Friday

19th Apr 2019

Analysis

From Solana to Mogherini: What did Ashton really do?

  • Ashton: a technocrat who served EU countries' small ambitions (Photo: state.gov)

When world powers and Iran clinched a deal in nuclear talks in Geneva in the small hours of 23 November 2013, US secretary of state John Kerry gave the credit to the EU’s first-ever high representative for foreign affairs and security policy, Catherine Ashton, with a theatrical hug.

She had just chaired four days of meetings on one of the world’s toughest foreign policy dossiers.

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Support quality EU news

Get instant access to all articles — and 18 year's of archives. 30 days free trial.

... or join as a group

But an Iranian official, speaking to the Israeli newspaper Haaretz, gave a less flattering account of her role in the talks: “She knows how to create a pleasant and practical atmosphere … [But] it’s quite clear that there is no genuine political power behind her. She has to go to consult with the representatives of the world powers on every minor detail. Nobody is under the illusion that she has any authority to decide on her own. She is no more than a liaison, and at that she is very effective".

The Iran moment captures Ashton in a nutshell: excessive praise for a technocrat who served big countries’ small ambitions for EU foreign policy.

The nuclear deal came after several months of secret Iranian–US diplomacy and after EU states joined the US in imposing crippling sanctions on Iran.

Ashton mastered the issues and had the stamina and good grace to act as a go-between, but no more.

The banality of her contribution was on show in the cautious, procedural nature of her press briefings and in her spokesmen’s updates: “EU high rep Ashton begins bilateral meeting … E3/EU+3 held internal co-ordination meeting after morning bilats. now further bilats and technical experts meetings”.

Her two other triumphs – building the EU External Action Service (EEAS) and brokering the 2013 Kosovo–Serbia accord – also merit a critical look.

Her defenders say she made the EEAS out of thin air using a few paragraphs in the Lisbon Treaty.

But, in fact, it was her predecessor as EU foreign policy chief, Javier Solana, who, with no treaty mandate, marshalled EU countries to create the bricks which Ashton put together.

Solana, a former Nato secretary general, forged a foreign policy cell in the EU Council and launched the EU’s first peacekeeping missions.

He also formed the Political and Security Committee, the European Defence Agency, the EU Military Committee and IntCen – the EU’s intelligence-sharing unit.

The EEAS that Ashton built comprises three buildings in Brussels – which house 1,500 of the best-paid people in the EU institutions – and 140 “embassies” (former European Commission “delegations”), with 2,000 more staff.

It has no control over its policy. But this isn't just because EU states hold vetoes.

It is also because Ashton didn't update Solana’s 2003 European Security Strategy or draft her own “strategic framework” paper.

The old security strategy discusses Iraq War-type issues, such as weapons of mass destruction, but says nothing of new, Ashton-era threats, such as foreign fighters, Russian resurgence, or cyberwarfare.

The lack of a strategic framework paper – a blueprint for the EEAS’ role in any given crisis – forced Ashton to negotiate division of labour with EU states in an ad hoc way as events unfolded.

The EEAS also has little control over its own budget, which is signed off in its minutiae by the commission.

It is known for its ghastly bureaucracy and for Ashton’s nervous leadership.

The EEAS chief ordained 23 separate reporting lines to her office; her people took at least four days to validate any official document; they took at least a month to clear any spending proposal.

She routinely filed agendas or option papers at the 11th hour before foreign ministers’ meetings because she feared her ideas would be shot down if EU capitals had time to read them.

Her micro-management also caused waste: Her decision to personally interview all of her new ambassadors saw candidates fly to Brussels on 114 separate occasions only to be told that she was too busy to meet them.

When, in April 2013, Ashton unveiled the Kosovo–Serbia accord it prompted the first wave of Kerry-type endorsements. But the real architects of the deal were German chancellor Angela Merkel and an unsung EEAS official – Fernando Gentilini, an Italian in charge of Ashton’s Western Balkans department.

Merkel travelled to Belgrade in 2011, before the Kosovo–Serbia talks began, to deliver the message there would be no EU enlargement without peace.

Merkel’s officials also went back and forth to Serbia three or four times a year in parallel with Ashton’s talks.

For all of her skill in creating a “pleasant and practical atmosphere”, it was Gentilini who hammered out the details of the final compromise.

No political power

The picture that emerges is that Ashton’s critics – who said from the beginning that the 58-year old British politician lacked the executive and foreign relations experience to fill Solana’s shoes – were right.

