Tuesday

14th Aug 2018

Investigation

Private jets - the Achilles heel of EU air traffic security?

  • Portuguese MEP Ana Gomes said the exemption of private jet data was clearly to 'privilege the richest, the ones who can travel in their private planes.' (Photo: Starr-Environmental)

A black sedan rolls along a small country road between fields of sunflowers, the passengers hidden behind the cars' tinted windows.

This is the route from Schoenhagen Airfield, and luxury cars are such a common sight that locals don't even raise their heads when they pass by.

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Support quality EU news

Get instant access to all articles — and 18 year's of archives. 30 days free trial.

... or join as a group

  • Frank Buckenhofer, president of the German trade union for police and customs officers, described the approach to private air traffic as 'grossly negligent' and posing a 'major security risk'. (Photo: German Police Union)

By car, Schoenhagen is about 35 minutes from the centre of Berlin, and 25 minutes from the centre of Potsdam, the capital of the Brandenburg federal state. The airport's website describes it as "the perfect place to land." Only a loose chain link fence separates the airfield from the woods and meadows that surround it.

Standing in front of the small terminal's counter feels closer to waiting at a hotel reception desk than the bustle and stress of the major airports nearby.

X-ray machines and metal detectors are missing, as are the queues for security and fraught passengers that have become synonymous with modern air travel.

A friendly air traffic controller is responsible for reception and checking passports. He is an employee of the airport and not police or border control, but only if the travel is outside Schengen countries does he need to phone the federal police for a passport check.

This experience is typical of small airports around Europe and it's easy to see the appeal of such a way of flying.

Passengers arrive just 20 minutes ahead of the flight. In the words of one company's publicity material, private jets passengers can "skip commercial security clearance and even board from the tarmac."

Light-touch security

But can this light touch sometimes be taken too far?

In 2011, emails leaked from the UK Border Agency to the Guardian newspaper revealed the extent to which border checks for visitors to the UK were already being waived.

According to the Guardian, the leaked emails showed internal concerns that: "Thousands of passengers from all over the world arriving on private jets were allowed into Britain this summer without any passport checks as a matter of official policy."

The internal reports show that immigration and customs staff were instructed not to meet passengers on private charter flights, including executive jets, as part of the "light touch" targeted approach secretly adopted this summer".

Also in 2011, Europol issued a report which included a reference to the use of light aircraft by criminals.

The law enforcement agency stated that "there has been a noted rise in the use of light aircraft for trafficking drugs into the EU (e.g. from north and west Africa), and the number of suspicious flights between EU member states is also increasing. In addition to drugs, though, light aircraft are also now being used to facilitate illegal immigration, smuggle victims of human trafficking, and to traffic firearms, diamonds and bulk cash shipments for money laundering."

The report pinpointed the "lack of monitoring" as a "key facilitator for this rise in the use of light aircraft for trafficking".

Police worries

Seven years later, this is a view echoed by Frank Buckenhofer, president of the German trade union for policemen and customs officers, who described the approach to private air traffic as "grossly negligent" and that it poses a "major security risk".

He told Investigate Europe that "smaller airports, especially those with no surveillance controls, are an open door to smuggling and illegal entry."

Arnd Krummen, a member of the board of the same trade union and specialist in airport security and border control, describes the situation as "a major security risk" and describes private air travel as "the Achilles' heel for internal security."

He argues the need for greater controls, explaining that "it should be in the interest of the German federal government to allow border crossings only at airports where federal police are able to exercise professional controls."

But it is not just in Germany that concerns about the security of smaller airports. have been raised.

David Weinberger, an expert at the French National Institute for Security Studies describes the exemption of private jet data as a privilege for the rich with "a political side: people with private jets usually have good connections to the government."

That private jets have and are being used for criminal activity is not disputed: there are many successful prosecutions from all over Europe that show how successfully border control, police and customs have been apprehending those guilty or crimes.

Whether this will continue as governments turn to technology to secure their borders is questionable, because in the words of Frank Buckenhofer:

"If there is no 'control', then there are no 'cases'."

EU's new 'Passenger Name Record'

The situation for ordinary travellers and holiday-makers catching commercial flights is very different, as this year the EU's Passenger Name Record (PNR) took effect.

While all passengers travelling on commercial airlines will have their data collected, those travelling on private jets within the EU may be exempt if the EU member state authorities so wish it.

This leaves many to question the effectiveness of the directive, and its ability to meet its original goal, especially when the European Parliament's own statement about PNR sounds quite ambitious:

"EU-level measures such as the directive on Advance Passenger Information (API), the Schengen Information System (SIS) and the second-generation Schengen Information System (SIS II) do not enable law enforcement authorities to identify 'unknown' suspects in the way that an analysis of PNR data does."

The PNR – which came into force in May of this year – is, according to the EU Commission, "a record of each passenger's travel requirements held in carriers' reservation and departure control system."

