Sunday

30th Apr 2017

Analysis

Can Europe afford a Russia trade war?

  • (Photo: malyousif)

“We’ve known for more than 100 years that protectionism and trade barriers are very bad for your economy”.

So says Hosuk Lee-Makiyama, a trade lawyer and director of the European Centre for International Political Economy, a Brussels-based think tank. The evidence backs him up.

Dear EUobserver reader

Subscribe now for unrestricted access to EUobserver.

Sign up for 30 days' free trial, no obligation. Full subscription only 15 € / month or 150 € / year.

  1. Unlimited access on desktop and mobile
  2. All premium articles, analysis, commentary and investigations
  3. EUobserver archives

EUobserver is the only independent news media covering EU affairs in Brussels and all 28 member states.

♡ We value your support.

If you already have an account click here to login.

  • EU sanctions have banned some of Russia's top banks from buying long-term bonds (Photo: sberbank.ru)

But such considerations did not stop Brussels from effectively waging a trade war on Russia this month – its ban on bond sales to some Russian banks and on sales of high-end technology to Russian oil firms swiftly leading Moscow to imposing a ban on imports of EU food.

Since then, however, support for the EU’s stand is starting to fray at the edges as national leaders start to count the costs.

Hungarian prime minister Viktor Orban and his Slovakian counterpart Robert Fico have publicly criticised the EU sanctions. Orban remarked that the sanctions “cause more harm to us than the Russians”, before adding in typically strident fashion that “in politics, this is called shooting oneself in the foot”.

For its part, Poland has made a formal request that the EU take Russia before the Swiss-based World Trade Organisation (WTO) to overturn the food ban, while a number of governments are already working out how much compensation they will claim from Brussels for their farmers.

The question is whether Europe can actually afford to fight a trade war with Russia?

Lee-Makiyama says that “mutually assured destruction”, at least in economic terms, will be the result of the sanctions and that neither side can afford the measures to last more than six to nine months.

It is still difficult to make anything more than an educated guess at the economic effect of the confrontation, while EU officials stress that its farmers may be able to replace the lost market in Russia with buyers elsewhere,

But there is increasing evidence that the sanctions battle will cause a sizeable dent in Europe’s collective wallet.

Research published on Wednesday (20 August) by Benelux bank ING forecasts that the import ban could cost the EU €6.7 billion, wiping out 6 percent of the EU’s production and 0.04 percent of its GDP.

For its part, ING remarked that its calculations were “a conservative estimate of the economic damage that can be caused by the crisis in Ukraine.”

The uncertainty has clearly dampened confidence, particularly in Germany, whose export-led economy is most reliant on trade with Russia.

The ZEW think tank’s index of financial market confidence in Germany’s economy fell to its lowest level since December 2012 this month. It remarked that the collapse in confidence was “likely connected to the ongoing geopolitical tensions in the Ukraine and elsewhere”.

The same week, Eurostat revealed that the eurozone economy was already flat between April and June, before the sanctions, leading to the bloc’s growth forecasts for 2014 being cut to 1 percent.

Carsten Brzeski, an economist with ING, told EUobserver that, ultimately, the ban “could shave off some 0.2 percentage points from Eurozone growth”. He added that it is “very hard to take into account whether there are any negative spill-over effects or positive off-setting factors like more demand from other countries or repatriation of foreign investments”.

In the pre-financial crisis years, losing 0.2 percent would have been the economic equivalent of a wasp or jellyfish sting – painful, but not for long. But with the eurozone economy flat-lining it could prove to be the difference between meagre growth and a triple dip recession – of high importance politically and psychologically to the bloc.

ING also estimates that the ban could jeopardise 130,000 jobs at a time when the EU is struggling to reduce a high unemployment rate.

While the US, Canada, Norway, and Australia are also subject to identical Russian bans, their trade with Russia is a fraction of the €270 billion in goods and services which were traded between Russia and the EU in 2012.

With the EU already in relative decline compared to the US and China, not to mention emerging economies, it can ill-afford to carry another economic millstone.

But if the EU’s sluggish economy is ill-prepared for a prolonged trade war, Russia is in even weaker shape to cope.

Since the start of the year foreign investors have withdrawn around €60 billion from Russia. Meanwhile, its economy, which grew by 1.3 percent last year, is heading back into stagnation, forecast to grow by less than 0.5 percent in 2014.

Agriculture minister Nikolai Fyodorov told national television on Wednesday (August 20) that the ban would cost “hundreds of billions of rubles” in extra farming subsidies.