Iran, the EEAS, and Kosovo aside, Ashton’s five years in the job also coincided with two of the biggest crises in a generation: the Arab upheavals and Russia’s war on Ukraine.

When crises escalate, big EU countries put aside EU institutions because only states with armies have the hard power to project their influence.

But Solana had the personal qualities to give his post what the Iranian official in Haaretz called “political power”.

In 2001, his interventions helped to end Albanian uprisings in Serbia and Macedonia and to persuade the then Israeli leader Ariel Sharon to make a truce with Palestine's Yasser Arafat.

In 2003, a Solana phone call to the then Moldovan leader halted the signature of the Kozak Memorandum – a blueprint for Russian domination.

The next year he was at the roundtable in Kiev negotiating former president Leonid Kuchma’s surrender to Viktor Yushchenko, the country's first post-Orange Revolution leader.

By contrast, Ashton failed to make a mark.

She tried to intervene on the Arab-Israeli conflict, on Libya, and on Egypt.

She decided in her first days in office that her EU legacy would be a breakthrough in the Middle East Peace Process. But she shelved the project when it became clear this is a US domain.

When EU countries met in the run-up to Western air strikes on Libya in 2011, Ashton, who disliked the idea, instructed her spokesman to tell media that France and the UK were isolated.

But British PM David Cameron, who got wind of it, scolded her in front of EU leaders, and Ashton later fired her man for his “rogue briefing” to save face.

She met more times with Egypt’s Mohammed Morsi, and his successor Abdel Fattah al-Sisi, than any other foreign statesman.

But EU diplomats who attended her debriefings say they sounded as hollow as the EEAS updates on Iran. “She told us she met with this or that person, or that the meeting lasted this or that amount of time, but she brought nothing new to the discussion”, a diplomat on the EU Council’s Mashreq/Maghreb Working Party told EUobserver in 2013.

Ashton left Ukraine to the EU's former neighbourhood commissioner Stefan Fule.

When events began heating up late last year, she travelled to Kiev. But when sniper killings on the Maidan in February threatened to provoke a bloodbath, three EU foreign ministers pushed Ashton aside to hold talks with the then Ukrainian president Viktor Yanukovych.

When Russia subsequently invaded Ukraine, Ashton’s role shrank further still to reading out ministers’ conclusions in Brussels.

No hard power

Meanwhile, if the EU lacks hard power, Ashton did nothing with the Lisbon clause on “the progressive framing of a common defence policy that might lead to a common defence”.

France, Germany, and the UK have little genuine interest in creating EU military capabilities alongside Nato.

Their uninterest was matched by that of Ashton, a former anti-nuclear campaigner, who felt more at home with humanitarian and civilian initiatives.

On a day-to-day level, she neglected EU defence ministers, the more than 200 seconded officers in the EU military staff, and IntCen.

The EEAS also earned a reputation for security lapses: Her staff walked from building to building with classified files in their bags, breaking protocol, for lack of secure IT systems.

They signed huge private security contracts, as in Afghanistan, with dodgy firms which were unable to do the job.

Ashton’s uninterest was also visible at the highest level.

EU leaders in December 2013 tasked her with making plans for “pooling and sharing” military resources.

But when Solana, who is now head of Madariaga, a Spanish foundation, asked delegates at the 2014 Munich Security Conference if there had been any follow-up, no one replied. “I take your silence as my response”, he said.

Ashton’s appointment, in 2009, was sold as an answer to the apocryphal question: “Who do I call if I want to call Europe?”. But another question is: Do people listen if Europe calls?

Her spokesmen say she avoided the press limelight out of modesty. But her decision to take up the EU role despite her unsuitability was an act of vanity.

She should have said: “Thanks, but no thanks”.

Mogherini: Another vacuum?

The same might be said of Italy’s Federica Mogherini, who was chosen as Ashton’s successor in August.

With even less experience than Ashton, she is a further step down from Solana.

Mogherini’s first decision in the run-up to her formal appointment was to say she would move her office from the EEAS building back to the commission HQ, leaving behind an empty space.

The move reflects Italy's ambition to have its commissioner closer to the centre of power in the EU capital.

It reflects the fragility and dependency of the EU diplomatic corps five years after its creation.

The empty office might also be a symbol of another vacuum at the top.

A version of this text was first published by Rusi, a London-based defence think tank

Rome continues to push Italian FM to replace Ashton

Rome is continuing to push Italian foreign minister Federica Mogherini to be the next EU foreign policy chief, despite opposition based on her experience and her country's perceived pro-Russia stance.

