Thursday

28th Jan 2021

Analysis

'Corona Orientalism': nothing to learn from the East?

  • It is 'Orientalist' to believe that Europe cannot learn from Asia - where some countries have tackled the coronavirus efficiently (Photo: Wikipedia)

The 14th century Renaissance poet Petrarch detested modern medicine. The reason? It was introduced in Europe by the Arabs.

Petrarch refused to listen to the advice of "modern" physicians because "nothing good can come from those Arabs."

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Become an expert on Europe

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

He wrote this at the time of the bubonic plague that killed 30 percent of the European population. The Arab idea of ​​quarantine was only applied to a limited extent.

Unfortunately for Petrarch, one of the plague's victims was his own son.

In today's corona times, we hear echoes of Petrarch's words. We read everywhere about "lessons from Italy" but rarely if ever about "lessons from South Korea".

However, the curve of South Korea, a neighbouring country of China, is spectacular.

South Korea, a country with 51 million citizens, was able to limit the number of cases to 10,000, while Italy, with 60 million inhabitants, has hit 180,000 infection cases, and is only now hoping for improvement.

The reason why South Korea has been able to curb the pandemic quickly is because they started testing quickly and massively. Any South Korean could get tested in car parks, a kind of 'drive-in' test, after which they were told whether they should go to hospital, quarantine, or home if healthy.

In addition, sanitisers were made available everywhere in public places, while everyone was urged to wear mouth masks.

It is true, of course, that some of the measures are seen by many as a serious invasion of privacy. The government developed apps that could show people how far they were from infected fellow citizens. That can only work if the infected people have it marked on their phone.

Also, in Wuhan, the Chinese city where the virus may have arisen, people could only enter shops (when the lockdown was lifted), after they had shown on their phone that they were not (no longer) infected.

One can be for or against these apps or other drastic measures taken in some Asian countries.

But it cannot be denied that a country like South Korea, plus also some other Asian states, so far have successfully tackled the corona crisis. Yet these countries and their success stories hardly get any credit in talk shows or articles on the current pandemic.

Moreover, the arguments are quite hallucinatory: 'Asians live in dictatorships, are naturally more obedient to the government and don't care about freedom and privacy'.

All this, of course, in contrast to democratic and freedom-loving Europe. The fact that South Korea is not a dictatorship but a democracy is just a detail.

American-Palestinian intellectual Edward Said called this attitude "Orientalism" in his eponymous 1978 book. Said described how Europeans look down on 'the East' as undeveloped people, unable to govern or represent themselves and thus needing European civilisation in order to progress.

Orientalism is a combination of a European feeling of superiority, born from 19th century European hegemony, with a poignant lack of actual interest in what "the Orientals" have to say. His thesis sparked much controversy, and led to the creation of a new scientific research field, Post-Colonial Studies, with the aim of adjusting to the Orientalist discourse.

But that turns out to be a difficult task.

Moreover, it looks like Orientalism has mutated in recent months to Corona Orientalism.

Western 'complacency'?

Former Singapore ambassador to the UN, Kishore Mahbubane, put rubbed salt into the wound in some recent interviews. He called the West complacent and said this was the cause of the late European response to the pandemic.

Mahbubane said it is still inconceivable for many Europeans that there could be something to be learned from some east Asian countries. As an example, he cited the financial crisis of 2008-2009. In the 1990s, a similar crisis hit Asia, which learned lessons from it. But Europe simply ignored those lessons in its response to its own crisis.

And we are not even talking about education, where Asian countries lead the rankings, in mathematics, science and even in reading skills.

In fairness, we have to say that in the past few days articles have started to appear in a number of Western newspapers on what lessons we can draw from Asia regarding the coronavirus.

This reporting is very important, even for virologists.

In an online media debate organised by the World Economic Forum a virologist said last week he gets a lot of information from the media about successes and failures of other countries.

But unfortunately, very little is written about the second wave in Japan, or the third wave in Taiwan, and how it was handled.

As editor-in-chief of EUobserver, I must admit that we too are underreporting this. Because there is too little interest in news from the East due to 'Corona Orientalism', we simply write too little about it and we make it more difficult for the medical and political world to make the right decisions.

In short, this is not an indictment of certain experts, politicians or journalists, let alone a criticism of individuals.

Rather, it is a call for Europeans to abandon our deep-seated and simply wrong sense of superiority over the East.

Today (like yesterday) there are lessons to be learned about how a number of Eastern countries are tackling this corona crisis. We also have to drop our bipolar world view à la Petrarch; the idea of ​​the free, rational West against the authoritarian, emotional East that focuses mainly on wisdom rather than science.

This is a global pandemic that we will only be able to stop if we look, think and find solutions globally.

Column

Saving Europe from corona's nasty geopolitics

Four months into the corona crisis and one month into the social and economic shutdown, it seems the big geopolitical loser of the pandemic is likely going to be Europe.

Infographic

Why coronavirus numbers tell complex stories

Numbers appear precise, but can also be unintentionally misleading when it comes to the pandemic, as experts warned that worldwide data is difficult to compare.

Europe's dilemma: to follow Asian 'exit strategies' or not?

Several Asian countries have seen the coronavirus surge back after easing restrictions - despite their initial success in restraining the outbreak. As a result, EU member states maybe starting to loosen restrictions without having a 'concrete' example to learn from.

Column

Some lessons from Ibsen's An Enemy of the People

Theatres are dusting off a 19th century play: Ibsen's An Enemy of the People. It is about truth, freedom and tyranny. It deals with the loner versus the group, the role of the elite and the power of the majority.

EU launches funding drive for Covid-19 vaccine

The European Commission launches on Monday an initiative to raise €7.5bn to speed up the development of vaccines, treatment and testing capacity, ensuring that is equally "available to everyone and at affordable prices" and avoiding nationalisms.

News in Brief

  1. Putin holds out olive branch to Europe
  2. US snatched Russian anti-air system from Libya warlord
  3. UK to extradite alleged trafficker to EU despite Brexit
  4. EU puts trust in Boeing 737s after post-crash ban
  5. EU animal-export trade under harsh spotlight
  6. City of London wants to set rules for EU
  7. MEPs want 2030 targets to reduce consumption footprint
  8. Coronavirus cases worldwide pass 100m

Opinion

Together Europe can beat pandemics, Alzheimer's, cancer

Let's expand the EU with a Health Union where cutting edge research and world-class applications go hand in hand. For this, it is worth being European, believing in Europe, working on Europe, writes European People's Party leader Manfred Weber MEP.

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. UNESDAEU Code of Conduct can showcase PPPs delivering healthier more sustainable society
  2. CESIKlaus Heeger and Romain Wolff re-elected Secretary General and President of independent trade unions in Europe (CESI)
  3. Nordic Council of MinistersWomen benefit in the digitalised labour market
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersReport: The prevalence of men who use internet forums characterised by misogyny
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersJoin the Nordic climate debate on 17 November!
  6. UNESDAMaking healthier diets the easy choice

Latest News

  1. Poland imposes anti-abortion law amid EU concern
  2. The EU's vaccine strategy - the key points
  3. EU-AstraZeneca row flares up after vaccines shortfall
  4. First Covid, now McKinsey - how austerity hit EU healthcare
  5. Frontex suspends operations in Hungary
  6. Cyprus: a heavy caseload for new EU prosecutors office
  7. MEPs: Portugal 'risks undermining' trust in EU prosecutor
  8. EU to control vaccine exports in row over delays

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us