27th Nov 2022

EU states want to keep hoarding passenger data, despite ECJ ruling

  • Finland says 81 percent its PNR data transfers have been related to internal EU flights so far this year (Photo: angeloangelo)
Listen to article

Member states are looking at circumventing an EU court ruling on hoovering up people's personal data.

The data vacuum is part of an EU law known as the passenger name record (PNR) directive and is supposed to help track and prevent terrorist attacks and serious crime.

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Become an expert on Europe

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

The 2016 EU law emboldened national authorities to start sweeping up everyone's passenger flight data, including people with no links to crime.

Part of the idea was to keep tabs on people for five years in case they commit a terrorist offence in the future, including those who were taking internal EU flights.

But the European Court of Justice over the summer decided that such tactics risk violating fundamental rights.

The court said that data processing and retention practices must be limited to what is strictly necessary to fight terrorism and serious crime.

It means national authorities can only collect data on flights within the EU if there is a real terror related threat.

EU states are not happy and are now debating how to interpret the ruling as widely as possible, including finding new ways to determine an objective evidence of a terror risk.

In September, the EU presidency under the Czech Republic, circulated an internal document among EU states.

The paper, leaked by London-based Statewatch, sought for possible ways around the requirements laid down by the judgment.

EUobserver has since reviewed those responses in a 100-page internal document, dated 26 October, also from the EU presidency.

Their responses paint a picture of widespread backlash against the court ruling.

In some cases, EU states appear to suggest that the PNR law could be used to predict future crimes.

Capitals' complaints

"It is very difficult to point out a logical methodology for removing data from a pool in which unforeseen future events have yet to play out," says Denmark.

Estonia makes similar remarks.

"Due to our geographical location we don't see the possibility to exclude even partial collection of regular intra-EU flights," they say.

Austria says it has processed some 66-percent less data since the ruling.

"We would highlight that the use of PNR data is an important prevention tool to identify terrorist attacks before the happen," they say.

Portugal says intra-EU flights represents more than 50 percent of its PNR data.

And Finland says it represents 81 percent so far this year alone.

"Needs for all intra Schengen PNR data is critical for Finland," it says.

Finland also appears to introduce a loophole into the EU court judgement.

It notes that while the EU court ruling sets clear requirements on processing PNR data, it "does not prescribe to the member states how they must ensure these goals in law or practice."

Others, like Greece, complain that the judgement requires each EU state to justify why they need to process data, instead of everyone using the same approach.

Athens is demanding EU funding in order to filter and delete data that is of no use.

It also says a six-month retention period creates a "security hole" because criminal gangs do not operate in six-month intervals.

Greece also wants to take the lead of any new EU working level group, first floated by Belgium and supported by Finland and Ireland, to create common risk-analysis model.

Meanwhile, Hungary has described as unrealistic the court's decision that requires evidence of any wrongdoing before data can be collected.

And Spain says that it will grudgingly accept any automated system that intends to filter out innocent people.

But such automated systems also have their problems.

An impact assessment by the European Commission found that five-out-of-six individuals are falsely identified in the automated analysis of PNR data.

"Indeed, predicting crime does not appear to work outside movie plots like 'Minority Report'," said the European Digital Rights (EDRi), a Brussels-based umbrella group, in a blog entry.


Panama and PNR on EU agenda This Week

Panama Papers revelations, that could topple the Maltese government, will be debated in the EP next week. Controversial legislation to share passenger name records will also be voted on.

EU Commission to keep Hungary's EU funds in limbo

The EU executive, on the other hand, is expected to approve Hungary's recovery plan, worth €5.8bn, but only would disburse actual money if Hungary delivers on some 27 key reforms.

News in Brief

  1. 'Pro-Kremlin group' in EU Parliament cyberattack
  2. Ukraine will decide on any peace talks, Borrell says
  3. Germany blocks sale of chip factory to Chinese subsidiary
  4. Strikes and protests over cost-of-living grip Greece, Belgium
  5. Liberal MEPs want Musk quizzed in parliament
  6. Bulgarian policeman shot dead at Turkish border
  7. 89 people allowed to disembark in Italy, aid group says
  8. UN chief tells world: Cooperate on climate or perish

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Nordic Council of MinistersCOP27: Food systems transformation for climate action
  2. Nordic Council of MinistersThe Nordic Region and the African Union urge the COP27 to talk about gender equality
  3. International Sustainable Finance CentreJoin CEE Sustainable Finance Summit, 15 – 19 May 2023, high-level event for finance & business
  4. Friedrich Naumann Foundation European DialogueGender x Geopolitics: Shaping an Inclusive Foreign Security Policy for Europe
  5. Obama FoundationThe Obama Foundation Opens Applications for its Leaders Program in Europe
  6. EFBWW – EFBH – FETBBA lot more needs to be done to better protect construction workers from asbestos

Latest News

  1. Sweden says 'no' to EU asylum relocation pledges
  2. The 'proof' problem with EU sanctions — and how to fix it
  3. The EU gas cap: will the bottle ever be 'uncorked'?
  4. Enough talk, only rights can eliminate patriarchal violence
  5. Swedish EU presidency: 'Ukraine, Ukraine, Ukraine'
  6. EU Commission to keep Hungary's EU funds in limbo
  7. 'No substance' price ceiling for gas leaves everyone disgruntled
  8. Paying consumers who save most energy could tame gas prices

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. European Committee of the RegionsRe-Watch EURegions Week 2022
  2. UNESDA - Soft Drinks EuropeCall for EU action – SMEs in the beverage industry call for fairer access to recycled material
  3. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic prime ministers: “We will deepen co-operation on defence”
  4. EFBWW – EFBH – FETBBConstruction workers can check wages and working conditions in 36 countries
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic and Canadian ministers join forces to combat harmful content online
  6. European Centre for Press and Media FreedomEuropean Anti-SLAPP Conference 2022

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us