Tuesday

26th Jan 2021

Opinion

EU minimum wage directive undercuts Scandinavian model

  • We, the Scandinavian Trade Unions, share the view that wages are too low in many parts of Europe. But EU legislation on pay would not only be in breach of the treaty, but would also interfere with well-functioning labour market models (Photo: Martin Vorel)

The European Commission has presented its proposal for a directive on adequate minimum wages.

We, the Scandinavian Trade Unions, share the view that wages are too low in many parts of Europe.

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Become an expert on Europe

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

At the same time, we have reminded the EU Commission that EU legislation on pay would not only be in breach of the treaty, but would also interfere with well-functioning labour market models.

First of all, it is our firm position that the EU lacks competence to legislate on issues regarding pay.

Pay is - just like the right of association, the right to strike or the right to impose lockouts - explicitly exempted from EU legislation, according to Article 153(5) in the treaty and related ECJ rulings.

This safety clause protects national wage-setting systems, which can vary substantially between member states.

Having conducted an analysis of the proposed directive, we can clearly say that our worries and concerns remain.

EU social affairs commissioner Nicolas Schmit has repeatedly promised that the directive would not affect Scandinavian countries, because it would include a "waterproof firewall" to protect our labour market models.

We take note of the inclusion of a reference in this spirit, but the proposed directive falls short of living up to these promises.

The draft directive states that "it that does not oblige member states where wage setting is exclusively done by collective agreements to introduce a statutory minimum wage nor to make the collective agreements universally applicable."

However, a directive is a binding legal act and the proposal requires member states – no exceptions made – to live up to the basic requirements in the directive: the need to ensure that all workers have access to minimum wage protection, either by statutory minimum wage or under collective agreements.

In addition, the directive states that every worker should be able to go to court to claim that minimum wage. These rules, addressed to member states, intervene directly in fields that in Scandinavia are exclusively defined and determined not through legislation, but by the social partners alone.

Thus, the directive is deeply contradictory and will leave room for interpretations by the Court of Justice.

From our experience this means that the commission's "waterproof firewall" - despite its intention - would not be able to safeguard our labour market model and will definitely not constitute a firewall, waterproof or not.

Although the commission's ambition is to strengthen collective bargaining, the draft directive would therefore directly interfere with existing and well-functioning collective bargaining structures.

The proposed directive also for the first time, introduces EU legislation concerning collective bargaining at national level, providing EU definitions to national concepts such as "collective bargaining" and "collective agreements".

This together with the demand of "adequate minimum wages" raises a number of other questions, as many articles are detailed – and at the same time very vague.

This leaves room for ambiguous interpretations, which would provide a carte blanche for the European Court of Justice to issue rulings that directly interfere with our labour market models and the autonomy of national social partners.

'Waterproof firewall'?

We have never asked for a "waterproof firewall". Simply because we already have one.

The Lisbon Treaty provides a safeguard, as its Article 153 exempts crucial labour market elements such as wage-setting and the right of association from EU interference.

It can also be noted that when agreeing on rules regarding representation and collective defence of the interests of workers and employers, including co-determination, the council shall act unanimously according to Article 153 (1f) in the Treaty.

Considering this, we would like to remind the commission that rather than proposing legal texts that stand in contradiction with the treaty, it should remember its role as guardian of the treaties.

As always, we are more than willing to engage in discussions on how to create a real Social Europe. We share the commission's willingness to increase wages and improve collective bargaining in many parts of Europe.

However, imposing minimum wages and interfering in collective bargaining through binding legislation, not only means breaching EU treaties.

There is also a serious risk that this will undermine successful labour market models that have delivered real wage increases for decades. We know that it is not the intention of the Commission. It may, however, be the direct consequence.

This is a momentum for a real Social Europe. However, it would be very unfortunate if the commission missed it due to misguided ambitions to harmonise widely-differing labour market models.

Author bio

Lizette Risgaard is president of the Danish Trade Union Confederation.

Bente Sorgenfrey is first vice-president of the Danish Trade Union Confederation.

Lars Qvistgaard is president of the Danish Confederation of Professional Associations.

Hans-Christian Gabrielsen is president of the Norwegian Trade Union Confederation.

Peggy Hessen Følsvik is vice president of the Norwegian Trade Union Confederation.

Ragnhild Lied is president of the Confederation of Unions for Professionals.

Kjetil Rekdal is vice president of the Confederation of Unions for Professionals.

Erik Kollerud is president of the Confederation of Norway Vocational Unions.

Hans-Erik Skjæggerud, is vice president of the Confederation of Vocational Unions.

Susanna Gideonsson is president of the Swedish Trade Union Confederation.

Therese Guovelin is first vice-president of the Swedish Trade Union Confederation.

Therese Svanström is president of the Swedish Confederation of Professional Employees.

Peter Hellberg is vice president of the Swedish Confederation of Professional Employees.

Göran Arrius is president of the Swedish Confederation of Professional Associations.

Disclaimer

The views expressed in this opinion piece are the author's, not those of EUobserver.

EU Commission unveils 'adequate minimum wage' plan

The European Commission proposed minimum standards to ensure adequate minimum wages all across the EU. But the proposal does not oblige member states to harmonise their systems, nor does it set a common minimum wage level.

EU minimum wage - a view from Poland

An EU minimum wage would vary between member states, at 60 percent of their respective average or median national wages. Six countries would be obliged to introduce a minimum wage. Is this a whim or a necessity?

Why EU minimum wage is actually bad idea for workers

As president of one of the largest trade union confederations in the EU, I see the need for good working conditions and decent pay in all member states - but an EU-wide minimum wage could be used to lower wages.

Column

BioNTech: Stop talking about their 'migration background'

I understand that the German-Turkish community - often subjected to condescension in Germany - celebrated the story. Uğur Şahin and Özlem Türecki represent scientific excellence and business success at the highest level.

Italy's return to statism spells trouble for the eurozone

There are profound questions about whether the windfall of cash from the EU coronavirus recovery fund will truly help Italy recover or whether it will cause more problems than it solves, for Rome and the rest of the eurozone.

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. UNESDAEU Code of Conduct can showcase PPPs delivering healthier more sustainable society
  2. CESIKlaus Heeger and Romain Wolff re-elected Secretary General and President of independent trade unions in Europe (CESI)
  3. Nordic Council of MinistersWomen benefit in the digitalised labour market
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersReport: The prevalence of men who use internet forums characterised by misogyny
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersJoin the Nordic climate debate on 17 November!
  6. UNESDAMaking healthier diets the easy choice

Latest News

  1. Giuseppe Conte: scapegoat or Italy's most cunning politician?
  2. Borrell to meet Lavrov, while Navalny behind bars
  3. Too few central and eastern Europeans at top of EU
  4. Rift widens on 'returns' deadline in EU migration pact
  5. EU adds new 'dark red' zone to travel-restrictions map
  6. Migrants in Bosnia: a disaster foretold on EU doorstep
  7. Navalny protests sharpen EU sanctions talks
  8. Why Russia politics threaten European security

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us