12th Apr 2024


Lawyer suing Frontex takes aim at 'antagonistic' judges

  • The Bellingcat probe was later cited as credible in a report by the EU's anti-fraud agency Olaf in its wider investigation into Frontex abuses (Photo: European Union, 2019)
Listen to article

Judges at the European General Court are demanding absurd levels of evidence for asylum seekers wanting justice over alleged abuses, says a lawyer suing the EU's border agency Frontex.

"It shows you how antagonistic they are really to the very rare cases being brought by victims of human rights violation at the EU's external border," says Iftach Cohen, a lawyer at Front-lex, a Dutch-based civil society organisation.

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Get the EU news that really matters

Instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

  • Screenshot of Alaa Hamoudi after landing on Samos island before being forced back onto a raft and set adrift in the Aegean, according to Bellingcat (Photo: Bellingcat)

Front-lex had in early 2022 taken the Warsaw-based agency to court following evidence by Bellingcat, a Dutch-based investigative outlet, of an alleged pushback of some 22 people off the Greek island of Samos in April of 2020.

Bellingcat had obtained digital evidence, including video footage of an Hellenic Coast Guard vessel leaving the raft adrift in the Aegean Sea. Their probe was later cited as credible in a report by the EU's anti-fraud agency Olaf in its wider investigation into Frontex abuses.

And Cohen says his client, Syrian national Alaa Hamoudi, was among those 22 that were then pulled back to Turkey during the documented incidents that took place on 28 and 29 April, 2020. A screenshot of the Bellingcat video footage shows a bearded Alaa looking down into this phone.

But the judges dismissed the photo and video as evidence amid claims it was not possible to distinguish the gender.

"The person indicated is wearing a hoodie, which covers a large part of his or her head, and is not looking directly at the camera in any of the screenshots," said judges, who later dismissed the case against Frontex in December of last year and demanded Hamoudi pay all legal fees.

Front-lex is now appealing, in the hope that the European Court of Justice (ECJ) will overturn the European General Court decision.

Cohen says the obfuscation over the screenshot is only part of the story, noting that the judges had also dismissed the veracity of the Bellingcat investigation and its significance in the Olaf report against Frontex.

At the time, the Olaf report had not yet been leaked to the wider public. But Cohen says he had demanded the court obtain full access to the Olaf report, given the Bellingcat investigation.

"I can tell you never in my life in Israel, such a thing would have happened, you know, just ignoring the most compelling evidence of the European Union's very own anti-fraud office establishing the credibility of the specific case alleged by the applicant," said Cohen.

Judges wary of ruling on Frontex operations

Similar frustrations were voiced by Dr Joyce De Coninck, a post-doctoral fellow at the Ghent European Law Institute, part of Ghent University.

"The General Court seems to pull out all sorts of stops to avoid assessing whether Frontex conduct and its contribution to these operations has given rise to a fundamental rights violations," she said.

De Coninck says the court avoids looking into the merits of such cases, because it would go beyond what has been coded into EU legislation. As for Hamoudi, the outcome is deplorable, she said.

"If what Hamoudi brings forward is even remotely true, it's unfathomable how he would have been able to prove an illegal covert mission," she said.

She says it's unreasonable to think that someone on a raft in the middle of the night, whose phone had been taken, is going to have the reflex to document everything.

And she also took issue with the court argument highlighting inconsistencies in Hamoudi testimonies, noting traumatised people are not going to remember minute details a year after the alleged pushback.

There are also other factors at play, spanning concepts of shared responsibilities when it comes to Frontex acting as a subsidiary of the hosting member state.

"I think that permeates into what the court does. It's very cautious about getting to the point where they're actually assessing the conduct of Frontex in operational settings," she said.

Case law at the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg is more clear about the burden standard and method of proof in these types of scenarios, she said.

The Strasbourg court says the burden standard must be at least shared when public authorities exercise a dominant power and when the applicant is in particularly vulnerable situation with no means to prove the claim.

But in this case, the General Court tossed out evidence altogether without clarifying what it means to have "conclusive" evidence. De Coninck says she hopes the appeal lodged at the ECJ would now at least make such evidentiary standards more clear, including who bears the burden of proof, what the standard of proof is and what the methods are that can be relied upon to provide proof.

Frontex did not respond, as of publication, to emailed questions regarding the case.

Frontex guilty of inflating legal fees against activists

A lawyer for Frontex billed too many hours in a case against transparency activists, the General Court of the European Union ruled. The agency had demanded a €23,700 legal bill from the activists - now reduced by over half.


MEPs set to rubber-stamp new restrictive phase of EU asylum

The European Parliament is set to rubber stamp a new internal EU management system on asylum. Years in the making, the overhaul has been described as a game-changer by EU institutions determined to reach an agreement ahead of June's elections.

EU 'ready' to support Cyprus on Lebanon migration

The EU is ready to offer extra support to Cyprus as the Mediterranean island faces a sharp increase in refugees arriving from Lebanon, a spokesperson for the EU executive told reporters on Thursday (4 April).


How migrants risk becoming drug addicts along Balkan route

Psychotropic drug abuse is one of the many dangers migrants face along the Balkan route. In overcrowded camps, doctors prescribe tranquilisers to calm people down. And black market circuits and pharmacies selling drugs without prescription contribute to the issue.

EU 'ready' to support Cyprus on Lebanon migration

The EU is ready to offer extra support to Cyprus as the Mediterranean island faces a sharp increase in refugees arriving from Lebanon, a spokesperson for the EU executive told reporters on Thursday (4 April).

Latest News

  1. UK-EU deal on Gibraltar only 'weeks away'
  2. Belgium declares war on MEPs who took Russian 'cash'
  3. Brussels Dispatches: Foreign interference in the spotlight
  4. Calling time on Amazon's monopolism and exploitation
  5. Resist backlash on deforestation law, green groups tell EU
  6. China's high-quality development brings opportunities to the world
  7. Ukraine tops aid list again, but EU spending slumps
  8. Who did Russia pay? MEPs urge spies to give names

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Nordic Council of MinistersJoin the Nordic Food Systems Takeover at COP28
  2. Nordic Council of MinistersHow women and men are affected differently by climate policy
  3. Nordic Council of MinistersArtist Jessie Kleemann at Nordic pavilion during UN climate summit COP28
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersCOP28: Gathering Nordic and global experts to put food and health on the agenda
  5. Friedrich Naumann FoundationPoems of Liberty – Call for Submission “Human Rights in Inhume War”: 250€ honorary fee for selected poems
  6. World BankWorld Bank report: How to create a future where the rewards of technology benefit all levels of society?

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Georgia Ministry of Foreign AffairsThis autumn Europalia arts festival is all about GEORGIA!
  2. UNOPSFostering health system resilience in fragile and conflict-affected countries
  3. European Citizen's InitiativeThe European Commission launches the ‘ImagineEU’ competition for secondary school students in the EU.
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersThe Nordic Region is stepping up its efforts to reduce food waste
  5. UNOPSUNOPS begins works under EU-funded project to repair schools in Ukraine
  6. Georgia Ministry of Foreign AffairsGeorgia effectively prevents sanctions evasion against Russia – confirm EU, UK, USA

Join EUobserver

EU news that matters

Join us