Tuesday

16th Aug 2022

Stakeholder

Making EU's climate policy fit for current political challenges

  • Wojciech Dąbrowski is chief executive officer of the PGE Polska Grupa Energetyczna
Listen to article

After Russia's invasion on Ukraine, the EU is getting serious about breaking its dependence on Russian energy. Reconciling climate, social and security goals will be difficult, but Europe already has some tools in place to face those challenges.

The reforms of the EU's Emissions Trading System might be one of the important steps to make EU more resilient and less dependent on fossil fuels imported from Russia.

Read and decide

Join EUobserver today

Become an expert on Europe

Get instant access to all articles — and 20 years of archives. 14-day free trial.

... or subscribe as a group

The Russian invasion on Ukraine came amid hiking costs of natural gas (which was at least partly caused by Gazprom's market manipulations) and rising price of CO2 allowances in EU.

On the political level, the unprecedented scale of the Western sanctions also revealed serious limitations and vulnerabilities of the West, due to its energy dependence on Russia.

Poland, together with other central and eastern European (CEE) countries has been warning about the threats of such dependence for years and has long ago adapted a long-term strategy, which will allow it to get rid of Russian gas from 2023, thanks to LNG imports and the Baltic Pipe project. Germany, finally, put Nord Stream 2 on hold and decided to invest in LNG infrastructure.

The necessary steps are discussed among member states and within organisations like International Energy Agency. The discussion now revolves not around "whether" but "how" to put an end to imports of natural gas, oil or coal from Russia. The biggest issue is to find the right balance between EU's climate goals and security and social challenges.

Commission's toolbox

This May, the European Commission proposed its REPowerEU strategy — a set of measures to address some of these challenges, which were set out as the set of legislative proposals and guidance.

The ambitious package proposes both short- and long-term tools, including cooperation with foreign LNG suppliers, boosting the share of renewables and increasing energy savings.

One of the measures that is particularly interesting is the European Commission's proposal to sell the emission allowances that are held in Market Stability Reserve (MSR) and are not currently available on the market, to finance reforms and investments.

Such proposal draws the attention to one of the most important EU decarbonisation tools: the Emission Trading System (EU ETS).

The proposal comes amid the legislation works on Fit for 55 and discussion on how to revise the system.

With the current energy security challenges, it could be used to decarbonise EU industry and at the same time protect companies against price shocks. It is even more important due to fact that many stakeholders push for cancelling large part of allowances held in MSR, instead of using them to stabilise the market.

Rethinking EU ETS

The EU cannot do much on the energy supply side in the short-term. The investments in green technologies and cooperation with foreign partners on natural gas or green hydrogen deliveries are the right thing to do, but this will take time.

On the other hand, EU can reform its own EU ETS market, to make European industry more resilient to price shocks.

The main shortcomings of EU ETS design were highlighted by the price crisis. The Market Stability Reserve is designed to absorb the oversupply of the allowances from the market and release the allowances in case of scarcity.

However, the trigger mechanism is not based on the price of allowances but on the total number of allowances in circulation (TNAC).

This design has serious flaws: if the allowances are bought and simply held on the accounts of investors/companies they are still calculated as if they were in circulation, even though they are subject to a long term "buy and hold" strategies.

It means, that MSR does not react to the price shocks like the recent one, especially if it (incorrectly) assumes that the supply of allowances is about right. One of possible solutions is to add also price-triggered mechanism.

The other measure, that was designed specifically to protect EU against high energy prices — Article 29a of the EU ETS directive — should be amended too.

It is activated if for more than six consecutive months the price of allowances is more than 300 percent of the average price in the two preceding years.

It is enough to say that it has never been used so far (even during the recent EU ETS price spikes) and will most likely remain ineffective tool, if it is based on the current multipliers only — introducing a mechanism based on a specific price limit or softening the triggering thresholds would be more effective.

The reform of MSR combined with softening the triggers to use Article 29a mechanism would not only protect the European companies against price volatility and make the prices more predictable.

However, those measures should go hand in hand with increasing market transparency and rethinking the role of financial actors on the European carbon market.

Their strategies evolve from maintain liquidity to cause skyrocketing carbon prices for their sole benefit. The recent years showed how the EU ETS and especially MSR is vulnerable to speculative actions, therefore the co-legislators should address this problem in finding a right balance between the necessary market participation of financial intermediaries and financial benefit they can generate from the EU ETS market.

