Monday

14th Jun 2021

Thunberg dubs new EU climate law 'a surrender'

  • 'Until you take the ['carbon budget' approach] seriously, we will remain here in the streets,' said a group of young activists, including Greta Thunberg (Photo: European Parliament)

A group of youth climate activists, including Greta Thunberg, have said that the climate law unveiled by the European Commission on Wednesday (4 March) is a "surrender" that postpones immediate action to mitigate climate change.

"Such a law sends a strong signal that real and sufficient action is being taken when in fact it's not," they said in an open letter to EU leaders at the European Commission, European Parliament and member states.

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Become an expert on Europe

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

"Nature doesn't bargain, and you cannot make deals with physics," they added.

According to the commissioner for the Green Deal, Frans Timmermans, Thunberg explained and urge the colleague of commissioners on Wednesday to adopt the 'carbon budget' approach - which is commonly shared by NGOs and scientists.

She also told MEPs that the proposal was insufficient, adding that it is essential to follow "a science-based pathway".

The 'carbon budget' approach, also known as emission budget, indicates a finite amount of greenhouse gas emission that can be emitted over a specific period of time.

"The 'emissions budget' will be a more transparent and better approach, since it clearly quantifies permissible emissions and underlines the need of drastic and immediate reduction of emissions," the head of international and European governance at the Ecologic Institute, Nils Meyer-Ohlendorf, told EUobserver.

However, the position of the commission to mitigate climate change relies on emissions targets.

The first-ever EU climate law offers a framework to make the 2050 climate-neutrality goal irreversible and legally-binding for all member states, although it failed to update the 2030 target adopted in 2014 - at least 40 percent emission cuts in ten years.

After a risk assessment is in place, the 2030 target might increase towards 50 to 55 percent emissions cuts - which could be essential to pass the law in the European Parliament.

However, despite the bloc's bill being unprecedented worldwide youth activists believe that "net zero emissions by 2050" for the EU equals "surrender" and it means giving up.

"We don't just need goals for just 2030 or 2050. We, above all, need them for 2020 and every following month and year to come," they said, adding that the 'carbon budget' approach applies immediately and not in a faraway future.

"Until you take this seriously, we will remain here in the streets," they warned.

Other criticisms

In addition, the climate law proposal was also criticised by the European Climate Foundation for failing to set up of an independent scientific body able to scrutinise the actions taken by the commission and member states - a common standard in many EU national laws.

"Independent scientific bodies support consistency between climate long-term goals and short-term action. They enhance the role of science, and help build the necessary political will to decarbonise economies," said Meyer-Ohlendorf, who believes that this is a "missed opportunity".

"The Climate Law will ensure we stay focused and disciplined, remain on the right track and are accountable for delivery," said Timmermans, adding that the legislative proposal sent also an "important" message to the EU's international partners.

Carbon border tax coming

To achieve the 2050 climate-neutrality and push other countries to raise their ambition, the commission pledged to protect European industry with the so-called 'carbon border adjustment mechanism'.

As a result, imports could be hit with some form of tariff if they do not meet EU's environmental standards.

The commission confirmed on Wednesday that they officially started to work on the impact assessment that will cover the carbon border tax and on the revision of EU rules for energy taxation.

"As long as many international partners do not share the same ambition as the EU, there is a risk of carbon leakage," reads the communication of the Green Deal.

While this measure could trigger new trade wars with third countries like the US, Timmermans said that "the best way to avoid carbon border tax is to be in the same direction".

"We are absolutely right to protect our industry from carbon leakage," he added.

Timmermans is expected to present the EU law to EU environment ministers on Thursday (5 March), but there will not be a formal exchange of ideas between member states until their next meeting, which is scheduled in June.

However, experts from the member states will dive into the specificities of the legislative proposal already in March.

If the commission's risk assessment for 2030 target is ready in June, the chair of the parliament's environment committee (ENVI), Pascal Canfin, would like ENVI to vote on the proposal in June - before it is submitted to the parliament's plenary in July.

"The European Commission must not slow us down by postponing the impact assessment of the 2030 target until September," Canfin said, adding that an agreed 'trilogue' should be ready before UN climate talks in Glasgow later this year (COP26).

EU climate law slammed for delaying action

The EU's unprecedented climate law will be unveiled on Wednesday, making its 2050 climate-neutrality goal irreversible, but proposal has been criticised for postponing action on the 'climate emergency'.

Agenda

EU climate law and Thunberg visit This WEEK

The European Commission will on Wednesday unveil the first-ever EU climate law, while environmental activist Greta Thunberg is in Brussels to meet with the college of commissioners and MEPs. Environmental ministers will also gather to discuss future climate developments.

Timmermans: EU climate law will 'discipline' rogue states

The first EU-wide climate law will be a "disciplining" exercise to implement the Green Deal - although the Polish climate minister Michal Kurtyka warned the EU Commission about the social cost of delivering the green transition.

Feature

Dutch case opens new era for climate-change litigation

Legal action related to climate change is set to grow considerably in the next few years - especially after a largely-overlooked ruling over Christmas by a Dutch court forced the government to reduce its emission by 25 percent by 2020.

Analysis

Will coronavirus torpedo the Green Deal?

2020 was supposed to be the crunch year in the fightback against climate change. However, the coronavirus pandemic has flattened Europe and beyond, which is likely to slow down international negotiations to fight climate change

Ministers back EU-wide 2050 climate goal, not by country

EU environment ministers reached on Friday a partial agreement on the bloc's climate law, pending a decision by EU leaders on the updated 2030 target. While none of the 27 EU countries rejected the bill, Bulgaria decided to abstain.

News in Brief

  1. EU top court fast-tracks rule-of-law case to October
  2. Hungary's Fidesz wants to ban LGBTIQ content for under-18s
  3. MEPs join EU citizens on farm-animal cage ban
  4. Council of Europe urges Russia to release Navalny 'immediately'
  5. China's anti-sanctions law alarms EU businesses
  6. Airlines seek to water down EU passengers' rights
  7. EU leaders join call for further probe into Covid origins
  8. Liberal MEPs under fire over Babiš abstention

Livestream

Live: Join the Nordic climate debate 'Choosing Green'

Although the Covid-19 pandemic has stalled climate negotiations, work has not stopped. The 'Choosing Green' debate will address some of the most important and most complex key areas relating to the global green transition. Live on EUobserver from 10:00 (CET).

Timmermans 'disappointed' with ongoing CAP reform

For European Commission vice-president Frans Timmermans, the Common Agricultural Policy has to answer to "higher expectations" on climate action, protection of biodiversity and environmental sustainability, while ensuring a fair income for all farmers.

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Nordic Council of MinistersNineteen demands by Nordic young people to save biodiversity
  2. Nordic Council of MinistersSustainable public procurement is an effective way to achieve global goals
  3. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic Council enters into formal relations with European Parliament
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersWomen more active in violent extremist circles than first assumed
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersDigitalisation can help us pick up the green pace
  6. Nordic Council of MinistersCOVID19 is a wake-up call in the fight against antibiotic resistance

Latest News

  1. EU urges Poland to step back from 'legal primacy' clash
  2. Pressure builds on EU to back WTO vaccine-patent waiver
  3. EU anti-fraud agency cracked down on fake pandemic supplies
  4. MEP office expenses kept secret on dubious evidence
  5. What the EU public think of EU pesticide regulation
  6. MEPs set to take EU Commission to court on rule-of-law
  7. EU takes legal action against Germany on bonds ruling
  8. MEPs demand new EU biodiversity law by next year

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us