission's proposal revealed that some gas plants that generated power and also provided heating or cooling could be deemed as a "sustainable", under certain conditions.

For example, the green label would apply to new co-generation gas plants if they stopped also burning coal and oil, leading to a cut of emissions of at least 50 percent per kWh of energy.

But experts have urged Brussels to resist political pressure from EU capitals and gas lobbyists and listen to science.

Meanwhile, EU member states remain divided on the role of gas in cutting emissions.

A number of countries is not willing to approve the overall architecture of the taxonomy, until they review the upcoming proposal on gas and nuclear - calling into question whether rules can start applying from 1 January 2022, as proposed initially by Brussels.

A majority of EU countries or the European Parliament could object and revoke the decision.

A European Commission spokesperson said they had received ClientEarth's letter and would respond "in due time".

EU defers decision on gas and nuclear as 'green' energy

The European Commission has laid out rules classifying industrial logging and the burning of trees and crops for energy as 'sustainable' investments. Decisions on whether to also list gas and nuclear energy as 'sustainable' investments will be made later.

Experts threaten to quit over new EU 'green finance' rules

Nine members of the expert group advising the European Commission on sustainable finance rules say criteria for gas, forestry and bioenergy are "a clear contradiction to climate science" - threatening to step down if lobbying and politics prevail over science.

EU reaches deal to define 'sustainable' investment

The agreement is the first step to set a framework for sustainable finance, that will help investors and consumers to identify economic activities that can unambiguously be considered environmentally green.

Gas price spike exposes rift at EU summit

The first topic leaders discussed at the EU summit were the continent's soaring gas prices, which have lead to a spike in household energy bills - amid widespread disagreement on how to solve the issue.

EU vows to uphold Paris climate ambition amid scientists' fears

EU leaders called for an "ambitious global response to climate change" to keep the 1.5 degrees global warming limit within reach - after scientists concluded that the projected global increase in fossil-fuel production for 2030 is inconsistent with this target.

News in Brief

  1. Russia's anti-vax campaign backfired, EU says
  2. China angered as MEPs call for Taiwan talks
  3. Emissions from La Palma volcano reach Brussels
  4. Body of eighth victim of Belarus border-crisis found in river
  5. Report: Syrian bank fiddling currency to evade EU sanctions
  6. Nato adopts plan to counter new Russian threats
  7. Alleged killer of British MP 'felt affiliated' to IS
  8. Coronavirus: Belgium returns to 'red' zone

More countries join EU and US-led methane pledge

Two dozen countries have joined the US-and EU-led initiative to reduce global methane emissions, as momentum builds ahead of the UN climate change conference in Glasgow. Delivering on this pledge could reduce global warming by 0.2 degrees by 2050.

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Nordic Council of MinistersNew report reveals bad environmental habits
  2. Nordic Council of MinistersImproving the integration of young refugees
  3. Nordic Council of MinistersNATO Secretary General guest at the Session of the Nordic Council
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersCan you love whoever you want in care homes?
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersNineteen demands by Nordic young people to save biodiversity
  6. Nordic Council of MinistersSustainable public procurement is an effective way to achieve global goals

Latest News

  1. EU states want more Belarus sanctions
  2. Gas price spike exposes rift at EU summit
  3. Poland vows not to give into EU 'blackmail' at summit
  4. EU vows to uphold Paris climate ambition amid scientists' fears
  5. Commissions's new migration pact still seeking 'landing zone'
  6. Europe can't ignore Chinese encroachment in Ukraine
  7. Lithuania - where 'biodiversity funding' is cutting down trees
  8. Dutch lawyers take Frontex to EU court over pushbacks

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us