Otherwise, the skyrocketing energy prices won't disappear with high gas prices.

Conclusions

While the commission is (rightly) putting forward new initiatives to ensure EU's long-term energy security, it is also important to consider the reforms of existing tools and mechanisms and ETS reforms is just one of such examples. The necessary amendments in EU ETS directive and MSR decision are not a silver bullet, but definitely can be a quick remedy (or at least quicker than some of the proposed measures).

Given natural gas prices volatility, the more predictable EU ETS market will make it easier for utilities to plan their long-term green investments.

It is even more important, due to fact that massive investments in renewables are crucial to deliver EU's climate goals and get rid of Russian fossil fuels.

Author bio

Wojciech Dąbrowski is chief executive officer of the PGE Polska Grupa Energetyczna, after a 10 year career in the energy sector, dealing with central and local government, and the EU, and degrees in law and public adminsitration from Warsaw University.

Disclaimer

This article is sponsored by a third party. All opinions in this article reflect the views of the author and not of EUobserver.

MEPs raise ambition on EU carbon market reform

MEPs on the environment committee agreed on reform of the European carbon market — including expanding it to buildings and transport. They also want to extend the scope of the carbon border tax, and phase out free permits by 2030.

Magazine

Interview: 'Carbon tax' MEP with one eye on Mozambique

Dutch MEP Mohammed Chahim is rapporteur forthe proposed carbon tax on imported goods which is planned to come into force in 2026. It is one of the biggest and most complex legislative proposals Europe has ever drawn up.

Opinion

Is there a fatal flaw in EU's emissions trading scheme?

New research has discovered fundamental flaws in a key component of the European Union's flagship Emissions Trading System. The little-known 'Market Stability Reserve' fixes a problem of the past but amplifies future shocks and undermines market stability.

For China and EU, cooperation is our only right way forward

In a world of profound changes, we believe that healthy and stable China-EU relations, especially in the economic and trade realm, can help counter the uncertainty on the global economic stage, and are conducive to global development and prosperity.

Ensuring global food security: what China says and does

The problem did not pop up just this summer. The consequences of the climate crisis, compounded by the Covid-19 pandemic and the Russia-Ukraine conflict, have significantly driven up food prices, tipping millions of people into hunger, especially in developing countries.

EU, wake up! Don't leave West Balkans to Russia or China

Russia's attack on Ukraine and European values must remind us how important the enlargement process is, if properly conducted, as a motor for democracy, freedom, peace, the rule of law and prosperity, write six S&D MEPs.

Dialogue and action – Nordic cooperation and view on COP26

Nordic countries launched several initiatives at the COP26 climate conference which will have a real impact on the ground. Nordic and UK pension funds are to invest billions in clean energy and climate initiatives. Greenland has joined the Paris Agreement.

News in Brief

  1. Zelensky vows to 'target' Russian soldiers at nuclear plant
  2. Putin vows greater cooperation with North Korea and Taliban
  3. Hungarian judge slams Orbán's rule-of-law attacks
  4. Borrell condemns 'despicable' Rushdie attack
  5. Slow wind-farm approvals risk green goals, warns industry
  6. Increase in people crossing Channel to UK in 2022
  7. Swedish government to toughen gang-crime penalties
  8. Germany to help nationals cope with energy price spike

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. EFBWW – EFBH – FETBBConstruction workers can check wages and working conditions in 36 countries
  2. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic and Canadian ministers join forces to combat harmful content online
  3. European Centre for Press and Media FreedomEuropean Anti-SLAPP Conference 2022
  4. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic ministers write to EU about new food labelling
  5. Nordic Council of MinistersEmerging journalists from the Nordics and Canada report the facts of the climate crisis
  6. Council of the EUEU: new rules on corporate sustainability reporting

Latest News

  1. Germany needs to cut gas use by 20% to stave off winter crisis
  2. Europe's wildfire destruction set to hit new record
  3. How Putin and Erdoğan are making the West irrelevant
  4. Defying Russian bombs, Ukraine football starts 2022 season
  5. Sweden to extradite man wanted by Turkey
  6. EU must beware Beijing's new charm offensive
  7. Forest fire near Bordeaux forces over 10,000 to flee
  8. Estonia and Latvia sever China club ties

Join EUobserver

Support quality EU news

Join us