Tuesday

26th May 2020

Poland faces 'nuclear option' of EU sanctions

  • Jean-Claude Juncker and Beata Szydlo: Relations between Brussels and Warsaw deteriorated quickly after Law and Justice came to power. (Photo: European Commission)

The European Commission may ask member states to punish Poland with sanctions on Wednesday (21 December), which would be the first time such a measure has been taken in the EU's history.

Poland's failure to reverse controversial reforms that have paralysed its judiciary system will be discussed at a meeting of the college of commissioners.

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Support quality EU news

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

The possibility of sanctions, which is laid down in article 7 of the EU treaty, has never been used.

The commission’s ex-president Jose Manuel Barroso labelled it as the "nuclear option", hoping the mere threat of sanctions would discourage national governments from going rogue.

But Poland's political crisis intensified over the weekend, with opposition MPs occupying the parliament's plenary hall to block its proceedings since Friday.

The EU's scrutiny over Poland already features historic firsts - the commission activating its rule-of-law mechanism earlier this year to probe the situation in the country.

In July, the EU executive found that Poland had failed to guarantee the independence of its courts.

It published a list of recommended actions that would redeem the situation.

Poland dismissed the recommendations as "political interference" and largely ignored them.

A commission source told Polish press agency PAP that the most recent turmoil convinced commission president Jean-Claude Juncker to put Poland on the college's agenda.

'Article 7 or nothing'

The source wouldn't specify what actions the commission could suggest, but according to Laurent Pech, professor of law at Middlesex University in London, the next step in the commission's probe, as foreseen in the mechanism, was triggering article 7.

"It's either that or doing nothing," he told this website.

"Practically speaking, one may expect the commission to put forward a document setting out the case that there is a clear threat of a serious breach by Poland of the values laid down in article 2 of the EU treaty."

The document would be sent to the European Parliament for its consent. The EU Council, representing member states, could then, acting by a majority of four-fifths of its members, give Poland a chance to reply to the commission’s case before addressing recommendations to it.

"In my opinion, the council would then most likely ask Poland to comply with the commission's recommendations of 27 July."

Given how little interest Poland's rulers have shown to living up to recommendations so far, it's likely they will ignore them this time too.

Even so, Poland is unlikely to face sanctions such as losing its voting rights because the move would need unanimity in the council.

Hungary, which has its own rule of law row with the EU, has already vowed to shield Warsaw from consequences.

Some have argued against triggering article 7 on these grounds, as that would only highlight how powerless the bloc is.

"Doing nothing isn't an option," Dutch liberal MEP Sophie in't Veld insisted.

"The commission has the duty to act, even in the lack of support from the council, when there are huge, systemic problems with the rule of law in a member state."

If the commission triggers article 7, it would make Poland a headache for the Council and its president Donald Tusk, a former prime minister of Poland and the rival of governing Law and Justice.

It would be Tusk's responsibility to act, but it's unclear what he would do in the situation.

An EU pact for democracy and rule of law

Sophie in't Veld said the commission should start working on an EU mechanism on democracy, the rule of law and fundamental rights that actually works.

Earlier this year, she steered through the parliament a report calling for such a measure, which would be based on better coordination of existing instruments: the commission's rule of law framework, as well as the council's rule of law dialogue, a reporting mechanism, notification, and sanctions through infringement procedures or article 7.

"It's not just the case of Poland. There are many other examples in the EU showing the growing need for a mechanism to uphold democracy, rule of law and fundamental rights," in't Veld said.

As for Poland, the EU can't do much about the constitutional crisis, without the cooperation of Poland.

"We support the commission's rule of law mechanism, but in the end, any solutions must be made in Warsaw," Ryszard Petru, leader of the Polish liberal party Nowoczesna and in't Veld's colleague, told EUobserver over the weekend.

Analysis

EU still shy of 'nuclear option' on values

The EU commission has moved forward with its rule-of-law probe on Poland, but critics say that a better framework is needed to uphold values.

Women shake Poland's pillars of power

Polish women are marching again this Sunday and Monday. They could succeed where the opposition, the European Commission and other protests failed, and redraw Poland's political map.

Interview

Polish government in bid to defund NGOs

Ruling Law and Justice has promised to overhaul the NGO sector. The move could strain relations with Norway, a major donor to Polish civic life.

MEPs urge tougher action on Poland

Dismayed by the lack of progress in solving Poland's rule of law crisis, some MEPs are demanding that the EU begins formal breach proceedings that could end up with Poland being stripped of voting rights.

News in Brief

  1. Johnson: Shops in UK will reopen on 15 June
  2. German doctors: Summer holidays could cause second wave
  3. EU forced to choose between China and US: Borrell
  4. Spain to lift two-week arrival quarantine from July
  5. Germany gives Lufthansa €9bn bailout for equity stake
  6. Volkswagen ordered to pay in landmark 'dieselgate' case
  7. 40 million health workers urge more G20 investment
  8. Jourova: Budget rule-of-law link 'more needed than ever'

This is the (finally) approved European Commission

MEPs gave the green light to the entire new European Commission during the plenary session in Strasbourg - but with the abstention of the Greens and a rejection by the leftist group GUE/NGL.

Magazine

Welcome to the EU engine room

Welcome to the EU engine room: the European Parliament (EP's) 22 committees, which churn out hundreds of new laws and non-binding reports each year and which keep an eye on other European institutions.

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. European Sustainable Energy WeekThis year’s EU Sustainable Energy Week (EUSEW) will be held digitally!
  2. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic states are fighting to protect gender equality during corona crisis
  3. UNESDACircularity works, let’s all give it a chance
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic ministers call for post-corona synergies between economic recovery and green transition
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic co-operation on COVID-19
  6. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic research collaboration on pandemics

Latest News

  1. How Kaczyński ruined Poland, judges tell MEPs
  2. EU data protection rules abused to censor media
  3. Draft EU 'green recovery' plan amid clash over natural gas
  4. Clock is ticking: 300,000 vs 3.3m Covid-19 Africa deaths?
  5. Recovery plans unveiled This WEEK
  6. EU and UK stumbling into Irish border crisis
  7. Malta patrol boat 'intimidates' capsized migrants
  8. How coronavirus might hit EU defence spending

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. UNESDAMaking Europe’s Economy Circular – the time is now
  2. Nordic Council of MinistersScottish parliament seeks closer collaboration with the Nordic Council
  3. UNESDAFrom Linear to Circular – check out UNESDA's new blog
  4. Nordic Council of Ministers40 years of experience have proven its point: Sustainable financing actually works
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic and Baltic ministers paving the way for 5G in the region
  6. Nordic Council of MinistersEarmarked paternity leave – an effective way to change norms

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us