Friday

31st Mar 2023

Opinion

Could a new lawsuit blow open von der Leyen's Pfizer texts?

  • The EU Commission has dug in its heels, saying that text messages could never be considered documents subject to transparency (Photo: EU Commission)
Listen to article

When other routes had failed, John Kerry started typing. In November, the US envoy turned to diplomacy's secret weapons — emails and texting — to save stalled UN climate talks COP27 at the Egyptian resort town Sharm el-Sheikh. Phone in hand, Kerry got in touch with his Chinese counterpart Xie Zhenhua. A meeting followed. Soon relations between the two great powers warmed, as the negotiators later recalled.

This is no lone example. The Guardian noted already back in 2016 the rise and rise of diplomacy by WhatsApp".

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Become an expert on Europe

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

Messaging apps have become an inescapable fact of life for most of us — and a standard form of communication between top officials in governments across the globe.

It therefore comes as surprise that president of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, claims that the EU's freedom of information law does not cover her text messages.

This is all the more astounding as the commission boasts about their impressive results.

Early last year, when vaccines against Covid were still scarce, Von der Leyen told the New York Times that she personally clinched a deal over 1.8bn doses in calls and messages with the CEO of Pfizer, Albert Bourla.

Sceptics point out that, according to a leaked partial contract, the deal Von der Leyen negotiated with Pfizer raised the price per dose from an initial €15.50 per vaccine dose to €19.50. This amounts to billions in profit for the pharmaceutical company.

NGOs complain that the high cost of European vaccine purchases came at the expense of strained public healthcare workers and countries in the Global South.

So what did the EU Commission chief promise Pfizer? We might never know.

Most European countries have strong laws mandating the disclosure of official documents. These laws protect sensitive information such as state secrets or private addresses from public, but officials must justify withholding access in every case.

The European Union has even enshrined transparency in its Fundamental Rights Charter. Article 42 grants the public a right of access to EU documents — "whatever the medium". This right has been a recognised principle of good governance for decades.

Such transparency is necessary in the fight against government overreach and corruption. "Sunlight is said to be the best disinfectant", as US supreme court judge Louis Brandeis famously argued. The recent Qatargate scandal drove home the lesson that public scrutiny of how the EU makes decisions and spends money is no "nice to have", but essential.

But when I asked for the exchanges with the Pfizer CEO, the Commission replied text messages were "short-lived" and therefore did not qualify as document under the law.

This drew a sharp rebuke from the European Ombudsman, who in January 2022 found that EU institutions must systematically archive and give access to texts, the same as with e-mails or letters. The European Parliament, too, has demanded more information about how the EU's billion-euro vaccine contracts came about.

But unfortunately the Ombudsman's rulings are non-binding. Meanwhile, parliament has failed to compel Pfizer CEO Bourla to appear at the special Covid committee to testify.

The Commission has dug in its heels, saying that text messages could never be considered documents subject to transparency. Moreover, it asserts that only messages it has put in its official archive may be released under FOI law — an act of cherry-picking that could put a lot of official communication out of transparency's reach.

With its intransigence, the Commission risks creating a legal black hole. If text messages are exempt from public scrutiny, they become the medium of choice for every illicit or odious purpose — from indecent proposals by authoritarian states to secret lobby deals between officials and the fossil fuel industry.

Texting — or any file sent by messenger apps — will become a dark channel for those who wish to avoid scrutiny. In effect, the European Union wants to 'quiet quit' on public access.

Strong action is needed. The New York Times has made a crucial intervention. Matina Stevis-Gridneff, the Times' Brussels bureau chief, has filed a lawsuit at the European Court of Justice that could force the Commission to disclose the texts.

More is at stake than just a few messages. This lawsuit could change institutional practice for decades. Will transparency end at an official phone's lock screen — or does the public have a right to know?

Crucial information needs to be captured — or it will come back to haunt us.

Author bio

Alexander Fanta is an EU correspondent for netzpolitik.org, a German news website covering digital rights issues.

Disclaimer

The views expressed in this opinion piece are the author's, not those of EUobserver.

EU Ombudsman: Missing texts with Pfizer CEO are 'wake-up call'

The EU Ombudsman said missing texts between European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen and the boss of Pfizer are a "wake-up call" for all institutions about how they should handle work-related instant messages in the digital era.

Von der Leyen slammed for not revealing Pfizer CEO texts

The European ombudsman has criticised the European Commission for its handling of a request for public access of text messages that were exchanged between president Ursula von der Leyen and Pfizer CEO Albert Bourla.

Ukraine — what's been destroyed so far, and who pays?

More than 50 percent of Ukraine's energy infrastructure, large parts of its transport network and industrial capacity, around 150,000 residential buildings damaged or destroyed. The bill is between €378bn to €919bn.

Why do 83% of Albanians want to leave Albania?

As autocracies collapsed across Eastern Europe in the early 1990s, Albanians had high expectations that democracy and a free-market economy would bring a better life. But Albania's transition from dictatorship to democracy has been uneven and incomplete.

Why do 83% of Albanians want to leave Albania?

As autocracies collapsed across Eastern Europe in the early 1990s, Albanians had high expectations that democracy and a free-market economy would bring a better life. But Albania's transition from dictatorship to democracy has been uneven and incomplete.

The overlooked 'crimes against children' ICC arrest warrant

An unprecedented component of this announcement has received less attention: the ICC also issued an arrest warrant for Maria Alekseyevna Lvova-Belova, Putin's commissioner for children's rights. Lvova-Belova is accused of deporting and unlawful transfer of Ukrainian children to Russia.

Latest News

  1. Aid agencies clam up in Congo sex-for-work scandal
  2. Ukraine — what's been destroyed so far, and who pays?
  3. EU sending anti-coup mission to Moldova in May
  4. Firms will have to reveal and close gender pay-gap
  5. Why do 83% of Albanians want to leave Albania?
  6. Police violence in rural French water demos sparks protests
  7. Work insecurity: the high cost of ultra-fast grocery deliveries
  8. The overlooked 'crimes against children' ICC arrest warrant

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. InformaConnecting Expert Industry-Leaders, Top Suppliers, and Inquiring Buyers all in one space - visit Battery Show Europe.
  2. EFBWWEFBWW and FIEC do not agree to any exemptions to mandatory prior notifications in construction
  3. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic and Baltic ways to prevent gender-based violence
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersCSW67: Economic gender equality now! Nordic ways to close the pension gap
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersCSW67: Pushing back the push-back - Nordic solutions to online gender-based violence
  6. Nordic Council of MinistersCSW67: The Nordics are ready to push for gender equality

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Azerbaijan Embassy9th Southern Gas Corridor Advisory Council Ministerial Meeting and 1st Green Energy Advisory Council Ministerial Meeting
  2. EFBWWEU Social Dialogue review – publication of the European Commission package and joint statement of ETUFs
  3. Oxfam InternationalPan Africa Program Progress Report 2022 - Post Covid and Beyond
  4. WWFWWF Living Planet Report
  5. Europan Patent OfficeHydrogen patents for a clean energy future: A global trend analysis of innovation along hydrogen value chains

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us