The associated EU directive (which excludes Denmark) stipulates that airlines must twice transmit their passengers' data to central police authorities, once at the time of booking, and then again after boarding the aircraft, when it certain that the passenger is on, and will stay on the flight. This applies to international flights to and from EU airports.

The data collected can include passport and contact details, payment method, dates of travel, seat number and travel itinerary.

The information is available to all police authorities in the EU, and also in the US for five years, making the database one of Europe's biggest, and, as previously reported in EUobserver, it had a projected cost of around €500m.

Objections off the agenda

This mass collection and storage of personal data also made it a highly controversial project causing "serious problems for data protection and transparency" and was described as "a step into the surveillance society", in the words of the EU data protection commissioner, Giovanni Buttarelli, in September 2015.

However, the terrorist attacks in Paris in November 2015, and the need to do everything possible to prevent other attacks, pushed such objections off the agenda.

The then French minister of the interior, Bernard Cazeneuve, called critics "irresponsible" and accused them of not doing everything so "that we protect Europe from the risk of terrorism".

The then French prime minister Manuel Valls travelled to Strasbourg to make this point at the plenary debate. He was convincing enough and MEPs voted in the law, in April 2016, with 461 in favour, 179 against, plus nine abstentions. It was then adopted by the parliament and the council on April 27.

Aside from terrorism, the offences the directive aims to counter – 26 in total - are clearly laid out in Annex II of the legislation, and include money laundering, drug trafficking, human trafficking and trafficking in weapons.

But the legislative process was a long one, taking more than five years to pass, and in December 2015, amendments were made to exclude passengers flying on private jets from the database.

The justification given for this exclusion was that of technical difficulties, in that inclusion would oblige private passengers to use tickets in much the same way as commercial passengers.

Increasing use of private jets

Criticism of the loophole this created were raised by Portuguese Socialist MEP Ana Gomes who says the exemption of private jet data was clearly to: "privilege the richest, the ones who can travel in their private planes."

But could it also privilege the very criminals it was intended to stop?

Gomes argues that "governments are not serious when they announce that they are fighting terrorism and leave a hole in the law.

Not so, says Swedish Socialist MEP Anna Hedh.

While acknowledging that small airports lack the electronic gate-based system required by PNR, she maintains that the information can be obtained by other means, such as from the police or customs.

She told Investigate Europe that she did "not consider that the directive and national law create a back-door."

But even if Hedh is right, is there a danger that the PNR database will lead to a relaxing of security – an outsourcing to technology of what is currently the role of border control?

The use of private jets is increasing. German aviation data specialist WingX reported private business jets flew about 450,000 charter hours in Europe in 2017, a jump of more than 10 percent on the previous 12 months.

More than 102,000 departures were recorded at airports across Europe between June and September, marking the busiest quarter since 2009, it told Flightglobal.com, with Paris Le Bourget and Geneva, Switzerland the top destinations for charter customers.

In addition, new flight-sharing sites, marketing themselves as the 'Ubers of the sky', promise to bring private aviation to the masses.

Under the radar

Will the exclusion of this data allow criminal activity to fly under the radar?

Asked about the problem posed by private plane exemptions, the commission told Investigate Europe that it intended to review the situation by May 2020.

A spokesperson said: "The review of the directive, which the commission will conduct by 25 May 2020, will examine the necessity of including non-carrier economic operators within the scope of this Directive."

However, the commission also appeared to devalue the PNR programme by stretching the definition of data included in the original directive.

It told Investigate Europe: "The definition of 'Passenger Name Record' goes beyond the specific and universally known records in the airline's reservation systems or departure control systems and can include any "equivalent system providing the same functionalities".

"So, for example, an excel file, word document or a simple email containing some form of information on the passengers or travel itinerary could be considered as 'PNR', and hence the carrier may be subject to the obligation to transfer these data to the Passenger Information Unit."

The decision not to include private jet data was seen by many critics as a privilege for the rich, but one open to exploitation by criminal gangs, smugglers, people-traffickers and terrorists.

On 19 July, the European Commission started a series of legal actions against the half of EU's member states that have so far not implemented the Passenger Name Record, namely Austria, Bulgaria, Cyprus, the Czech Republic, Estonia, Finland, France, Greece, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia and Spain.

The countries have two months to answer before further legal action resumes.

Investigate Europe is a pan-European pilot project: a team of nine journalists from eight European countries who research topics of European relevance and publish with media partners Europe-wide. The project is supported by Germany's Hans Boeckler Foundation, Huebner & Kennedy Foundation, GLS Treuhand, Rudolf-Augstein Foundation, Norwegian's Fritt Ord Foundation, and the Open Society Initiative for Europe. The team cooperates with the NGOs Journalismfund and N-Ost. To this research contributed: Wojciech Ciesla, Ingeborg Eliassen, Nikolas Leontopoulos, Maria Maggiore, Leila Minano, Paulo Pena, Harald Schumann and Elisa Simantke.

Feature

'Flobert' guns - Europe's latest terror loophole

Project Safte, an international research project funded by the European Commission, has revealed a loophole in the EU firearms directive that is being exploited by criminals and possibly terrorists.

