Monday

25th Sep 2017

Poland avoids talks on rule-of-law sanctions

  • Protest against Law and Justice reforms in Warsaw. (Photo: Grzegorz Zukowski)

EU ministers on Tuesday (16 May) asked Poland to unblock talks with the European Commission and implement its recommendations on the rule of law. But they shied away from talking about stronger measures, such as sanctions.

"There was a broad agreement around the table that rule of law is a common interest and common responsibility of [EU] institutions and member states. This is a very strong starting point," said the EU commissioner Frans Timmermans, in charge of the rule of law probe.

Thank you for reading EUobserver!

Subscribe now and get 40% off for an annual subscription. Sale ends soon.

  1. €90 per year. Use discount code EUOBS40%
  2. or €15 per month
  3. Cancel anytime

EUobserver is an independent, not-for-profit news organization that publishes daily news reports, analysis, and investigations from Brussels and the EU member states. We are an indispensable news source for anyone who wants to know what is going on in the EU.

We are mainly funded by advertising and subscription revenues. As advertising revenues are falling fast, we depend on subscription revenues to support our journalism.

For group, corporate or student subscriptions, please contact us. See also our full Terms of Use.

If you already have an account click here to login.

It was the first time that ministers weighed in on Poland's breaches of the rule of law, notably its capturing of the country's constitutional tribunal.

Shortly after its victory the parliamentary elections in October 2015, the winning Law and Justice party started stacking Poland's constitutional court with government-loyal judges.

The EU commission launched a probe into the matter in January 2016, but Poland has been unwilling to reverse the reform, ultimately having Timmermans reach out to the ministers for help.

For a long time, there was little certainty on whether the ministers would agree to the discussion, fearing it would be too uncomfortable to corner a colleague over its domestic policies.

But undemocratic tendencies in several member states, notably in Hungary, have convinced some other countries that something must be done.

"We had a very intensive debate, in an open atmosphere. It was very to the point," said Bert Koenders, the Dutch foreign minister, adding that discussions on the rule of law shouldn't be a taboo.

"We are a community of values, when there is an issue, as we have at the moment with Poland, we should have a serious dialogue," he added.

According to one EU source, the Netherlands was one of the countries that spoke most forcefully in favour of the European Commission's probe, together with Belgium, France, Germany, Italy and Sweden.

The Czech Republic and Hungary spoke against the procedure, arguing that the rule of law is a "national competence", with which the EU should not be involved. So did the UK - but it only weighed in with its objections after the end of the ministers' debate, angering some other EU diplomats.

Brexit over democracy

“It demonstrated that Brexit is more important than democracy,” one EU diplomat told the Financial Times.

Other ministers opted to back the commission's oversight of the rule of law in member states more generally, without specifically mentioning Poland. This group included Ireland, Luxembourg, Spain and Slovakia, the latter of which is considered a Polish ally.

Poland's EU minister, Konrad Szymanski, reduced the importance of the debate. He said that the Law and Justice government was always ready to talk to the commission and is just as committed to the rule of law and democracy.

"This isn't a conflict over values, but about our interpretation of these values," he said.

"We don't agree with the commission's interpretation [of Poland's reforms] and we presented all member states with copies of the documents that we have sent to the commission," he added.

If further talks fail to solve the issue, the commission could, in theory, trigger article 7 of the EU treaty and formally acknowledge that Poland has breached its obligations under EU law.

The procedure could lead to sanctions against Poland, including the loss of voting rights in the council.

Poland-friendly Orban

But such a step would require the unanimous backing of EU heads of state and government, and Hungary's prime minister, Viktor Orban, has already said he would protect Poland by exercising his country's veto.

Article 7 was absent from Tuesday's discussion, according to Sweden's EU minister, Ann Linde, who said she hoped the issue would be solved by Poland reversing its controversial reforms, rather than by sanctions.

Belgium's foreign minister, Didier Reynders, said he hoped that the commission would come back to the Council of the EU with a report detailing Poland's rule of law breaches during the Maltese presidency already, which ends in June, or the Estonian presidency that will follow.

"I hope this dialogue will take place and that we can come back to the issue shortly in the council," Reynders said.

"In the future, I hope we will go further and install a periodic review mechanism for all member states. We already have such a review mechanism for the single market and the budgets, we should also have it for the rule of law."

When asked about the commission's options if it failed to find common ground with Poland, Timmermans said: “It's not going to help the dialogue if I start setting deadlines or threats".

But he added that, "If we need to use a tool in the toolbox, then the commission is free to do so."

Tusk summoned again to Polish court

EU president said he may use diplomatic immunity to decline invitations to appear as a witness in Polish cases if they start to interfere with his work.

News in Brief

  1. Merkel wins fourth term, exit polls say
  2. EU to hail 'aspirations' of former Soviet states
  3. UK says credit downgrade was wrong
  4. Dutch state appeals ban on taking air-polluting measures
  5. May proposes 2-year transition period after Brexit
  6. May to call on EU's 'sense of responsibility'
  7. Catalonia has 'contingency plans' for independence vote
  8. Last German polls confirm Merkel's lead

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. EU2017EEEU Finance Ministers Agreed to Develop New Digital Taxation Rules
  2. Mission of China to the EUGermany Stands Ready to Deepen Cooperation With China
  3. World VisionFirst Ever Young People Consultation to Discuss the Much Needed Peace in Europe
  4. European Jewish CongressGermany First Country to Adopt Working Definition of Antisemitism
  5. EU2017EEFour Tax Initiatives to Modernise the EU's Tax System
  6. Dialogue PlatformResponsibility in Practice: Gulen & Islamic Thought
  7. Counter BalanceHuman Rights Concerns Over EIB Loan to the Trans Anatolian Pipeline Project
  8. Mission of China to the EUChina Leads the Global Clean Energy Transition
  9. CES - Silicones EuropeFrom Baking Moulds to Oven Mitts, Silicones Are a Key Ingredient in Kitchens
  10. Martens CentreFor a New Europeanism: How to Put the Motto "Unity in Diversity" Into Practice
  11. Access MBAGet Ahead With an MBA Degree. Top MBA Event in Brussels
  12. Idealist QuarterlyIdealist Quarterly Event: Building Fearless Democracies With Gerald Hensel

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Mission of China to the EUPresident Xi Urges Bigger Global Role for Emerging Economies
  2. EU2017EEAre We Socially Insured in the Future of Work?
  3. European Jewish CongressFrench Authorities to Root Out "Societal Antisemitism" After Jewish Family Assaulted
  4. European Federation of Local Energy CompaniesClean Energy for All? On 10.10 Top-Level Speakers Present the Clean Energy Package
  5. UNICEFUp to Three Quarters of Children Face Abuse & Exploitation on Mediterranean Migration Routes
  6. Swedish EnterprisesEurope Under Challenge; Recipe for a Competitive EU
  7. European Public Health AllianceCall to International Action to Break Deadlock on Chronic Diseases Crisis
  8. CES - Silicones EuropePropelling the construction revolution with silicones
  9. EU2017EEEU 2018 Budget: A Case of Three Paradoxes
  10. ACCAUS 'Dash for Gas' Could Disrupt Global Gas Markets
  11. Swedish Enterprises“No Time to Lose” Film & Debate on How Business & Politics Can Fight Climate Change
  12. European Free AllianceSave The Date!! 26.09 - Coppieters Awards To... Carme Forcadell