Investigation
Ex-commissioner refuses to testify at dieselgate probe
-
Verheugen: "Only the present commission is entitled and capable to give you the evidence, which you want" (Photo: European Commission)
By Peter Teffer
Former EU commissioner Guenther Verheugen told the European Parliament he does not see the added value he could provide by testifying in the inquiry committee into the dieselgate scandal, even though he was in charge of EU industry affairs from 2004 to 2010.
“My conclusion is that only the present commission is entitled and capable to give you the evidence, which you want,” he wrote in a letter, seen by EUobserver, addressed to committee chairwoman Kathleen Van Brempt.
Join EUobserver today
Support quality EU news
Get instant access to all articles — and 18 year's of archives. 30 days free trial.
Choose your plan
... or join as a group
Don't miss out on
EUobserver's coverage of the 2019 European election. Investigative. Independent. Influential. Try us.
Why join?
Watch our founder Lisbeth Kirk explain the reasons in this 30 seconds video.
-
Schulz told Verheugen he should show up at the hearing because 'democratic accountability' also applies to him (Photo: consilium.europa.eu)
The inquiry committee is trying to find out whether EU institutions and politicians could have done more to prevent car manufacturers from cheating on emissions tests.
The MEPs have requested appearances from four former commissioners and the two current commissioners in charge of industry and environment.
Verheugen is the only one to have rejected the invitation.
“I fully respect the role and the responsibility of the EP, and I appreciate your explanation why the committee wants to hear me,” Verheugen wrote.
However, he told Van Brempt he would not come.
“I still do not see how I could contribute more than the commission, which is in possession of all relevant documents," he wrote.
"Therefore I ask your understanding that my position remains unchanged."
The letter was dated 19 May, but Van Brempt told this website she had not seen it on 24 May, when she told this website that the “rude” commissioner had not replied.
She told this website on Wednesday (1 June) the rejection was “unacceptable”.
The pressure on Verheugen, who currently works as a consultant, is increasing.
On 26 May, EP president Martin Schulz wrote a letter, also seen by this website, telling Verheugen he was “surprised” by the rejection, and reminding him that a key regulation that deals with illegal cheating software in cars was adopted during his tenure.
Schulz stressed that former commissioners hold valuable insights and that “democratic accountability” also applies to them.
Both Schulz and Verheugen are German and of the centre-left Social Democratic party, which sits in the EP with Van Brempt's socialist group.
Copies of the letter, written in German, were sent to Van Brempt, and to current EU commission chief Jean-Claude Juncker.
Verheugen's appearance before the committee, if he caves into the pressure, is scheduled for 14 July.
