25th Sep 2022

Court casts doubt on EU's flight-data regime

  • Tuesday's court ruling could embolden further legal challenges in EU (Photo: Ray Swi-hymn)
Listen to article

The European Court of Justice (ECJ) in Luxembourg has struck a blow against Europe's data-collection regime on flight passengers — in the name of civil liberties.

The EU passed its Passenger Name Record (PNR) law in 2016, forcing airlines to tell EU states details of who was flying into or inside Europe, including credit card information and phone numbers, in case these matched with people flagged as terrorist suspects in law-enforcement databases.

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Become an expert on Europe

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

The law was hotly-contested by privacy advocates at the time, while also being credited with helping to extend US visa waivers for EU travellers.

But Tuesday's (21 June) ruling said the way Belgium had interpreted the EU directive amounted to "undeniably serious interferences with the rights guaranteed in Articles 7 and 8 of the Charter [of Fundamental Rights — an EU accord]".

Belgium "seeks to introduce a surveillance regime that is continuous, untargetted and systematic, including the automated assessment of the personal data of everyone using air transport services," it added.

It said the PNR system should only be used subject to very strict conditions when it came to internal EU flights.

These included limiting its use to fight "terrorist offences and serious crime having an objective link ... with the carriage of passengers by air" — but not to combat irregular migration, for instance.

The ECJ judges said Belgium's PNR usage should "be open to effective review, either by a court or by an independent administrative body whose decision is binding".

It said authorities must demonstrate "a terrorist threat which is shown to be genuine and present or foreseeable" to use the full force of the regime.

They must also delete people's PNR data after six months unless they can demonstrate an "objective link" to their "terrorist offences or serious crime", the court added, while lamenting "the extremely high rate of false positives and errors" in Belgium's handling of its new powers over the past six years.

The case arose after the League of Human Rights (LHR), a Belgian branch of a German group, challenged the PNR regime in Belgium's constitutional court.

"This judgment undoubtedly calls into question our [Belgium's] law [on PNR]," Catherine Forget, the LHR's lawyer, who pleaded its case in Luxembourg, told EUobserver Tuesday.

"The ball is now in the court of the Constitutional Court," she added.

Forget described the verdict as a "victory" and said the Belgian tribunal will need to either amend Belgium's interpretation of the EU-wide PNR law, or scrap it altogether.

The precedent-setting EU court ruling would likely embolden anti-PNR challenges in other EU countries, she added.


Frontex chief took €8,500 private flight to Brussels meeting

Frontex spent €8,500 to send its executive director Fabrice Leggeri on a private jet to attend an evening meeting in Brussels. The Warsaw-based agency said there were scheduling conflicts preventing him taking a commercial flight.

'No decision expected' for EU decision on unanimous decisions

Swedish minister for European affairs Hans Dahlgren told EUobserver no decision can be expected on majority vote next year. Mikuláš Bek, the Czech minister for European affairs, said enlargement and changes to the decision-making are politically interlinked.

'Cosmetic changes' not enough on EU funds, Hungary warned

Critics point out that Hungary will continue to receive substantial inflows of EU funds since the proposed suspension applies only to around 22 percent of total EU subsidies earmarked for Hungary in the bloc's current budget for 2021-2027.

EU Commission proposes freezing 65% of funds to Hungary

The freezing, the first time in the EU's history using the conditionality mechanism linking EU subsidies to the respect of the rule of law, would suspend money from the bloc's cohesion funds under the 2021-27 long-term budget.


What von der Leyen's 'State of Union' didn't mention

Ursula von der Leyen barely noticed that European democracy is under attack not only from external threats, but from within. Two of the world's leading autocratic countries are EU member states.

News in Brief

  1. More Russians now crossing Finnish land border
  2. Report: EU to propose €584bn energy grid upgrade plan
  3. Morocco snubs Left MEPs probing asylum-seeker deaths
  4. EU urges calm after Putin's nuclear threat
  5. Council of Europe rejects Ukraine 'at gunpoint' referendums
  6. Lithuania raises army alert level after Russia's military call-up
  7. Finland 'closely monitoring' new Russian mobilisation
  8. Flights out of Moscow sell out after Putin mobilisation order

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. UNESDA - Soft Drinks EuropeCall for EU action – SMEs in the beverage industry call for fairer access to recycled material
  2. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic prime ministers: “We will deepen co-operation on defence”
  3. EFBWW – EFBH – FETBBConstruction workers can check wages and working conditions in 36 countries
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic and Canadian ministers join forces to combat harmful content online
  5. European Centre for Press and Media FreedomEuropean Anti-SLAPP Conference 2022
  6. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic ministers write to EU about new food labelling

Latest News

  1. Ireland joins EU hawks on Russia, as outrage spreads
  2. Editor's weekly digest: Plea for support edition
  3. Investors in renewables face uncertainty due to EU profits cap
  4. How to apply the Nuremberg model for Russian war crimes
  5. 'No big fish left' for further EU sanctions on Russians
  6. Meloni's likely win will not necessarily strengthen Orbán
  7. France latest EU member to step up government spending in 2023
  8. Big Tech now edges out Big Energy in EU lobbying

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us