23rd Jul 2021

EU court takes UK line on welfare checks

  • Cameron (r) is drafting proposals for EU reform ahead of his in/out referendum (Photo: Crown)

The European Court of Justice (ECJ) should dismiss the European Commission's challenge to UK welfare restrictions for EU migrants, the court's advisor said in a non-binding opinion Tuesday (6 October).

The legal advisor to the EU's top court, Cruz Villalon, said the UK's “right to reside” test - a check on whether a benefit claimant really lives in the UK - is justified to safeguard the state’s public finances, even if it may be considered “indirect discrimination”.

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Become an expert on Europe

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

The Court, in a separate ruling on Tuesday, also said EU states can restrict voting rights of convicted criminals, but cast doubt on the legality of Britain's blanket ban on prisoner votes.

The welfare opinion represents a boost for UK prime minister David Cameron’s campaign to reform EU ties before holding a referendum on Britain’s EU membership.

Renegotiating benefit rights for EU citizens is a major piece of Cameron’s reform plan.

The advocate general said the UK residency checks on EU migrants do not impose any condition additional to what is inscribed in EU law, but simply examines the lawfulness of that residence according to European rules.

The legality of this test was thrown into question when the European Commission took Britain to court in spring 2014.

The final ruling, due later by the court, is not bound by the advocate general’s opinion, but the EU judges, in practice often follow their advisors’ decision.

The ECJ ruling on voting bans for people “convicted of a serious crime” is also being closely watched in the UK.

Earlier, Cameron vowed to ignore the ECJ on the matter if it were to outlaw a blanket ban on voting for prisoners.

He argued it is up to national parliaments to decide on voting arrangements.

Britain, the only western European country with a blanket voting ban for prisoners, has repeatedly ignored rulings by the non-EU Strasbourg-based European Court of Human Rights which say its restrictions are unlwaful.

The ECJ case was brought by a French murderer, Thierry Delvigne, who defended his right to vote by reference to the European Charter of Fundamental Rights.

The ECJ ruled that “it is possible to maintain a ban” on voting in the European Parliamentary elections for people who have committed a “serious crime”.

But the ruling added that such a ban must be proportionate to the aim pursued.

A UK spokesperson said it welcomed the welfare opinion, saying it "supports our view that we are entitled to ensure only EU migrants who have a right to be in the UK can claim our benefits".

'We are not slaves': Brussels' migrant hunger-strike

Almost 500 undocumented migrants in Brussels have been demanding a legal pathway for residency in Belgium. Most have been on hunger strike since 23 May, with some now refusing water. MEPs are demanding the Belgian government offer them a solution.

Frontex chief accused of possible rights 'cover up'

A group of MEPs delivered their final report into the EU's border agency Frontex. After a four-month probe, they found it had failed to take its responsibility to protect fundamental rights at Europe's external borders.

News in Brief

  1. Macron changes phone after Pegasus spyware revelations
  2. Italy to impose 'vaccinated-only' entry on indoor entertainment
  3. EU 'will not renegotiate' Irish protocol
  4. Brussels migrants end hunger strike
  5. Elderly EU nationals in UK-status limbo after missed deadline
  6. WHO: 11bn doses needed to reach global vaccination target
  7. EU to share 200m Covid vaccine doses by end of 2021
  8. Spain ends outdoor mask-wearing despite surge


The exploited Sikh labourers babysitting Italy's buffalos

The migrant workers are exploited (by landlords and dairy-businessmen) like slaves. They work up to 14-hours per day, every single day non-stop without any leave, for barely €400 per month. If they get injured, their bosses hide these incidents.

On board with SOS Méditerranée

Libyan police lieutenant: 'Coast guard are smugglers'

The Libyan coast guard actively works with smugglers and are run by a militia, an ex-Libyan lieutenant police officer. The EU is buying the guard three new P150 high speed patrol boats.

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Nordic Council of MinistersNineteen demands by Nordic young people to save biodiversity
  2. Nordic Council of MinistersSustainable public procurement is an effective way to achieve global goals
  3. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic Council enters into formal relations with European Parliament
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersWomen more active in violent extremist circles than first assumed
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersDigitalisation can help us pick up the green pace
  6. Nordic Council of MinistersCOVID19 is a wake-up call in the fight against antibiotic resistance

Latest News

  1. Far left and right MEPs less critical of China and Russia
  2. Why is offshore wind the 'Cinderella' of EU climate policy?
  3. Open letter from 30 embassies ahead of Budapest Pride
  4. Orbán counters EU by calling referendum on anti-LGBTI law
  5. Why aren't EU's CSDP missions working?
  6. Romania most keen to join eurozone
  7. Slovenia risks court over EU anti-graft office
  8. Sweden's gang and gun violence sets politicians bickering

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us