Tuesday

18th Feb 2020

Magazine

Breaking up is hard to do

  • Scots voted 'No' in their referendum in September but talk about further devolution will continue (Photo: Phyllis Buchanan)

For a frenzied 72 hours of campaigning, the future of the United Kingdom was under threat. The 300-year old settlement binding together Scotland and England in danger of being torn up.

A poll putting the Yes campaign marginally ahead, along with a string of others putting the campaign in a dead heat, prompted panic from Edinburgh to London.

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Support quality EU news

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or join as a group

  • The November poll in Catalonia was not binding - the independence question remains uncertain (Photo: sba73)

Were Scots really about to kiss the Auld Enemy goodbye?

The consequences for British politics would be profound. Scottish independence would force David Cameron out of Downing Street and cause an unprecedented constitutional crisis. Not to mention the question of whether Labour, which has traditionally held most of Scotland's Westminster seats, could ever win another election without Scottish votes.

Alex Salmond

In the event, the panic was unjustified. The pollsters were wrong. The 55-45 margin in favour of remaining in the Union was decisive. In the end, it was the charismatic Scottish National Party leader, Alex Salmond, who announced his resignation after the vote.

Having been the dominant figure in Scottish politics for more than a decade, Salmond's retirement will leave a void.

But even defeat by a 10-point margin must still be counted as a triumph for Salmond.

Tony Blair's Labour government introduced devolution for Scotland and Wales more than 15 years ago in part to kill off future demands for independence.

Despite being in government in Edinburgh since 2007, the Scottish Nationalists were still 20 points behind the No campaign at the start of 2014. The Scottish campaign was never supposed to be so close.

Scotland's EU status

EU membership was one of the main bones of contention. The pro-Union Better Together campaign argued that an independent Scotland would be booted out of the bloc and be forced into a lengthy and uncertain accession procedure.

The Yes campaign claimed that a simple revision of the EU treaty could protect Scotland's EU status without accession negotiations.

Pro-Independence campaigners also retorted that Cameron's plan to hold an in/out referendum on the UK's continued membership in 2017 was a more serious threat to Scotland's EU status.

Just as serious was the debate about whether an independent Scotland would be able to continue to use the pound or be forced into the eurozone, an issue on which the Yes campaign failed to offer a clear answer.

Relief in Brussels

In Brussels, meanwhile, although the European Commission studiously avoided taking sides, the relief in the EU executive's Berlaymont headquarters was almost as palpable as in London.

Scottish independence would have caused a major headache for the EU institutions and sent a shock-wave across the bloc.

There is no precedent for an EU country breaking up. Carefully constructed compromises on voting weights in Council – where member states are represented - and MEP seats would have had to be unpicked and re-written, not to mention a potentially fraught accession process for a Scottish bid to join the EU.

It would also have provided a huge fillip for nationalist and regional parties that have seen a surge in support across a number of EU countries.

Catalonia

Two months later, and a few thousand kilometres south of Edinburgh, voters in Catalonia had their own independence poll.

Catalonia's vote lacked similar drama for the simple reason that it was not going to change anything.

Spain's centre-right government and the opposition socialist party were united in their opposition to the poll, while the country's constitutional court forbade the holding of a formal referendum.

The court even sought to halt the consultative referendum pending an analysis on whether it breached the Spanish constitution - a position which was ignored by the Catalan government.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, most Catalans chose not to vote. Only one in three Catalans went to the polls on 9 November, although around 80 percent of those who did voted Yes to the two questions: "Do you want Catalonia to be a state? If so, do you want this state to be independent?".

Ten percent backed a Catalonian state that remained part of Spain while 4.5 percent voted No on both questions.

In both cases the referendum result is not the final word in the story.

Kingmakers

As the opinion polls narrowed, pro-Union politicians offered new powers to the Scottish government, including more powers over taxation and economic policy, in a bid to keep Scotland in the UK.

These will now have to be fleshed out.

Cameron's Conservative party only holds one of the 59 MPs elected to Scottish constituencies, and his English-centric party will be resistant to any extra financial support to Scotland. He has also vowed to tackle the constitutional quirk which allows Scottish and Welsh MPs to vote on policy matters that affect England but not vice versa.

Nor does the referendum defeat appeared to have dampened the enthusiasm of Scots for either the SNP or independence. A survey conducted in early November indicated that 52 percent of Scots now back independence.

Polls also suggest that the SNP will gain a bushel of seats from the Labour and Liberal Democrat parties and could, potentially, end up as kingmakers following next May's general election. If Scottish independence is on the back-burner for now, it would be naive to rule out the prospect of another referendum within the next decade.

Artur Mas

The situation is more turbulent in Spain, where Catalan government leader Artur Mas is set to face federal charges for disobeying the court order and misusing public money by holding the referendum.

Prime minister Mariano Rajoy has also stated that there is no chance of a formal referendum on secession, describing the November poll as "not a consultation or a democratic vote but rather an act of political propaganda".

However, the overwhelming Yes among those who voted is likely to stiffen the resolve of Mas and his supporters to demand a binding referendum in the future.

Independence campaigners have been silenced, but probably not for long.

This story was originally published in EUobserver's 2014 Europe in Review Magazine.

Click here to read previous editions of Europe in Review magazines.

Cameron in a pickle over Scotland promises

British PM David Cameron is under fire from his own party and from the Labour opposition for having promised more powers to Scotland but being vague on similar devolution plans for England.

Magazine

Macron: Hegelian hero of EU history?

The election of the 39-year old newcomer injected new hope and dynamism. But the French president still has to find solid allies in the EU and deliver his ambitious agenda at home.

Magazine

In 2018, make Europe great again!

Is the EU back on track to make Europe great again? The fifth edition of EUobserver's Europe in Review magazine looks at the biggest events that shaped the EU in 2017 and prospects for 2018.

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Nordic Council of MinistersScottish parliament seeks closer collaboration with the Nordic Council
  2. UNESDAFrom Linear to Circular – check out UNESDA's new blog
  3. Nordic Council of Ministers40 years of experience have proven its point: Sustainable financing actually works
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic and Baltic ministers paving the way for 5G in the region
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersEarmarked paternity leave – an effective way to change norms
  6. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic Climate Action Weeks in December

Latest News

  1. Ending shell companies does not threaten privacy
  2. Net payer countries push back on EU budget plans
  3. Is Belgium heading for new elections?
  4. Budget, Zuckerberg, Pelosi and Cayman Islands This WEEK
  5. EU plan on AI: new rules, better taxes
  6. What the EU can do for South Sudan - right now
  7. The last best chance for Donbas and peace in Europe?
  8. EU commissioner lobbied by energy firm he owns shares in

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us