Friday

23rd Oct 2020

China pressured EU on coronavirus report, Borrell admits

  • EU foreign affairs chief Josep Borrell (c) (Photo: consilium.europa.eu)

China did try to pressure the EU into diluting a report on coronavirus disinformation, the EU's top diplomat has admitted.

But this was just normal diplomacy, he added, while attacking an EU whistleblower.

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Become an expert on Europe

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

"China expressed its concern when they knew what the document contained and they did this through diplomatic channels," Borrell told MEPs in a videoconference on Thursday (30 April).

"Diplomatic démarches [complaints] can be accompanied by a range of incentives and disincentives, which don't even need to be explicitly mentioned," he added, in a hint of what the Chinese threatened.

"But everybody is doing this, including ourselves, and our closest partners," the former Spanish foreign minister also said.

The controversy concerned two EU foreign service reports on Chinese and Russian coronavirus information attacks.

The first one - an internal, 25-page EU text called an Information Environment Assessment (IEA) - was circulated among EU diplomats on 20 April and leaked to the Politico news website and, later, EUobserver.

The second text - a much shorter one called a "special report" - was published on the EU foreign service website on 24 April.

The second report mentioned China 15 times and accused it of "conspiracy narratives and disinformation".

But it used milder language than the IEA paper and omitted some examples, notably one about an ugly row between France and China on Chinese propaganda.

And in the meantime, US newspaper the New York Times obtained copies of internal EU emails saying Chinese pressure had diluted the public version of the EU text.

"The Chinese are already threatening with reactions if the [IEA] report comes out," Lutz Güllner, an EU official, said in one email the day after the Politico leak.

The EU was "self-censoring to appease the Chinese Communist Party," Monika Richter, an EU diplomat, said in another email.

For his part, Borrell also said, on Thursday, it was normal practice for diplomatic services to have internal reports that differed from public ones.

"These are two different products for two different audiences ... because we are dealing with very sensitive issues", he said.

But he denied that Chinese pressure had caused his personnel to water down accusations.

"We haven't bowed to anyone," Borrell said.

"There was no altering of our findings, no matter how uncomfortable they might be ... just read the [public] report," he said.

The public report omitted the Chinese-French row only because EU sub-editors ultimately deemed it an example of Chinese "bullying" not "disinformation," he added.

And he, personally, had no knowledge of the whole controversy until staff alerted him to it on 24 April, when he was having a day off for his wedding anniversary, Borrell said.

Shooting the messager

The foreign service chief voiced anger at those who leaked the IEA and internal emails to press.

Some MEPs referred to the leakers as ethical "whistleblowers".

But Borrell said: "It's clear we can't work on the basis of these kinds of lies, which are very damaging for our work".

The emails alleging EU "self-censorship" were "written with the aim of being leaked", he said.

"This is very serious," he added.

Borrell got broad support from senior MEPs in Thursday's video-meeting.

"I believe you're an honourable man and I accept your explanation," Radek Sikorski, a Polish former foreign minister, said.

"I was also in the diplomatic service for years and it's perfectly normal," Nathalie Loiseau, a French former EU affairs minister, added.

"It's clear the substance of the report hasn't changed," Reinhard Bütikofer, a German Green MEP, also said.

"I would be happy if all our [EU] leaders used the same kind of language," as the still-harsh China criticism in the EU's public text, Bütikofer added.

Speaking about Russian and Chinese propaganda more broadly, Borrell said on Thursday there was "an infodemic accompanying the pandemic".

His service had recorded 400 fake news items on the virus in recent weeks, he said.

Some of the Russian ones peddled fake cures which were "putting people's lives at risk", he added.

But the EU's debunking website had had an 800 percent increase in traffic since the pandemic began, with 10,000 readers a day, Borrell said, indicating the effectiveness of its work.

Coronavirus

EU criticised for giving in to Beijing censorship

The EU's foreign affairs chief Josep Borrell called agreeing to Chinese censorship on the origins of coronavirus "misguided". Nevertheless, he said diplomacy works like that in China.

Coronavirus

Borrell: Coronavirus has 'blown up' global order

"The coronavirus has ending blowing up the model of global multilateral governance that has been functioning over the past few years," EU foreign affairs chief Josep Borrell told a group of reporters on Thursday.

News in Brief

  1. UK scientists fear Brexit blow to joint EU research
  2. Greek migrant camp lockdown extended
  3. Lukashenko and 14 others in EU crosshairs
  4. EU imposes sanctions over 2015 Bundestag cyberattack
  5. Italy reignites Mont Blanc border dispute with France
  6. Commission to press Croatia on migrant 'abuse' at border
  7. Belarus opposition awarded 2020 Sakharov Prize
  8. Belgium's foreign minister in intensive care for Covid-19

Column

A 'geopolitical' EU Commission. Great idea - but when?

Safeguarding Europe's position starts with recognising the unpleasant reality that Europe's power is waning. Behind the facade of European cooperation, national self-interest still predominates and that has never been any different.

Rightwing MEPs bend to Saudi will after Khashoggi death

Saudi dissident and journalist Jamal Khashoggi was killed two years ago on 2 October. Since then, mainly centre-right, conservative and far-right MEPs have voted down any moves to restrict, limit or ban the sales of weapons to the Saudi regime.

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. UNESDAMaking healthier diets the easy choice
  2. Nordic Council of MinistersUN Secretary General to meet with Nordic Council on COVID-19
  3. UNESDAWell-designed Deposit Return Schemes can help reach Single-Use Plastics Directive targets
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic Council meets Belarusian opposition leader Svetlana Tichanovskaja
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic Region to invest DKK 250 million in green digitalised business sector
  6. UNESDAReducing packaging waste – a huge opportunity for circularity

Latest News

  1. South Caucasus death toll much worse than feared
  2. Polish court effectively bans legal abortions
  3. MEPs urge EU to be ready to dump disputed energy treaty
  4. EU commission on defensive over 'revolving doors'
  5. Why German presidency is wrong on rule of law
  6. Nato and EU silent on Turkey, despite Armenia's appeal
  7. EU tells UK to decide on Brexit as deal 'within reach'
  8. EU farming deal attacked by Green groups

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us