While not catastrophic, these snap-shots make it clear that the West’s sanctions are hurting Moscow and will continue to do so.

But for the moment, diplomacy trumps short-term economic interests.

The threats of a Russian invasion of Ukraine remain high. This factor, coupled with Russian leader Vladimir Putin’s continued support for pro-Moscow rebels in Ukraine, despite their being implicated in shooting down Malaysian airlines flight MH17, left the West with little alternative other than to step up its sanctions regime.

In the words of Lithuanian foreign minister Linas Linkevicius, whose country shares a border with Russia: “Better shoot yourself in the foot, than let yourself be shot in the head”.

Russia relaxes EU food ban, counts costs

Russia has said its ban on EU food imports will cost it “hundreds of billions of rubles”, while taking several items off the blacklist.

EU lodges new WTO protest against Russia

The EU lodged its fourth formal complaint against Russia to the World Trade Organisation (WTO) on Friday in the latest round of the trade battle between the two blocs.

EU demands WTO ruling on Russian trade tariffs

The European Commission accused Russia of breaking its trade commitments on Thursday, urging the World Trade Organisation to arbitrate on illegal import duties on a range of products.

News in Brief

  1. Vote of no confidence prepared against Spanish PM
  2. Syria to buy Russian anti-missile system
  3. Germany seeks partial burka ban
  4. Libya has no plan to stop migration flows
  5. EU has no evidence of NGO-smuggler collusion in Libya
  6. Poland gets 'final warning' on logging in ancient forest
  7. Commission gives Italy final warning on air pollution
  8. Romania and Slovenia taken to court over environment policies

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. European Healthy Lifestyle AllianceCharlotte Hornets' Nicolas Batum Tells Kids to "Eat Well, Drink Well, Move!"
  2. ECR GroupSyed Kamall: We Need a New, More Honest Relationship With Turkey
  3. Counter BalanceParliament Sends Strong Signal to the EIB: Time to Act on Climate Change
  4. ACCARisks and Opportunities of Blockchain and Shared Ledgers Technologies in Financial Services
  5. UNICEFRace Against Time to Save Millions of Lives in Yemen
  6. Nordic Council of MinistersDeveloping Independent Russian-Language Media in the Baltic Countries
  7. Swedish EnterprisesReform of the European Electricity Market: Lessons from the Nordics, Brussels 2 May
  8. Malta EU 2017Green Light Given for New EU Regulation to Bolster External Border Checks
  9. Counter BalanceCall for EU Commission to Withdraw Support of Trans-Adriatic Pipeline
  10. ACCAEconomic Confidence at Highest Since 2015
  11. European Federation of Allergy and Airways60%-90% of Your Life Is Spent Indoors. How Does Poor Indoor Air Quality Affect You?
  12. European Gaming and Betting AssociationCJEU Confirms Obligation for a Transparent Licensing Process

Latest News

  1. EU boasts unity on Brexit talks
  2. May’s election juggernaut
  3. EPP scolds Orban over university and NGO laws
  4. Oxford-Studie besorgt über 'Schrott' News in Frankreich
  5. Alte Freundschaft zwischen Le Pen und Putin
  6. EP chief faces questions after homophobic 'summit'
  7. EU signals Northern Ireland could join if united with Ireland
  8. One year later: EU right to open internet still virtual

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. Nordic Council of MinistersNordic Region and the US: A Time of Warlike Rhetoric and Militarisation?
  2. European Free AllianceEFA MEPs Vote in Favor of European Parliament's Brexit Mandate
  3. Mission of China to the EUXinhua Insight: China to Open up Like Never Before
  4. World VisionViolence Becomes New Normal for Syrian Children
  5. International Partnership for Human RightsTime to Turn the Tide and End Repression of Central Asia's Civil Society
  6. European Free AllianceAutonomia to Normalnosc - Poland Urged to Re-Grant Autonomy to Silesia
  7. UNICEFHitting Rock Bottom - How 2016 Became the Worst Year for #ChildrenofSyria
  8. Malta EU 2017Green Light Given for New EU Regulation to Bolster External Border Checks
  9. ACCAG20 Citizens Want 'Big Picture' Tax Policymaking, According to Global Survey
  10. Belgrade Security ForumCall for Papers: European Union as a Global Crisis Manager - Deadline 30 April
  11. European Gaming & Betting Association60 Years Rome Treaty – 60 Years Building an Internal Market
  12. Malta EU 2017New EU Rules to Prevent Terrorism and Give More Rights to Victims Approved