MEPs earned millions via side-jobs, NGO says
MEPs' financial declarations have brought to light an array of side-jobs, while posing questions on possible conflicts of interest and sloppy record keeping.
Over one quarter of the bloc's 705 MEPs have declared side-jobs, collectively worth between €3.9m and €11.5m in outside earnings, according to a study by Transparency International EU, an NGO.
Join EUobserver today
Become an expert on Europe
Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.
Choose your plan
... or subscribe as a group
Already a member?
And the money will likely cast a shadow over efforts to create an independent ethics body to ensure codes of conduct are fully respected, the NGO's Vitor Teixeira said.
"The parliament has to agree to the new rules and to the new body. But will they agree considering that so many are able to earn so much of their side-income without any monitoring?," he said on Wednesday (13 October).
Having a side job is not against the rules.
But failing to properly declare it could lead to suspicions of outside influence swaying an MEP's judgement, especially if they legislate on issues dear to their private paymasters.
The current system of self-regulation relies on five MEPs from the different political groups, with the European Parliament president having a final say on any sanctions in case of wrongdoing.
But not a single sanction has been issued over the past five years, leading to a sense of impunity, even though some 25 MEPs did breach the rules.
"Significant side income of elected MEPs always brings with it the risk of conflicts of interest," said German Green MEP Daniel Freund, in a statement.
"Where the side income itself significantly exceeds the parliamentary allowance, the question arises as to what the side-job is," he said.
Freund had spearheaded a European Parliament initiative to create an EU inter-institutional and independent ethics body.
Although the centre-right European People's Party group abstained, the initiative recently passed with a majority vote, meaning the European Commission is now tasked to bring forth a proposal.
Sikorski to update declaration
The NGO, earlier this week, listed Polish centre-right MEP Radosław Sikorski as the highest earning deputy, based on his latest declaration of interest from 2019.
They said he likely took in between €588,000 to €800,000 per year on top of his MEP-salary of €8,757 per month. This included €40,000 a month from Sikorski Global, plus "other consulting" tasks.
Sikorski disputed the figures, in part, because of the manner in which he had listed the declarations.
"The figures listed in the report of Transparency International are not correct," he told EUobserver in an email.
"The income from outside activities in 2020 was much smaller, namely 333 387,92 Polish złoty per annum [€72,800]," he said.
He said he would clarify matters after having declared some activities twice.
"For example, a number of activities are remunerated as part of the activity listed as Sikorski Global, but to highlight the nature of the activity, some activities have been listed as a separate activities in other sections to denote from which organisations I receive remuneration," he said, noting that some figures were therefore listed twice although he was only paid once.
"I will update the declaration to make this clearer," he said.
He also noted his declarations can be found on Polish government websites (here, here and here).
Gozi disputes figures
Sikorski was not alone in disputing the figures cited by Transparency International EU, which based its calculations on their public records.
Among them was French liberal MEP Sandro Gozi, who was cited as having the second biggest salary for side jobs, earning between €360,000 and €720,000 annually.
"As you know, in my previous position, I did earn significant amounts of money for a few years. However, the figures mentioned are wrong," he said by email.
Gozi said his declarations could be found on a French government website, resulting in some €277,000 gross side-income in 2019.
European Parliament declarations are also vague, demanding MEPs to only checkbox earnings spread out across five different income ranges.
Gozi checked five activities with income ranging from between €5,001 to €10,000 per month, as well as other less well-paid jobs.
MEP declares no conflicts
Meanwhile, Finnish socialist MEP Miapetra Kumpula-Natri was also highlighted by the NGO as holding side-jobs that could lead to conflicts of interests.
It noted her paid positions on the boards of two energy companies in Finland - she also serves as a member of the committee on industry, research, and energy.
"Members of city councils hold positions in the energy companies that are city owned," said Miapetra Kumpula-Natri, in an email.
She noted that the energy company Vaasan Sähkö is owned by her home city, Vaasa. Its board also includes people representing the liberals, greens, and the centre-right, she said.
"I was still member of the city council last spring when the board was nominated," she said.
Site Section
Related stories
- Negotiations set for new, tougher, EU ethics body
- EU kept in dark on ex-commissioner's new lobby job
- German ex-commissioner Oettinger lands Orban job
- Qatargate? EU parliament's culture of impunity is its own creation
- EU Parliament to present 14 point anti-corruption reform
- Consultancies pocketing EU millions prompts MEP grilling