Friday

29th Sep 2023

Polish judiciary on trial in EU top court

  • The ECJ's grand chamber will hear the commission, Ireland, Poland, and several other member states in the case (Photo: Court of Justice of the European Union)

The European Court of Justice (ECJ) will hold a hearing on Friday (1 June) on a case that could be a make or break the EU's efforts to uphold rule of law in the bloc.

The 17-member grand chamber in Luxembourg will hear arguments spelling out whether Poland's judiciary has been compromised after an Irish high court judge in March refused to extradite a suspected drugs offender to Poland due to concerns about the integrity of the Polish justice system.

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Become an expert on Europe

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

Justice Aileen Donnelly referred the case of Polish Artur Celmer, arrested on drugs charges in Ireland last year, to the ECJ because the recent changes in the Polish judicial system had been "so immense" that Ireland's high court had been forced to conclude that the rule of law in Poland had been "systematically damaged" and the "mutual trust" underpinning the European arrest warrant process had been compromised.

The European Commission, last December, launched the so-called Article 7 procedure against Poland.

The unprecedented sanctions process could see Poland punished for putting its judiciary under political control.

Dialogue between Brussels and the Polish government has been bumpy and the commission has given Warsaw until the end of June to comply with the EU executive's recommendations by rolling back some of the changes.

If it does not, fellow member states could decide to impose the sanctions the commission proposed.

The commission has been using the argument that safeguarding rule of law and the independence of the courts is crucial because a breach in one EU country has an effect on the union as a whole.

Courts are interdependent by upholding EU law in justice cooperation and internal market issues.

If the ECJ rules that Poland's judiciary has indeed been compromised, it would not only be a damning verdict on Warsaw's overhaul of the courts, it also could add fuel the commission's arguments.

However, the ECJ could also take a more narrow view and focus only on Celmer's case, without answering the broader question on the situation in Poland.

The Irish Times reported on Thursday (31 May) that Ireland will make the case that the Polish man would get a fair trail if deported to Poland and that the commission will back that argument.

"This is a make or break moment for the ECJ to play a decisive role in the Polish rule of law situation," Laurent Pech, professor of European law at Middlesex University told EUobserver, adding that it was very difficult to predict which route the court will take.

One of the worst scenarios for Warsaw would be that all European arrest warrants coming from Poland would be stopped and that other EU mechanisms based on "mutual trust" would halt as well.

If the ECJ's summer ruling tackles the wider concerns regarding Poland's judiciary, it "could reinforce the European Commission's negotiating power in the Article 7 discussions or could weaken it, if it says there is no issue in Poland," Pech added.

Meanwhile, Warsaw chose a combative approach.

Pro-government Polish media ran personal attacks on the Irish judge.

Mariusz Muszynski, vice-president of Poland's constitutional tribunal, whose appointment has been disputed accused the ECJ of political, pro-EU bias and of over-interpreting EU law.

"This 'guardian of the Treaties' violates the rule of law itself," he wrote.

The Polish government has already had run-ins with the EU's top court, as it hasignored a previous ECJ ruling to stop logging at the country's primeval Bialowieza forest.

Pech said the ruling comes at an important time, and could help prevent other countries backsliding on rule of law issues.

Hungary's nationalist government, which has a two-thirds majority in parliament, earlier in the week tabled a constitutional amendment calling for the establishment of so-called administrative courts that could pave the way for loyalist judges to rule on politically sensitive issues.

In Romania, the constitutional court, in a controversial ruling on Thursday, limited the president's powers and gave the justice minister, a political appointee, more control over prosecutors.

After Friday's hearing, the ECJ's advocate general will issue an opinion and the chamber is expected to rule before mid-July because the case has an "expedited" status as the Polish drugs suspect is currently in custody.

Poland, Hungary push back at EU budget 'conditionality'

EU affairs ministers held their first discussion on the Commission's long-term post-Brexit budget plans - with cohesion and agriculture cuts, phasing put rebates, and the overall size emerging as major divisions.

Poland defends judicial reforms, warns against EU pressure

Prime minister Mateusz Morawiecki presented the Commission with 94-pages of arguments backing Warsaw's controversial judicial reforms - while his EU minister warns that constant conflict with Brussels could stoke anti-European sentiment.

Dutch refuse Polish arrest warrant over judicial fears

A court in Amsterdam has questioned the independence of the Polish judiciary - turning down a Polish request for a European arrest warrant over fears that the suspect would not a get a fair trial in Poland.

Poland urged to halt 'purge' of top court

Next month Supreme Court judges could be removed in Poland - due to a controversial reform seen as a judicial purge by a government that wants to control the courts. The European Commission wants Warsaw to act now.

Opinion

How do you make embarrassing EU documents 'disappear'?

The EU Commission's new magic formula for avoiding scrutiny is simple. You declare the documents in question to be "short-lived correspondence for a preliminary exchange of views" and thus exempt them from being logged in the official inventory.

Column

Will Poles vote for the end of democracy?

International media must make clear that these are not fair, democratic elections. The flawed race should be the story at least as much as the race itself.

Latest News

  1. Added-value for Russia diamond ban, as G7 and EU prepare sanctions
  2. EU states to agree on asylum crisis bill, say EU officials
  3. Poland's culture of fear after three years of abortion 'ban'
  4. Time for a reset: EU regional funding needs overhauling
  5. Germany tightens police checks on Czech and Polish border
  6. EU Ombudsman warns of 'new normal' of crisis decision-making
  7. How do you make embarrassing EU documents 'disappear'?
  8. Resurgent Fico hopes for Slovak comeback at Saturday's election

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. International Medical Devices Regulators Forum (IMDRF)Join regulators, industry & healthcare experts at the 24th IMDRF session, September 25-26, Berlin. Register by 20 Sept to join in person or online.
  2. UNOPSUNOPS begins works under EU-funded project to repair schools in Ukraine
  3. Georgia Ministry of Foreign AffairsGeorgia effectively prevents sanctions evasion against Russia – confirm EU, UK, USA
  4. International Medical Devices Regulators Forum (IMDRF)Join regulators & industry experts at the 24th IMDRF session- Berlin September 25-26. Register early for discounted hotel rates
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersGlobal interest in the new Nordic Nutrition Recommendations – here are the speakers for the launch
  6. Nordic Council of Ministers20 June: Launch of the new Nordic Nutrition Recommendations

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. International Sustainable Finance CentreJoin CEE Sustainable Finance Summit, 15 – 19 May 2023, high-level event for finance & business
  2. ICLEISeven actionable measures to make food procurement in Europe more sustainable
  3. World BankWorld Bank Report Highlights Role of Human Development for a Successful Green Transition in Europe
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic summit to step up the fight against food loss and waste
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersThink-tank: Strengthen co-operation around tech giants’ influence in the Nordics
  6. EFBWWEFBWW calls for the EC to stop exploitation in subcontracting chains

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us