Monday

25th Jul 2016

Merkel in tough spot over US spy scandal

  • Merkel wants Obama to respect German law on German soil (Photo: Bundesregierung/Kugler)

German Chancellor Angela Merkel on Friday (19 July) defended her stance on the US spying affair, saying Washington needs more time to give all the answers and that she cannot force the US to change its laws.

At the traditional "summer press conference" ahead of breaking off to holidays in Italy, Merkel was grilled for over an hour about her response to revelations made by fugitive whistleblower Edward Snowden.

Dear EUobserver reader

Subscribe now for unrestricted access to EUobserver.

Sign up for 30 days' free trial, no obligation. Full subscription only 15 € / month or 150 € / year.

  1. Unlimited access on desktop and mobile
  2. All premium articles, analysis, commentary and investigations
  3. EUobserver archives

EUobserver is the only independent news media covering EU affairs in Brussels and all 28 member states.

♡ We value your support.

If you already have an account click here to login.

The former US intelligence contractor last month exposed a secret surveillance programme (Prism) ran by the National Security Agency which taps into the servers of Google, Apple or Facebook, enabling them to snoop emails, chats or voice conversations in their search for alleged terrorism suspects.

Germany turned out to be the country where most data is collected from among EU nations, according to Snowden, who also pointed the finger at the German intelligence services for knowing and assisting the NSA in this project.

Faced with increased criticism from the opposition that risks to dent her popularity ahead of her re-election bid on 22 September, Merkel said "German law needs to be respected on German soil."

"Here in Germany and in Europe it's not about the law of the strongest, but about the strength of law," she said.

However, a declaration from the US side that they abide by German law and are not engaged in mass surveillance of German citizens, as she asked for when President Obama visited her in Berlin last month, has not been formulated yet.

"They asked for more time to look at all the questions we sent them. In this case, I think it's better to wait than to get a declaration which turns out to be void," she said.

Even if she understands that the terrorist attacks of 11 September 2001 put the US in a "deep shock" and that at that time Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder promised "unlimited solidarity", Merkel is still "concerned" about the proportionality of all anti-terrorism programmes in the US.

"The end doesn't justify the means. Just because you have a certain technology doesn't mean you need to use it," she said.

But she also pointed to the limitations of her mandate. As a German chancellor, she can only demand from the US to stick to German law while on German soil.

"But I cannot tell them to adapt their laws to the German ones. We are finding it difficult even in the EU to agree on data protection standards," she pointed out.

Germany and France are now jointly pushing for a revamp of the EU data protection law to also cover intelligence services, Merkel said. "It will be a difficult task," she said, pointing to the UK, where decades of conflict and terrorism in northern Ireland have made the country more tolerant to surveillance than Germany.

The two countries are also pushing for internet companies like Facebook and Google to be obliged to give notice when they hand over private data to other governments or organisations.

Merkel downplayed the effect the scandal may have on her reelection bid and the chances to remake the same coalition with the Liberal Party.

"We are 66 days ahead of elections, data privacy will play a role, but several other topics are likely to come up too. We have a convincing concept and I am confident this can be explained well to our citizens," she said.

The opposition has criticised her for failing to defend the interests of German citizens.

"What does the government know? Is the programme still ongoing? What is Merkel doing to defend German interests? We need answers to all these questions now," Social-Democrat leader Frank-Walter Steinmeier told Bild.

The Greens reacted by saying she was not convincing at all.

"Merkel's performance at the press conference was not only an insult to all listeners who expected explanations, but also an intellectual insult to all those who work in the chancellery, pretending not to have known about anything," Green deputy leader Volker Beck told Spiegel.

A poll ran by ARD shows that over two thirds of those questioned are not happy with how the German government is handling the NSA affair. But so far this has failed to swing the voters' mood for the 22 September elections: 33 percent say this will impact their choice only marginally and 37 percent said this will play no role at all.

Merkel's coalition has so far managed to keep its lead over a leftist-green coalition, according to latest polls. Her Christian-Democrats are comfortably at 41 percent, while the Liberals clock in at five percent among voters. The Social-Democrats are at 23 percent and the Greens at 14 percent.

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Belgrade Security ForumMigration, Security and Solidarity within Global Disorder: Academic Event Agenda for 2016
  2. GoogleHow Google Fights Piracy: Creating Value While Fighting Piracy
  3. EJC"My Visit to Israel" - Opinion by MEP Lopez Aguilar, Chair of the EP Working Group on Antisemitism
  4. World VisionChildren Migrating, Out of School and at Work as Hunger Deepens in Southern Africa
  5. European Healthy Lifestyle AllianceStand-Up (and Exercise) to Prevent Chronic Diseases
  6. Centre Maurits CoppietersLaunches a Real-time News Hub Specialised in EU Stakeholders
  7. Dialogue PlatformFethullah Gulen Calls for International Probe Into Turkey Coup Allegations
  8. GoogleEU-US Privacy Shield: Restoring Faith in Data Flows and Transatlantic Relations
  9. World VisionWorld Leaders & Youth Advocates Launch Partnership to End Violence Vs. Children
  10. Counter BalanceReport: Institutionalised Corruption in Romania's Third Largest Company
  11. Access NowEuropol Supports Encryption. We Can Relax Now… Right?
  12. GoogleLearn about Google's projects across Europe on Twitter @GoogleBrussels

Latest News

  1. Munich attack might not have been terrorism
  2. A very British (and Corbynite) coup
  3. Poland 'changing for the worse' for Muslims and refugees
  4. EU aims to lift visas on Turks despite purge
  5. ECB in ‘bail-out’ of scandal-tainted VW
  6. EU failed to learn lesson from Brexit, Poland says
  7. UK accord on EU workers 'crucial', France says
  8. EU and US take different lines on Turkey crackdown