EU Commission skirts Italy sanctions on Roma evictions

The European Commission, as guardian of the treaties, declines to sanction Italy's treatment of the Roma following a forced eviction on Thursday of some 300 from a camp in the outskirts of the Italian capital.

News in Brief

  1. Malta to allow Aquarius migrants to disembark
  2. Juncker sends condolences over Genoa bridge collapse
  3. EU pledges €500,000 more for Indonesian earthquake island
  4. EU commission in talks with states on new Aquarius migrants
  5. Man held after car crashes into UK parliament security barrier
  6. Brexit delays better readability of medicines' instructions
  7. Masked youths set dozens of cars alight in Sweden
  8. Spain and Italy refuse new Aquarius-rescued migrants

Opinion

The systemic risk that Europe has to face

One of the biggest systemic risks across Europe, illustrated by Hungary and Poland, is the dominance of the executive power over the judiciary and informal channels of political dependency.

Schengen at stake in Austria-Germany talks

German interior minister Horst Seehofer is in Vienna on Thursday - as his plan to reject some asylum seekers was met by an Austrian threat to close its borders too.

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. ACCACompany Law Package: Making the Best of Digital and Cross Border Mobility,
  2. IPHRCivil Society Worried About Shortcomings in EU-Kyrgyzstan Human Rights Dialogue
  3. UNESDAThe European Soft Drinks Industry Supports over 1.7 Million Jobs
  4. Mission of China to the EUJointly Building Belt and Road Initiative Leads to a Better Future for All
  5. IPHRCivil society asks PACE to appoint Rapporteur to probe issue of political prisoners in Azerbaijan
  6. ACCASocial Mobility – How Can We Increase Opportunities Through Training and Education?
  7. Nordic Council of MinistersEnergy Solutions for a Greener Tomorrow
  8. UNICEFWhat Kind of Europe Do Children Want? Unicef & Eurochild Launch Survey on the Europe Kids Want
  9. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic Countries Take a Stand for Climate-Smart Energy Solutions
  10. Mission of China to the EUChina: Work Together for a Better Globalisation
  11. Nordic Council of MinistersNordics Could Be First Carbon-Negative Region in World
  12. European Federation of Allergy and AirwaysLife Is Possible for Patients with Severe Asthma

Latest News

  1. EU commission steps up legal case against Poland
  2. Separation of powers instead of 'Spitzenkandidat' process
  3. Revealed: ExxonMobil's private dinner with Cyprus' top EU brass
  4. What Salvini teaches us about Operation Sophia
  5. 14 lobbyist meetings with Oettinger and Canete went unminuted
  6. UK poll suggests Brits would now vote Remain
  7. Some EU states face delays in 5G preparation
  8. Nordic and Baltic farmers urgently need EU support

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. PKEE - Polish Energy AssociationCommon-Sense Approach Needed for EU Energy Reform
  2. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic Region to Lead in Developing and Rolling Out 5G Network
  3. Mission of China to the EUChina-EU Economic and Trade Relations Enjoy a Bright Future
  4. ACCAEmpowering Businesses to Engage with Sustainable Finance and the SDGs
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersCooperation in Nordic Electricity Market Considered World Class Model
  6. FIFAGreen Stadiums at the 2018 Fifa World Cup
  7. Mission of China to the EUChina and EU Work Together to Promote Sustainable Development
  8. Counter BalanceEuropean Ombudsman Requests More Lending Transparency from European Investment Bank
  9. FIFARecycling at the FIFA World Cup in Russia
  10. Nordic Council of MinistersOECD Report: Gender Equality Boosts GDP Growth in Nordic Region
  11. Centre Maurits Coppieters“Peace and Reconciliation Is a Process That Takes Decades” Dr. Anthony Soares on #Brexit and Northern Ireland
  12. Mission of China to the EUMEPs Positive on China’s New Measures of Opening Up

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Macedonian Human Rights MovementOld White Men are Destroying Macedonia by Romanticizing Greece
  2. Counter BalanceControversial EIB-Backed Project Under Fire at European Parliament
  3. Nordic Council of MinistersIncome Inequality Increasing in Nordic Countries
  4. European Jewish CongressEU Leaders to Cease Contact with Mahmoud Abbas Until He Apologizes for Antisemitic Comments
  5. International Partnership for Human RightsAnnual Report celebrates organization’s tenth anniversary
  6. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic Cooperation Needed on Green Exports and Funding
  7. Mission of China to the EUPremier Li Confirms China Will Continue to Open Up
  8. European Jewish CongressCalls on Brussels University to Revoke Decision to Honour Ken Loach
  9. Nordic Council of Ministers12 Recommendations for Nordic Leadership on Climate and Environment
  10. Macedonian Human Rights MovementOxford Professor Calls for an End to the Anti-Macedonian Name Negotiations
  11. ACCAPeople Who Speak-Up Should Feel Safe to Do So
  12. Mission of China to the EUProgress on China-EU Cooperation

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us