Ashton looks to closer EU ties on Iran visit

EU foreign affairs chief Catherine Ashton has offered to work more closely with Iran on human rights and drugs trafficking on her first visit to the country.

Letter

An unfair critique of Ashton

Brilliant individuals can occasionally work miracles; but teamwork, and the people and organisation that make it happen, are also indispensable.

Magazine

Europe in Review 2014

EUobserver, in its second annual review, looks back at the main events of 2014: Russia's annexation of Ukraine; the selection of the EU's new top cadre; separatism in Europe and more. Order your copy here.

EU migrants sneaking into US from Mexico

Almost 1,000 Romanian nationals were caught trying to sneak into the United States in 2017, of which around half attempted to cross via Mexico. Nationals from countries like Hungary and the UK were also intercepted.

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Counter BalanceSign the petition to help reform the EU’s Bank
  2. UNICEFChild rights organisations encourage candidates for EU elections to become Child Rights Champions
  3. UNESDAUNESDA Outlines 2019-2024 Aspirations: Sustainability, Responsibility, Competitiveness
  4. Counter BalanceRecord citizens’ input to EU bank’s consultation calls on EIB to abandon fossil fuels
  5. International Partnership for Human RightsAnnual EU-Turkmenistan Human Rights Dialogue takes place in Ashgabat
  6. Nordic Council of MinistersNew campaign: spot, capture and share Traces of North
  7. Nordic Council of MinistersLeading Nordic candidates go head-to-head in EU election debate
  8. Nordic Council of MinistersNew Secretary General: Nordic co-operation must benefit everybody
  9. Platform for Peace and JusticeMEP Kati Piri: “Our red line on Turkey has been crossed”
  10. UNICEF2018 deadliest year yet for children in Syria as war enters 9th year
  11. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic commitment to driving global gender equality
  12. International Partnership for Human RightsMeet your defender: Rasul Jafarov leading human rights defender from Azerbaijan

Latest News

  1. Romania drafts EU code on NGO migrant rescues
  2. Bulgaria, Hungary, and Malta shamed on press unfreedom
  3. EU drafts $20bn US sanctions list in aviation dispute
  4. Brunei defends stoning to death of gay men in EU letter
  5. US Democrats side with Ireland on Brexit
  6. Wifi or 5G to connect EU cars? MEPs weigh in
  7. How Brexit may harm the new EU parliament
  8. EU parliament backs whistleblower law

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. UNICEFUNICEF Hosts MEPs in Jordan Ahead of Brussels Conference on the Future of Syria
  2. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic talks on parental leave at the UN
  3. International Partnership for Human RightsTrial of Chechen prisoner of conscience and human rights activist Oyub Titiev continues.
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic food policy inspires India to be a sustainable superpower
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersMilestone for Nordic-Baltic e-ID
  6. Counter BalanceEU bank urged to free itself from fossil fuels and take climate leadership
  7. Intercultural Dialogue PlatformRoundtable: Muslim Heresy and the Politics of Human Rights, Dr. Matthew J. Nelson
  8. Platform for Peace and JusticeTurkey suffering from the lack of the rule of law
  9. UNESDASoft Drinks Europe welcomes Tim Brett as its new president
  10. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic ministers take the lead in combatting climate change
  11. Counter BalanceEuropean Parliament takes incoherent steps on climate in future EU investments
  12. International Partnership For Human RightsKyrgyz authorities have to immediately release human rights defender Azimjon Askarov

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Nordic Council of MinistersSeminar on disability and user involvement
  2. Nordic Council of MinistersInternational appetite for Nordic food policies
  3. Nordic Council of MinistersNew Nordic Innovation House in Hong Kong
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic Region has chance to become world leader when it comes to start-ups
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersTheresa May: “We will not be turning our backs on the Nordic region”
  6. International Partnership for Human RightsOpen letter to Emmanuel Macron ahead of Uzbek president's visit
  7. International Partnership for Human RightsRaising key human rights concerns during visit of Turkmenistan's foreign minister
  8. Nordic Council of MinistersState of the Nordic Region presented in Brussels
  9. Nordic Council of MinistersThe vital bioeconomy. New issue of “Sustainable Growth the Nordic Way” out now
  10. Nordic Council of MinistersThe Nordic gender effect goes international
  11. Nordic Council of MinistersPaula Lehtomaki from Finland elected as the Council's first female Secretary General
  12. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic design sets the stage at COP24, running a competition for sustainable chairs

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us